| Rev. William L. Strange | March 1, 1901-December 1, 1902 |
| Rev. John Kershaw | January 1902-September 11, 1904 |
| Rev. Clyde W. Greenlee | January 13, 1905-November 15, 1908 |
| Rev. Thomas Gilbert | February 1, 1909-December 25, 1910 |
| Rev. Henry Fiske Knight | July 1, 1911-January 3, 1917 |
| Rev. George McDonald | (Resigned to enter W. W. I) |
April 29, 1917-July 15, 1917 |
| Rev. J. E. Sears | November 14, 1917-January 1, 1919 |
| Rev. Clayton S. Rice | May 11, 1919-April 1923 |
| Rev. William D. Price | May 6, 1923-0ctober 12, 1924 |
| Rev. Aaron I. Ferch | January 1, 1925-June 30, 1926 |
| Rev. Clayton Judy | September 1, 1926-June 30, 1930 |
| Rev. Charles D. Gaffney | August 1, 1930-February 2, 1936 |
| Rev. William A. Roberts | January 1, 1937-September 1939 |
| Rev. Virgil C. Carlson | June 16, 1940-March 1943 |
| John Anderson, interim Dean of Religion, Caldwell, Idaho |
1944 |
| Rev. Kenneth Ubbelohde | 1945, November 2, 1947 |
| Charles Jackle--Student Minister | June 6, 1948-Sept. 5, 1948 |
| Rev. J. Edwin Elder | September 5, 1948-1951 |
| Rev. I. N. Stanley-interim | 1951-1952 |
| Rev. John Towery | August 1952-July 8, 1956 |
| Rev. Leonard C. Fuqua | October 10,1956-December 1956 |
| Rev. Macon | December 16, 1956-1957 |
| Rev. Robert Allen | March 10, 1957-May 31, 1959 |
| Rev. Don Mills-pastor-at-large | December 4, 1960-February 1961 |
| Rev. James Wood | March 1, 1961-July 1, 1962 |
| Rev. Stanley Banks | September 1962-August 18, 1963 |
| Rev. Richard England | September 1, 1963-June 1, 1968 |
| Robert Fletcher-interim | June 1, 1968-December 29, 1968 |
| Rev. Stanley Banks-interim | January 1, 1969-May 1, 1969 |
| Rev. Earl Traughber | May 1, 1969-May 1, 1988 |
| Rev. Doris Dunn | April 1988-August 15, 1992 |
| Rev. Susan L. Howe-interim | Sept. 1, 1992-Decmeber 18, 1992 |
| Rev. Susan L. Howe | December 18, 1992 |
