The conspiracists are so focused on claims that NASA falsified the
lunar photos that they don't realize they too can be suspected of
falsifying evidence.
One conspiracist web site shows the following two photos. The one
on the top, it argues, is genuine, while the one on the bottom is
alleged to be a forgery. The photo is of Apollo 12 astronaut Al Bean
taken by commander Pete Conrad. Conspiracists allege that a third
astronaut is visible in Bean's visor in the top photo, and was
airbrushed out in the bottom photo.
Here is an enlargement of the visor area in the image containing
the "extra" astronaut.
Near the center of the visor is the reflection of Pete Conrad, who is
taking the picture. The reflection near the left edge is of an unknown
astronaut, whom conspiracists say NASA had to remove from the photo to
maintain that there were only two astronauts on the lunar surface.
I have several problems with this explanation.
First, the visor is almost perfectly spherical. I've seen and held
many of these visors. A spherical reflector highly distorts images
around the edges. That's why you can see very distorted reflections of
Bean's right arm holding a specimen container, and Bean's chest camera
at the bottom of the visor. Our mystery astronaut's reflection is
actually farther toward the edge than these images, yet it's as well
shaped as Conrad's reflection in the center. It's not distorted at
all.
Second, the lighting is wrong. Conrad's shadow falls back behind
him, and Bean is backlit. The highlight on Bean's visor is at the very
edge. The highlight on Conrad's visor is near it's center. All the
shadows in the image fall behind. Thus the light source is above and
behind Bean. Yet the mystery astronaut is also backlit. His lighting
doesn't match his shadow.
Third, the mystery astronaut is not very much of a mystery. The
object at the mystery man's feet is the magnetometer from the ALSEP
experiments. Below is part of the the NASA photo of Al Bean deploying
the magnetometer earlier in the mission.
And here is that same picture, cropped and converted to black and
white, shown side by side with the close-up of the allegedly original
photo.
There is no question in my mind that the "extra" astronaut was
copied from the ALSEP photo and pasted into the Bean photo in order to
make it look like there are three astronauts. The only ones who would
stand to gain from a photo containing three astronauts are the
conspiracists, making it quite obvious who doctored this photo.
See here for additional discussion of the alleged inconsistencies
of this photo.
|