| A. Luelling | Dec. 8, 1876 - Dec. 10, 1877 |
| Charles True Tozier | Dec. 10, 1877 - Dec. 3, 1878 |
| Alvin Montgomery Collins | Dec. 3, 1878 - Dec. 2, 1879 |
| William D. Pittenger | Dec. 2, 1879 - Dec. 18, 1880 |
| Phineas M. Dennis | Dec. 18, 1880 - Jan. 2, 1882 |
| Rodolph Crandall | Jan. 2, 1882 - Dec. 13, 1882 |
| Thomas H. Tongue | Dec. 13, 1882 - Dec. 10, 1883 |
| Alvin Montgomery Collins | Dec. 10, 1883 - Dec. 7, 1884 |
| Rodolph Crandall | Dec. 7, 1884 - Dec. 14, 1885 |
| William Davenport Hare | Dec. 14, 1885 - Dec. 13, 1886 |
| Thomas H. Tongue | Dec. 13, 1886 - Dec. 9, 1887 |
| Francis Alonzo Bailey | Dec. 9, 1887 - Dec. 3, 1888 |
| Samuel Towers Linklater | Dec. 3, 1888 - Dec. 2, 1889 |
| Samuel Bruce Huston | Dec. 2, 1889 - Dec. 5, 1890 |
| Francis Alonzo Bailey | Dec. 5, 1890 - Dec. 11, 1891 |
| Francis Alonzo Bailey | Dec. 11, 1891 - Dec. 6, 1892 |
| J. D. Merryman | Dec. 6, 1892 - Dec. 5, 1893 |
| Joseph Coulson Hare | Dec. 5, 1893 - Dec. 4, 1894 |
| Samuel Bruce Huston | Dec. 4, 1894 - Dec. 5, 1895 |
| Richard Bennett Goodin | Dec. 5, 1895 - Dec. 8, 1896 |
| William Nathan Barrett | Dec. 8, 1896 - Dec. 5, 1899 |
| George Herbert Wilcox | Dec. 5, 1899 - Dec. 4, 1900 |
| Francis Alonzo Bailey | Dec. 4, 1900 - Dec. 2, 1902 |
| William Nathan Barrett | Dec. 2, 1902 - Dec. 15, 1903 |
| Benjamin Peyton Cornelius | Dec. 15, 1903 - Dec. 4, 1906 |
| John Dennis | Dec. 4, 1906 - Dec. 1, 1908 |
| John Wesley Connell | Dec. 1, 1908 - Dec. 7, 1909 |
| Augustus B. Bailey | Dec. 7, 1909 - Dec. 6, 1910 |
| Harry T. Bagley | Dec. 6, 1910 - Jan. 5, 1915 |
| William Nathan Barrett | Jan. 5, 1915 - Jan. 2, 1917 |
| John Milton Wall | Jan. 2, 1917 - Jan. 4, 1921 |
| Arthur Clay Shute | Jan. 4, 1921 - Feb. 5, 1924 |
| J. B. Trullinger | Feb. 5, 1924 - Jan. 6, 1925 |
| Mason P. Cady | Jan. 6, 1925 - Jan. 2, 1929 |
| Orange Phelps | Jan. 2, 1929 - Jan. 2, 1935 |
| John Henry “Jack” Garrett | Jan. 2, 1935 - Jan. 3, 1939 |
| Hugh S. Rogers | Jan. 3, 1939 - Apr. 20, 1945 |
| E. A. Griffith | Apr. 27, 1945 - Jan. 4, 1949 |
| Harry Martin Seabold | Jan. 4, 1949 - Jan. 2, 1951 |
| Leslie J. Alter | Jan. 2, 1951 - Jan. 2, 1957 |
| S. Howard Davis | Jan. 2, 1957 - Jan. 2, 1959 |
| S. Howard Davis | Jan. 2, 1959 - Jan. 3, 1963 |
| Lloyd T. Anderson | Jan. 3, 1963 - Jan. 3, 1967 |
| Lloyd T. Anderson | Jan. 3, 1967 - Jan. 7, 1969 |
| Harold R. Ruecker | Jan. 7, 1969 - Jan. 5, 1971 |
| Harold R. Ruecker | Jan. 5, 1971 - Jan. 2, 1973 |
| Miller M. Duris | Jan. 2, 1973 - Jan. 1977 |
| Larry Johnson | Jan. 1977 - 1981 |
| Jim Darr | 1981 - 1985 |
| Shirley Huffman | 1985 - 1993 |
| Gordon Faber | 1993 - Jan. 2, 2001 |
| Tom Hughes | Jan. 2, 2001 - Jan. 6, 2009 |
| Jerry W. Willey | Jan. 6, 2009 - |
