A St. Louis jewelry salesman who sold
Penthouse Magazine a video of a topless sunbather misidentified
as Anna Kournikova testified on Tuesday he mistook the woman
for the tennis star because of the diameter of her nipples.
Frank Ramaesiri, the salesman, testified at a hearing to
determine whether Penthouse will be forced to recall unsold
issues of June magazine which carries about a dozen photos of
the sunbather, who is actually Judith Soltesz-Benetton, the
daughter-in-law of Italian fashion designer Luciano Benetton.
Last week Penthouse, which is owned by financially troubled
General Media Communications, acknowledged its mistake and
issued a public apology. However both women are pursuing cases
against the magazine, whose circulation has dropped to about
650,000 a month from almost 5 million.
Auditors for General Media said in the company's annual
report that it may be taken over by its trustee, Bank of New
York, if it cannot make its debt payments.
Tuesday's hearing stemmed from Soltesz-Benetton's lawsuit
filed in Manhattan federal court. Last week the judge in the
case stopped Penthouse from posting the photos on the Internet
and he must now rule on whether Penthouse should have its
distributor recall the June issue.
The sale date of the issue, whose cover carried the
headline "Exclusive Anna Kournikova Caught Close Up on Nude
Beach," was April 30 and it is unclear how many issues are
already in the hands of readers or on sale at retailers.
Plaintiff's lawyer Judd Burstein said that although
Kournikova began questioning the validity of the photographs as
early as April 24 and denied they were of her on April 26
Penthouse did nothing to stop distribution. He alleged this was
done to boost sales and avoid a financial disaster.
Penthouse founder Bob Guccione acknowleged on the stand
that while the magazine can try to get remaining issues back
from wholesalers, it has no access to retailers.
Although a recall at this point may have little financial
impact on Penthouse, the magazine could be hit with monetary
damages from the Soltesz-Benetton case in New York or
Kournikova's lawsuit in California.
Soltesz-Benetton, 28, alleged in her lawsuit that the video
was taken while she was sunbathing topless in Miami about seven
years ago. She alleged the unauthorized publication of the
photos violated her privacy and that the photos were used for
advertising purposes without her consent.
The plaintiff contended the article accompanying the photos
was not a real news story but an advertisement aimed at selling
the video from which the pictures were taken.
The suit, which seeks more than $10 million in damages,
argued that the magazine rushed to run the pictures without
confirming they were actually of Kournikova.
Penthouse argued it tried to verify the pictures and that
they were used to illustrate a legitimate news article.
Guccione testified that he spent five or six days comparing
the video to Internet photos of Kournikova. Although Burstein
seemed incredulous his client could be mistaken for Kournikova,
Guccione maintained there were similarities in their faces, rib
cages and how they extended their pinkies.
The article's author Annette Witheridge testified she had
been asked by Penthouse to write an article to accompany the
photos. She said she had felt the pictures were more important
than the words and that she had been told by Penthouse not to
contact Kournikova.
She said Kournikova's quotes in the article -- including
one in which the tennis diva reportedly praised her own breasts
-- all came from the Internet or published sources and that she
had not checked to confirm the accuracy of the quotes.
Ramaesiri, who is not a professional photographer,
testified that he had videotaped some topless sunbathers
several years ago. When he was reviewing the tape earlier this
year, he saw a woman he thought was Kournikova and contacted
Penthouse. "I couldn't believe it, it was a match," he
testified.
Burstein asked Ramaesiri what had led him to the
conclusion the woman was Kournikova. The salesman replied there
were several reasons including that the sunbather looked
Russian, appeared to be seeking privacy and because of the size
of her nipples.
He said that while he had never seen Kournikova at a
tournament, he had seen a photo of her on the Internet in which
her tennis dress was soaked with sweat, revealing the shape of
her nipples. "They were pretty evident ... the diameter matched
what we had on film," he said.
Ramaesiri said Penthouse flew him to New York where he met
with Guccione. He said Penthouse asked him if the video was
time stamped. When he said it was not, Ramaesiri said the
magazine did not ask for further proof as to when the video was
shot. He said his payment included Super Bowl tickets.
The salesman, wiping tears from his eyes, called himself an
"idiot" and apologized to the women and Guccione in court.
"It was unfathomable that it wasn't Anna Kournikova," he
said. "Until I saw Ms. Benetton I though it was Ms. Kournikova.
I'm probably the last to know. I'm very sorry I made a
mistake."