2004-2005 1st-Team All Shore Awards
| Forward | Paul Daley | Toms River North | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forward | James van Riemsdyk | Christian Brothers Academy | |
| Forward | Tom Chiapetta | Christian Brothers Academy | |
| Defense | Eric Castellazzo | Christian Brothers Academy | |
| Defense | Jim Hall | Middletown North | |
| Goalie | Tony Baptist | Red Bank Catholic |
2004-2005 2nd-Team All Shore Awards
| Forward | Mike Foley | Middletown North |
|---|---|---|
| Forward | Jerry Malanga | Monsignor Donovan |
| Forward | Mark Schofield | Christian Brothers Academy |
| Defense | Brian Shubsda | Toms River North |
| Defense | John Gillen | Christian Brothers Academy |
| Goalie | Ryan DeCeuster | Christian Brothers Academy |
2004-2005 3rd-Team All Shore Awards
| Forward | Alex Cohen | Toms River North |
|---|---|---|
| Forward | Brendan Keelen | Middletown South |
| Forward | Nick Staggard | Red Bank Catholic |
| Defense | Dan Moser | Toms River North |
| Defense | Matt Siuzdak | Red Bank Catholic |
| Goalie | Britton Spark | Monsignor Donovan |