Anya's Love Connections

• Olaf the Troll (boyfriend in predemon life)- Olaf and Anya existed before Anya was a demon, this was when she was a mortal a few thousand years ago and Olaf wasn't a troll. Things didn't go well between them and Olaf was made into a troll and sent to live in the land of trolls, courtesy on a vengeful Anya when he cheated on her.
• Xander Harris (was engaged)- When Anya became a mortal after her powers were taken away the first mortal male she liked was Xander and their first date was the Prom. It was obvious from the beginning that the strange feelings for Xander, which Anya was feeling, were very real. But when she asked Xander if he'd go away with her and he declined things seemed over between them, until she made a surprise return, and things kicked off from there. The couple going from strength to strength. And now they are engaged after Xander proposed to her in the basement of The Magic Box. But the wedding didn't go ahead. Xander was told tall tales of what the future could hold, and brought out some fears, which he already had, so he parted from the heart broken Anya who went to D'Hoffryn for comfort. D'Hoffryn restored her powers and she tried to grant a wish for herself to get vengeance on Xander, but she couldn't go through with it.