Bill `Shakespeare in Love' as inspired romantic comedy
By Lawrence Toppman
A superb film script, like a great athlete, makes everyone on a team play at the
top of his game.
A director of modest gifts shows fresh insight into his craft. A once-bland hero
commands the screen, while a once-dull leading lady glows like marble by
moonlight.
All this happens in ``Shakespeare in Love,'' an exhilarating romantic comedy
that brings the Elizabethan era to bawdy, bustling life and turns the world's
most venerated writer into a very human being. It also exalts the power of
theater -- still the world's most potent art when written and performed by
masters -- to change our minds, hearts, even our lives.
Marc Norman (who wrote the initial draft) and dazzling playwright Tom Stoppard
(who rewrote it years later) are the engineers behind this remarkable machine.
Like their title character, they can cram almost every type of emotion into two
hours' traffic on screen yet dovetail them neatly.
The time is 1593. The 29-year-old bard (Joseph Fiennes) has writer's block, and
for good reason: Seedy impresario Philip Henslowe (Geoffrey Rush) demands a
comedy called ``Romeo and Ethel, the Pirate's Daughter.'' Shakespeare wants to
write a play as solemn as Christopher Marlowe's ``Doctor Faustus,'' but he
satisfies his producer instead of his muse.
At auditions for ``Romeo,'' he's drawn to actor ``Thomas Kent'' -- really Viola
de Lesseps (Gwyneth Paltrow), a theater-struck lass who, like all women then, is
prohibited from appearing on stage.
``Kent,'' fearful of discovery, runs home; Shakespeare follows and learns her
identity. Soon he earns Viola's love and the enmity of Lord Wessex (Colin
Firth), the unwanted groom-to-be assigned by her social-climbing father.
Since Shakespeare has a wife, and Queen Elizabeth (Judi Dench) sanctions the
Wessex-de Lesseps union, the playwright knows he and Viola share a hopeless
passion. It seeps into his writing, elevating ``Romeo'' to tragic grandeur.
Norman and Stoppard, aided by intelligent direction from John Madden, riff away
from the central plot like virtuosic jazz musicians.
They use a huge supporting cast, from egomaniacal actor Ned Alleyn (Ben Affleck
in a bravura performance) to Hugh Fennyman (Tom Wilkinson), a sadistic
moneylender who develops a tender side as he falls in love with theater.
In-jokes flow like ale in a dockside tavern. Shakespeare keeps overhearing
phrases and encountering people who'll find their way into his work for years.
Marlowe (Rupert Everett) takes pity on him, suggesting not only a new title for
``Romeo and Ethel'' but a change of scene to Italy, where the heroine might have
a brother or cousin who disapproves of her lover.. . .
My favorite gag is the street urchin who cavorts with rats and goes to plays
only for bloody bits: He likes ``Titus Andronicus,'' where Shakespeare has a
villain tear out a rape victim's tongue. The kid is John Webster, who grew up to
redefine English theater with gory dramas such as ``The Duchess of Malfi.''
The writers occasionally try sleight-of-hand they can't pull off. I never
believed Shakespeare could dance with Viola, then meet her again as ``Kent''
without recognizing her. (And how did Viola's two feet of strawberry blond hair
fit under a close-fitting brown wig?)
While truth can be stretched in so noble an effort, Shakespeare was hardly
obscure at the time of ``R&J''; he'd written about a dozen plays, many of them
hits. He pens ``Twelfth Night'' in a burst of creativity after Viola leaves, but
it wasn't really written for another four years. And how could Wessex have
tobacco plantations in Virginia? The first British settlers didn't land there
until 1607!
Only a churl would let this interrupt his pleasure, especially when the facts
get lost in a swirl of sharp swordplay and sharper acting. I especially liked
Fiennes' intemperate Shakespeare and Dench's imperious, clever, spiteful
Elizabeth.
The revelation was Paltrow, who has approached this level of commitment only in
``Emma.'' Maybe, like Laurence Olivier, she needs a whalebone corset, assumed
accent and glued-on mustache to find the heart of a character, changing her
interior by changing her exterior first. She has never been less like herself or
more appealing.
The Charlotte Observer
Published: December 25, 1998