The Second Corinthian Epistle
Rex Banks
Lesson 14
Authorship
(1)
Paul (1:1; 10:1). On Paul the apostle, see our Paul's
Epistles, Introducing Paul.
(2)
Paul includes “Timothy our
brother” in the salutation. “(He) is with Paul, having been sent on to
“Timothy had aided in the evangelization of
In my view, if Timothy did contribute
in some way to the writing of 2 Corinthians, this would not in any way,
undermine apostolic authority or raise doubts about the divine authorship of
this book.
(3)
In this
context, what are we to make of the use of the first person plural and first
person singular in the Pauline Epistles?
Daniel B. Webster points out that “In many situations in the NT especially in the epistles, the use of we is not always clear.” He explains:
“Does the author mean to include his
associates (or co-authors), or his audience, or is this simply an editorial way of referring to himself? The use of the first person plural to refer
only to the author is known as the editorial ‘we’ (or
epistolary plural); the use of the first
person plural to refer to the author and his associates as distinct from the
audience is called exclusive ‘we’;
and the use of the first person plural to refer to both author(s) and his
reader(s) is called the inclusive ‘we’” (Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics).
In his commentary
on 2 Corinthians, Murray J. Harris has:
“Whenever Paul uses a first-person plural
pronoun or verb (eg … [“our”] in v. 3; parakalouvmeqa [parakaloumetha, “the comfort we ...
received”] in v. 4), the referent(s) may be (1) a plural subject made clear in
the context, (2) Paul himself (‘epistolary plural’), (3) Paul and his
co-workers mentioned in the salutation or his amanuensis (exclusive ‘we’), (4)
Paul and his addressees (inclusive ‘we’), (5) Jews, (6) all Christians, or (7)
men in general. That Paul can on
occasion oscillate from singular to plural, apparently without intending a
distinction to be drawn, is shown by the gravfomen (graphomen, ‘we write’), ejlpivzw (elpizo,
‘I hope’), and hJma’” (hemas, ‘us’) of vv. 13, 14 and the singulars
of vv. 15-17” (Expositors Bible Commentary).
(4) The following points are worth noting:
·
It is noticeable that in the
first nine chapters of 2 Corinthians, the first person plural
occurs more frequently than the first person singular. From
·
From 10:1 Paul tends to use the
first person singular more frequently than the first person plural. What’s more “Second Corinthians 10-13
includes several instances of what many regard as epistolary plurals,
especially since they are sprinkled among the more frequent first person
singulars” (Daniel B Webster, Greek Grammar Beyond the
Basics). Webster cites
“One possible reason for the use of the
epistolary plural throughout these chapters is that Paul, being obviously
self-conscious about displaying the credentials of his apostleship under the
present circumstances , occasionally reverts to the plural out of modesty”
(ibid).
If this is the case, this may
suggest that in the earlier chapters, although Paul sometimes uses the first
person plural to speak of believers in general (eg
3:18; 5:1-10), he also uses it to indicate that Timothy joins him in
speaking to the brethren at Corinth. Again this would not, in any way undermine
apostolic authority or raise doubts about the divine authorship of this book.
External
evidence
“The internal evidence of 2 Corinthians
vividly attests its genuineness… External
evidence, while not so clear as in the case of 1 Corinthians, yet is
unambiguous in establishing the existence and the use of the letter, especially
in the second century. Although Clement
of Rome is silent, the epistle is quoted by Polycarp. It is referred to in the epistle of Diognetus 2 Cor 5:12. It is sufficiently corroborated by Ireneaus,
Theophilus, Athenagoras, Tertullian, and Clement of Alexandria” (Ungers
Bible Dictionary).
Examples:
Ignatius of
“Be not deceived with strange doctrines, ‘nor
give heed to fables and endless genealogies,’ and things in which the Jews make
their boast. Old things are passed away: behold, all things have become new” (2 Cor
Polycarp (69-155
AD)
“And let the presbyters be compassionate and
merciful to all, bringing back those that wander, visiting all the sick, and
not neglecting the widow, the orphan, or the poor, but always “providing for
that which is becoming in the sight of God and man;” (2 Cor. 8:31 – Rex)… (And) “we must all
appear at the judgment-seat of Christ, and must every one give an account of
himself” (2 Cor
Clement of
“But us the Word enjoins ‘to look not on the
things that are seen, but the things that are not seen; for the things that are
seen are temporal, but the things that are not seen are eternal’” (2 Cor 4:18 -
Rex) (Paedagogus 3.2).
Composition:
Date, Place and Circumstances
(1)
In our introduction to 1
Corinthians we said that Paul wrote from
(2)
This was Paul’s second
letter to the brethren at
(3) However, it is difficult to piece together details of Paul’s movements at this point. What we do know is this:
·
When Paul writes 2 Corinthians
he refers to his having been present with the Corinthians “the second time” (2
Cor 13:2) and says that when he visits them next it will be for “the third
time” (2 Cor
· In 2 Corinthians Paul makes reference to a letter which he had written the Corinthians “with many tears” (2 Cor 2:3-4) and which had caused the Corinthians great sorrow (2 Cor 7:8 ff).
Ø
Some take this as a reference
to what we today know as I Corinthians. This may be the case and this position does
enjoy good support. However, Paul seems
to suggest that the tearful letter dealt mainly with a wrongdoer and
the need to discipline him (2 Cor 2:3-9).
Although 1 Corinthians does deal with the case of the immoral man (1 Cor
5), this is not the letter’s primary thrust.
Moreover, Paul speaks of his personally forgiving the wrongdoer
(2 Cor
Ø Some think that this tearful letter is preserved in 2 Cor
10-13, arguing that in this section of the letter Paul goes on the attack and
trounces his opponents. They argue that
the negative tone of chapters 10-13 is quite different from the joyful,
positive tone of chapters 1-9. According
to this view, the tearful letter was somehow appended to 2 Corinthians
(chapters 10-13) at an early date. However
there is no manuscript support for this theory, and there is no mention in
chapters 10-13 of the need to discipline the wrongdoer, yet this was evidently
the primary focus of the tearful letter. What’s more, 12:18 tells us
that Titus had paid at least one visit to Corinth in connection with the
collection and thus this verse in this section (chapters 10-13) follows
2 Cor 8:6, 16-19. Finally, we must not
exaggerate the differences between chapters 1-9 and 10-13, because as we will
see later, chapters 1-9 also demonstrate that despite Titus’ positive
report there are still real difficulties in the church at
Other suggestions have been made but in my view the tearful letter is neither 1 Corinthians nor an appendage to 2 Corinthians, but instead, a separate communication and thus we have:
Ø Letter 1 referred to in 1 Cor 5:9.
Ø Letter 2 which we know as 1 Corinthians.
Ø Letter 3 written “with many tears” (2 Cor 2:3).
Ø Letter 4 which we know as 2 Corinthians.
Our comments below reflect this position.
(4) The following is a likely reconstruction of the events of this period:
·
Somehow Paul learned that the
situation at
·
Paul abandons his previous
plans and travels to
·
Paul writes his “many tears”
letter (2 Cor 2:3, 4) - a strongly-worded missive which was carried to
·
Titus brought a report from
(5) Again there has never been any serious doubt that Paul wrote this letter and it is quoted by Polycarp, Ireneaus, Clement of Alexandria and Tertullian.
Addressees
The First Corinthian epistle is addressed to “the
Purpose, Theme
and Characteristics
(Since 2 Corinthians contains a great deal of
information about Paul’s relationship and interaction with the church at
(1) Of all the Pauline epistles, 2 Corinthians is the most personal, intimate and emotional. It contains references to a whole host of incidents and personal details in Paul’s life and it is by far the most autobiographical of all the apostle’s writings. It is the product of deep emotion and stress. On the one hand Paul is immensely relieved to hear that his tearful letter has produced a repentant spirit in many, but he is distressed and angered by the presence opponents who are seeking to undermine his authority. Charles R Erdman captures the spirit of the letter well:
“Here, as plainly as in his other epistles, great fundamental doctrines
are discerned... However, this letter is
less doctrinal than any of the other epistles; with the exception of
Philemon... We look into (Paul’s) heart.
We see his motives, his anguish, his
joys, his hopes, his wounded feelings, his ardent love... The style is broken, involved, and at times
obscure. The impetuosity of the thought
moves from point to point with a rapidity which makes it hard to grasp the
sequence and connection... The epistle
is one of many moods. ‘Joy and
heaviness, anxiety and hope, trust and resentment, anger and love’ follow one
another with bewildering abruptness. It
presents a conflict of feelings in which gratitude and indignation, gladness
and grief, are struggling for the mastery. Mingled severity and tenderness, reproof and
praise, command and exhortation, suffering and rejoicing, humiliation and
exaltation are set forth in terms unparalleled in all the literature of the
world” (The
Second Epistle of Paul to the Corinthians).
(2)
The
distinctive tone of chapters 1 to 7 is set by the words rejoice and joy (2:3;
·
Likely
in his tearful letter Paul has demanded that the Corinthians
demonstrate their love and support for him by disciplining the offender, and
they have done so. Paul speaks of the
“punishment” inflicted by “the majority” (2 Cor 2:5-6) but then goes on to warn
these brethren that having inflicted sufficient punishment they must now
“forgive and comfort him, lest somehow such a one be overwhelmed by excessive
sorrow” (2 Cor 2:7).
·
Paul’s
instructions in this matter had (in part) been to
put their obedience to the test (2 Cor 2:9) and now this obedience is to be demonstrated by willingness
to forgive the offender as Paul had done (2 Cor 2:10).
·
Paul
informs the Corinthians that he had been greatly comforted by Titus’ report of
their “longing...mourning (and) zeal” for him (2 Cor 7:7). He had temporarily regretted the sorrow that
his letter had caused them (2 Cor 7:8) but rejoiced that this sorrow had lead
to repentance leading to salvation (2 Cor
Thus joy and comfort in the midst of
adversity is a dominant theme in chapters 1-7. In one beautiful passage (
(3)
But
all is not well at
·
From
Paul’s response we can get some idea of the charges which his enemies have
brought against him, and among them we find the following:
Paul’s failure
to visit
Paul responds
that he was not “vacillating” in this matter (2 Cor
Paul has no proof of
his authority or commission since he lacks letters of commendation
(Likely Paul’s
opponents claimed to possess such letters, perhaps from
Paul’s letters are “weighty and strong” but
in person he “unimpressive” and his speech is “contemptible” (2 Cor
Paul answers
that “what we are in word by letters when absent, such persons we are also in
deed when present “(2 Cor
Paul does
not accept support because he knows himself that he is not a true apostle
deserving of such support
Paul responds
that support from brethren elsewhere enabled him to preach the gospel at
Despite his
refusal to accept support Paul has fleeced the Corinthians in some way perhaps by
way of his agents
Paul appeals
to his record: “Certainly I have not
taken advantage of you through any of those whom I have sent to you have I?” (2 Cor
Paul does not have what it takes to carry out his threats of
discipline
Paul’s
response: “I say in advance to those who
have sinned in the past and to all the rest as well, that if I come again, I
will not spare anyone” (2 Cor 13:2).
Other matters
Various other
statements by Paul in this epistle may well have been by way of response to the
claims of his adversaries. It is by way
of response to his opponents’ accusations that Paul also speaks of such things
as his having been “caught up to the third heaven” (2 Cor 12:1 ff) and of his labours, imprisonments, beatings etc in the service of Christ (2 Cor
·
Who
were these opponents? Carson et al point out that “there is no evidence whatsoever that at the time of
writing 1 Corinthians the apostle Paul was facing a church that had been taken
over by leaders from the outside. By the time of 2 Corinthians 10-13, that has
certainly happened.” It seems apparent
that these opponents of Paul are Jews claiming to possess letters of
commendation from
“These
intruders were not Judaizers in the narrower sense;
they did not try to impose legal observances on gentile believers. They simply conceived it as their mission to
impose the authority of the mother church over the Christian world.”
In Paul’s view
they are “false apostles,” “deceitful workers” (2 Cor
(4)
From
A Triumphant
ministry (
The
spread of the gospel is likened to a Roman triumphus or victory procession in which a victorious general leads his captives
through the streets while the scent of incense, sacrifices etc fill the
air. God is pictured as the triumphant
general “who always leads us in His triumph” (
A Ministry with
credentials (3:1-2)
Christian lives are the fruits of this
ministry.
A Glorious
ministry (3:4-18)
Although
the ministry of Moses was indeed glorious the gospel of Christ is of surpassing
glory.
A ministry accomplished by God’s power
Paul
insists that “our adequacy is from
God” (3:8) and explains that “we have this treasure in earthen vessels, so that
the surpassing greatness of the power will be of God and not from ourselves”
(4:7).
In fact, “all these things are
from God who reconciled us to Himself through Christ and gave us the ministry
of reconciliation” (
An honest
ministry (4:1-6)
Not
characterized by “shame,” “craftiness” or adulteration of the truth (4:2). If the gospel is not recognised as truth by
some it is because Satan “the god of this world has blinded...their minds”
(4:4).
A ministry
characterized by suffering and also by hope (4:7-
We are
“afflicted in every way” says Paul (4:8) but sustained by hope (“knowing that
He who raised the Lord Jesus will raise us also with Jesus...” -
A ministry
motivated by respect for God (
“Therefore
knowing the fear of the Lord we persuade men...” (
A ministry of
reconciliation (
Reconciliation
to God is man’s great need and the gospel is all about “God...in Christ
reconciling the world to Himself” (
A ministry which involves accepting hardships
that others might be blessed (6:3-10)
This
impressive portrait of the role of ministry under the new covenant is not
merely an academic discourse. It is an
autobiographical note from one who devoted his whole life to the work to which
the Lord had called him.
(5)
Chapters
8 and 9 concern the collection for the saints at
The example of
the Macedonians (8:1-5)
Despite “a great deal of affliction” and “deep poverty,” they gave
joyfully, liberally (8:2), “beyond their ability” and “of their own accord”
(8:3). Having given themselves to the Lord and His
cause (8:5), they regarded it as an honour to participate in this work of
benevolence (8:4). Encouraged by this,
Paul makes arrangements for the Corinthians to complete their collection (8:6).
The example of Christ
“…though He was rich yet for your sake He became poor” (8:9).
The need to put intentions into practice
They were “the first to begin a year ago” and now they
needed to “finish (lit) the doing” (
God’s
expectations
“...according
to what a man has, not according to what he does not have” (8.12).
The law of sowing and reaping
To sow
sparingly is to reap sparingly and to sow abundantly is to reap abundantly
(9:6-11). The cheerful giver is loved by
God (2 Cor 9:7).
The fact that God’s glory will be promoted;
that thanksgivings will be offered to Him for this benevolent work; that the
recipients of the blessing will intercede for the Corinthians in prayer; that the Jerusalem saints will feel warmly
disposed to their benefactors (8:12-15).
Chapters 8 and
9 constitute “a complete summary of the motives and methods of church support
and of church benevolences” (Erdman) - we have touched the hem.
This most
personal of all the Pauline epistles gives a deep insight into the character
and personal history of Paul the great apostle of Christ.
Brief Outline
(1) Paul Explains His Conduct and Ministry (2 Cor 1:1-7:16).
Salutation (2 Cor 1:1-11).
Explanation of Paul’s Conduct (2 Cor
The Nature the Apostolic Ministry (2 Cor
Paul’s Appeal to the
Corinthians (2 Cor
Meeting Titus in
(2)
Exhortation to Give: Collection
for the Believers in
(3) Defence of Apostolic Authority (2 Cor 10:1-13:10).
(4)
Final Exhortation and Greetings
(2 Cor