Best Justin Story: Full Circle of Healing by SM
Best JC Story: Everything I Own by Jenni
Best Lance Story: Writer's Block by Scoop
Best Chris Story: Angel by Amy
Cutest Couple: Full Circle of Healing by SM [couple-Justin and Kayla]
Best Villian: Full Circle of Healing by SM [villian-Heather]
Best Fictional Character: Full Circle of Healing by SM [character-Kayla]
Best Fight Scene: The Dying Game by Megan
Best Kiss: Full Circle of Healing by SM
Best Revenge: What About That by Liz
Best Line: Full Circle by Hell Bent
Reader's Choice: This Side of Me by Tiff and Roxy
