Home My Figure Skating Page My Life Experiences My Writing Page |
Laurie's Review of the Long Programs
Okay, here's the rest of it.....forgive any mistakes - it's 3:00 a.m. here now, and I was up at 6:00 a.m. this morning (er, yesterday morning, LOL)...
Tech marks:Ina & Zimmerman: Wearing a sparkly burgundy shirt for him with black pants, and a plastic looking burgundy dress for her, they skated to "My Baby You" by Marc Anthony. The throw triple sal was very good! SBS double axels were good. Death spiral was good, loved their he-in-spread-eagle-position-she-draped-over-him move. Speed in the combo spin. Nice program! Tech marks:Shen & Zhao: Wearing what had to be one of the ugliest costumes ever seen, LOL....reminded me of Stannick Jeannette's green Skeletor costume from last year. This one is perhaps best described as purple spray paint on plastic light blue bodysuits. They skated to horribly cut music - "Moonlight Sonata" - then to something modern - reverts back to "Moonlight" and more Beethoven. Death spiral was good. Triple twist - wow! Throw triple sal - good! Nice star lift, SBS double axels, good. SBS double axel/double toes - good! Not a lot of speed to their skating. Tech marks:Final standings for pairs: 1st place: Berezhnaya & Sikharulidze - (controversial win) 2nd place: Ina & Zimmerman 3rd place: Shen & Zhao Interpretive free skate - men's:
Steven Cousins: Wearing his multi-colored purple, green, and orange print shirt with black pants, Steven performed his SOI program from last year. He stepped out of his triple lutz. He did a backwards somersault on the ice, not a backflip. Crowd liked the sass in the program, but it was weak on tech difficulty, of course.
He started with what we thought was a triple toe intended to be a quad toe, but perhaps it was a triple flip, as he performed a triple toe later in the program. He followed this with a triple axel he stepped out of, followed by a triple loop and triple toe. Nice spread eagle. Great butterflies. Lots of drama in the program, including dying on ice. Footwork was very good and difficult. Pancake and scratch spins were nice. There was an interesting slide move. I've seen this program skated with more passion, and I missed all the extra butterflies and dance leaps from the Sun Valley version, but it was very good. Photos taken by Dianna Nowain Tech marks:
1st place: Todd Eldredge 2nd place: Alexei Yagudin 3rd place: Ilia Kulik 4th place: Steven Cousins Interpretive free skate - ladies: Yuka Sato: Wearing a deep blue costume and skating to a ballad with vocals, Yuka started with an overroated first jump - didn't catch what it was. Triple toe and double axel were good. Ina Bauer was very nice. Triple sal was good. Yuka has a very gentle and lyrical quality to her skating I always like. Tech marks:Lu Chen: Skated to Indian sounding music with sitar and tabla drums, which may have been Beatles/George Harrison music. She was wearing one of her SOI costumes - black halter top with black pants. I think she started with a triple toe. She completed a double axel and then singled her loop jump. Wonky triple sal. Technically better than I expected. I want my "Butterfly Lovers" Lu Chen back... (sniff).... Tech marks:Irina Slutskaya: Dressed in a flowy and pretty white and green (Kim said it was blue, LOL) costume, and skating to soft, romantic piano music, Irina started with a very nice triple lutz, followed by a good double axel, triple loop, and triple sal. Can't ask much more than that, LOL. Beautiful spins - lots of speed and nice positions. Very nice program! Tech marks:Michelle Kwan: Dressed in her beautiful pale pink costume with lacy silver at the top, Michelle skated to a soft, pretty ballad with vocals of "If I could Change the World." Started with a nice double axel, followed by a double loop, triple lutz, double sal, and triple toe/double toe. Beautiful camel/Y-spin/cross foot spin combination, along with her very nice Charlotte. Her obligatory and wonderful inside/outside edge spiral. Spread eagle was very nice. Typical Michelle Kwan performance - deep immersion into the mood of the music, and soft, light jumps. Tech marks:Maria Butyrskaya: When she came out in the warm ups, I almost didn't recognize her. Covering her blonde hair with a brunette wig and a silver headband, Maria was dressed in a sapphire blue costume with silver Egyptian looking designs, and skating to some vaguely middle eastern sounding music. She started with an overrotated triple lutz. There were lots of Egyptian looking hand movements. Triple loop was also wonky - triple toe and double axel were fine. Her spins were good - I liked the cross foot spin and the illusion spin. I think this program could work for her, but it still seems new. Tech marks:Final standings for ladies: 1st place: Michelle Kwan 2nd place: Irina Slutskaya 3rd place: Yuka Sato 4th place: Maria Butyrskaya 5th place: Lu Chen My final conclusions? Some of the judging seemed a little strange. I love B & S as much as the next person, and, yes, they have tremendous speed, unison, flow, great lifts, yadda, yadda, yadda.....but how many huge mistakes can you make and still beat a respectable and solid program? Apparently, quite a few....I wouldn't have minded so much if presentation had carried the day - these are interpretive programs, after all - but when only one the parties is actually showing some presentation skill, then I think something is a little off.... Ladies could have gone the other way, but not likely. Irina sure has the technical chops, and she has a lovely style as well. But Michelle is Michelle, LOL....I think the judges made the right choice, but I think it was closer than the marks would lead you to believe. Men was about right. I think the placements ended up where they belonged. Laurie |