Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!
Play games in Angelfire Arcade
Lycos Music: Tunes, news, and more!
Lycos Angelfire Logo
Free Homepages | Free E-Mail
Shop | Chat | MP3
Search the Web:

Due to the sensitivity of current legal proceedings to the surveys proposed by this project, I will no longer be distributing a survey to residents of Musqueam Park.

The original project proposed here depended in large part upon data to be collected through surveying Musqueam Park residents. Since surveying is no longer considered an option, I will be shifting the focus of the project to make use of data from the public domain. The new topic will likely relate to the development of ‘finder’s-fee’ type premiums in both Musqueam Park and for other long-term lease properties in Vancouver.


Leasing Discounts in Musqueam and Salish Park, 1980-1998

Southwest Point Grey is currently home to a heated battle between a group of leaseholders and the Musqueam nation, lessors of the land on which most of the homeowners built. In 1965, the Musqueam nation offered for lease at an average annual rent of approximately $400 per lot. Lots in the subdivision were quite attractive; private, surrounded by greenspace, 10,000+ square feet in area. During the subsequent 30 years, property values appreciated dramatically in Musqueam Park and adjacent areas, in part due to the luxurious homes built by the folks who leased the land. 

As part of a clause included in the original leasing agreements, in 1995 the Musqueam nation adjusted annual leasing amounts to more accurately reflecting the market values of the property. In most cases this involved an increase of 5000% or more.  Originally pegging the new lease amounts at an average of $38,000 annually, the Musqueam Nation was directed by judicial decision first to offer the leases at an average of $10,000 per annum, but, after appeal, at an average of $22,400. Needless to say, leaseholders in the Musqueam Park were particularly agitated by this turn of events.  Upon the initial judicial decision setting rents at $10,000 most leaseholders were willing to meet the increased obligation.  With that amount overturned through appeal, the vast majority of the leaseholders refused to pay.  To date, 2 households of 75 have paid their obligations.  The Musqueam band, with support from both federal and provincial authorities, issued eviction notices with an Oct. 26, 1999, deadline for full payment of outstanding accounts. 

In the latest turn of events, after a series of blustery legal moves from both parties, the Musqeuam Leaseholders Association filed a writ with the Supreme Court of Canada, seeking compensation for alleged conspiracy between the Musqueam Band and federal and provincial authorities. We are currently awaiting the decision, anticipated to be available in late August 2000.

 
 

The following working paper is the internet version of an ongoing project, posted in December 1999. While it is informative as an introduction to the situation, those seeking a more rigorous discussion of discount behaviour in Musqueam and Salish Park may download the April 2000 final draft by clicking on the link below.

Working Paper

April 2000 Final Draft

 

  • A map of the area in question
  • Answers to

    frequently asked questions

    .
  •  
     

    Related Links:

    Links of Further Interest
    Research Links
    Bill's Aboriginal Links City of Vancouver Archives
    • includes links to land claims, treaty negotiations, Department of Indian Affairs
    • search the Vancouver archives for Musqueam Park material at the provincial and municipal levels
    • enter "Musqueam"
    Constitutional History of Canada City of Vancouver Homepage
    • chronological links to constitutional acts, some very good legal background to the BC treaty process
    • search the city's database for related material 1991-1999
    Comparison of Musqueam and False Creek Lease Terms Indian Act
    Crown Aboriginal Rights Policy Framework Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development
    Letters from Mike Scott, MP to Minister of Indian and Northern Affairs, Jane Stewart Guerin vs. Queen
    • summary of breach of trust case in which federal government badly mishandled trusteeship of Musqueam Park leases
     
     

    Any and all constructive feedback will be greatly appreciated. Contact me through my home page.