Whitney walked into the bathroom looked around but there wasn’t anything unusual so she walked into the bedroom where she saw Ally laying on the bed reading a magazine.
“Ally?”
“Oh hi” Ally said.
“What are you doing out here?”
“You guys were all joking around in there and I was bored so I came out here”.
“Oh” said Whitney as she walked over to the bed. “Oh and by the way I’m Whitney”.
“Yeah I know I heard Aaron tell Nick that in the kitchen. I’m Ally” she said as she put down her magazine and sat up on the end of the bed. There was a brief moment of silence until Ally spoke up “Your Leslie’s friend right” said asked as she smiled at Whitney who was acting very shy.
“Yeah I am” Whitney answered.
“So where are those Carter brothers at” Ally said getting up off of the bed.
“Oh they’re in the other rooms looking for whoever was supposed to be in here” Whitney said as she looked up at Ally who was playing with her hair.
"Well then lets go find them" Ally said walking towards the door. Just as Whitney was about to yell tot he guys to say that she found the person in here Ally covered Whitney's mouth with her hand and said “Hey Whitney what do you say we scare the hell out of these 2”
"Ok, how are we gonna do that"
“Hmmmm lets see you go peak around that corner and tell me who you see.”
"Ok" she said looking around the corner. "They are both out there”
“Ok now I’m gonna take this phone and call nicks cell phone that is by the pool and when you hear it ring you go out there and tell them to go get the phone and that you'll keep looking in here and that you'll be ok” Ally explained.
“Ok”
“Ok now when your sure that they can't see us you come tell me” Ally said as she started to dial nicks cell phone number as it started to ring Whitney walked into the living room and told the guys exactly what Ally told her to after about 2 mins of convincing that she would be ok nick and Aaron both headed off to get the cell phone leaving the 2 girls in the pool house.
“Ok they did it now how are we going to scare them” Whitney asked curiously........Well you see I set the phone to redial his # everytime he hangs up so that should keep them busy while we set up” Ally said as both girls ran into the kitchen.
“Now what were gonna do is make it look like we're dead so get the ketchup” Ally said as she got a big butchers knife and some of nicks little joke toys out of the box that nick likes to call the Toy Box.
“Ok what now” Whitney said as they both walked back into the bedroom.
“Well the floors in the bathroom are tile so that will be easier to clean up” Ally said as she was putting the ketchup on her shoes and on the knife.“Now Whitney I want you to put this little fake cute looking thing around your neck and also put some blood on your shoes shirt pants everything and then sit up in the shower with ketchup all on the walls. Whitney did just what she was told as she watched Ally write You 2 Are Next on the bathroom mirror with nick’s red blood marker.
After both girls were fixed up and the bathroom was just how it needed to be to look like someone had come in and killed the girls Ally told Whitney to scream so the guys would come look for her. And just as Ally said within 2 seconds both Carter brothers were in the house yelling for Whitney.
Finally, Nick and Aaron went into the bathroom and found Ally on the counter and Whitney in the shower dead or so they thought.
"Oh my God Nick I think they are dead" Aaron said.
"Oh God no. She can’t be gone. NOOOO ALLY" Nick screamed. “I need her to much. You can’t leave me” He said crying and hugging his girlfriend.
“No Whitney you can’t be dead I really like you. I want you to be my first real girlfriend” Aaron said starting to cry.
“Who ever did this is gonna pay” Nick yelled.
"Ni...Nick" Aaron stuttered. "Look at the mirror"
“Oh shit” Nick said as he read the message on the mirror. “Ok lets just think here. Um first lets check their pulses”
"Ok you get Ally and I’ll get Whitney”. Just as both girls had suspected the guys walked over to see if they had a pulse now Ally and Whitney had planned to scream as soon as the guys got close to them.
As soon as both Nick and Aaron were right in front of their girlfriend’s faces to see if they were breathing Ally gave the signal that Whitney would see since her eyes were opening and they both just started screaming .....Nick and Aaron jumped away from the girls screaming Aaron immediately grabbed hold of Nick just as Nick started to grab a bat still screaming. Both girls jumped up laughing there asses off.
“What the hell” Nick yelled.
“Oh my god I can’t believe you fell for it! King of Pranks himself” Ally said still laughing.
“What this was all a trick” Aaron asked looking at Whitney still kinda scared.
“Yep” Whitney said smiling.
"I can't believe you did this Ally. You scared the shit out of me" Nick said getting mad.
"Aww come on Nicky. It was only a little prank. You do it all the time" Ally said going over to give him a hug.
"Oh no you are not hugging me with all the ketchup and red stuff all over you. No way" he said backing up.
"Come on. I wanna give you a hug"
"No Ally get away from me" Nick said running out of the house with Ally right behind him.
"Well that was interesting" Whitney said turning to look at Aaron.
“Yeah it was” Aaron said quietly still shocked and kinda mad from what the girls had done.
"So did you really mean what you said earlier"
“Ummmm well yeah I guess I did mean all that” Aaron said whlie looking down at his feet.
"Well I feel the exact same way" she said.
Aarons head shot up “You do” he asked really suprised.
"Don't look so surprised" She said smiling at him.