The Exclusive California Song
Interview by Kevin McCarley
CalSong: The Doors of the 21st Century . a new band with a great
history.
Robby Krieger: We're doing songs and ideas for new stuff. There's songs
that Ray and I have written and songs that Ray and Jim Carroll had done
a few years ago. Ian Astbury is going to be writing some stuff too.
CS: I'm directing the focus onto you as the songwriting legend behind
numerous rock classics. That's because your real contribution to The
Doors collective body of work, other than as the guitarist, was the
songwriting.
RK: I got some words too that I've written down.
CS: You're the lyricist for many, many of those rock classics,
especially all The Doors #1 hit songs ... and Jim Morrison was not The
Doors exclusive poet/lyricist. I'm just curious to find out if it was a
collaborative composing process.
RK: We collectively arranged the songs. Like most of the ones I did, I
came up with myself and then I'd bring it in to arrange it.
CS: And that - not that you didn't get a lot of credit for it - but
perhaps your musical legacy over time has been so overshadowed by the
celebrity aspects. What were some of the song titles where you completed
all the music and lyrics?
RK: Well, "Light My Fire" was the first one ... AND The Doors' first #1
hit song. There's "Love Her Madly", "Love Me Two Times", "Lost Little
Girl", "Spanish Caravan", "The River Knows", "Touch Me ...
CS: "Touch Me" ... another #1 hit song for The Doors and all the words
and music ... that was you?
RK: Yeah ... I wrote the words and music to all those and many others.
I always tried to write something that Jim could sing. I knew I had some
pretty stiff competition - so you just can't write anything, you know!
CS: Was it easy for him to fit his voice into your lyrics?
RK: Jim never complained about singing any of my lyrics - no matter how
dumb they were. He was great about that.
CS: If Jim Morrison would sing them, I imagine he thought they weren't
all that dumb! Where does Robby Krieger's story really begin with The
Doors?
RK: I really started playing guitar in the San Francisco Bay area. The
guitar music that I played first was classical Spanish flamenco music,
until a couple of friends up there at school - really got me into the
American roots-folk music scene like 1963. We were right near Berkeley,
we'd go hear folk music there. I had no thought of even playing electric
guitar at the time. It was folk music, flamenco and bluegrass-styled
acoustic stuff.
CS: Doors' music is unmistakably the blues!
RK: We loved music, we drew from all kinds of stuff ... but I was also
into blues stuff and of course so was Ray, being from Chicago. 'The Paul
Butterfield Blues Band' was my favorite band at the time and Paul
Rothchild was their record producer. Long before it ever came to pass,
I had decided that if there was only one guy I could pick to produce The
Doors, it was going to him, Paul Rothchild.
CS: Is that why Jac Holzman, (Elektra Records Prez' 66') approached
him?
RK: No. Jac approached him because he was Elektra's only producer at
the time. It just happened to be. It just happened that Paul Rothchild
became our producer.
CS: There were higher powers at work then?
RK: In different ways. Also it was, well for the first couple of
albums, The Doors original inspiration and composer of melodies and
lyrics was Jim Morrison, which was so unusual because Jim did not play a
musical instrument at all! He just had a lot of stuff that he just heard
in his head. He would actually hear it in his head and convey to Ray and
I what he was hearing.
CS: Would he have a melody for his poems/lyrics?
RK: Yeah, he had the melody and the whole thing.
CS: But then not necessarily the chords for it or a key signature.
RK: No, no chord changes or a particular key because again, he didn't
play anything, but he'd surely hear it inside his head. Then it was just
a matter of coming up with the right chords and stuff.
CS: Yeah, like "Moonlight Drive" which was based on poetry, one of his
poems.
RK: Well, no, not really. He had it as a song; it was always a song in
his head. He sang it to Ray that day they met for the second time, on
the Venice beach boardwalk ... That was one of the songs that Jim
composed in his mind. Ray suggested they start a rock n' roll band
together and Jim suggested using the title of a William Blake book ...
"The Doors of Perception." "Crystal Ship" was another with no chord
changes or a particular key. Again, it was just a matter of coming up
with the right chords. "Crystal Ship" was definitely a Jim Morrison song
because he'd finished it inside his head. That was just one of the ones,
from those first ten songs or so that he had finished on his own. Jim
always loved traditional American Indian music and he'd always want John
to play 'toms' on everything.
CS: Jim also loved the way you played blues bottleneck guitar and he'd
always want you to play 'slide' on everything.
RK: Yeah.
CS: Jim, in his way was an arranger as well as a songwriter. He was
helping to build the mold using and encouraging all of the components,
finding a way to blend everybody's individual sounds into a group sound.
RK: Yeah. And then, you know, when we realized we really didn't have
enough songs at the time, Jim tried to get us to write some new songs
too!
CS: Did higher powers go to work again?
RK: Yeah. And so, the first song I wrote was "Light My Fire".
CS: Still, no one really guessed how important in rock history that
song would become and how that one song would literally change each of
your lives forever!
RK: After we made that first album we knew we had this great album. The
first single did nothing ... "Break On Through". It was on my mind, "Oh
my God, here we made this great album and nobody was going to hear it!"
CS: And you guys thought your careers were over.
RK: And then they talked us into shortening "Light My Fire" to a
3-minute song and it would be a big hit on the AM radio, which you had
to have in those days. But then, there was no such thing as a 6-minute
pop song on radio.
CS: Yeah, in Los Angeles, 93 KHJ and the 'Real Don Steele' show started
playing the 3-minute version of "Light My Fire" which became a HUGE hit
on AM radio.
RK: So the songwriting gods smiled on our second single, because it
would have been our last if "Light My Fire" was like ... "Break On
Through" and did nothing Instead, "Light My Fire" went up like a rocket.
CS: Then, across America, the song became so popular that AM radio
stations were deluged with listener requests for the album version.
"Light My Fire" ... if I'm historically correct, was the very first
6-minute pop song put into heavy rotation on AM radio in America!!
RK: You know, if "Light My Fire" hadn't taken off, that would have been
our last album.
CS: Instead, you broke ground and created a paradigm shift in rock n'
roll music forever. The test of a great song is to do it with only one
instrument and one voice. You could do that with "Light My Fire" and the
song wouldn't lose the emotion behind it.
RK: I think that the test of a great song is that you could do it in
many different arrangements and it would still hold up. "Light My Fire"
for instance, was also the first #1 hit song for Jose Feliciano ...
totally different.
CS: But still it's considered as another 'classic' version of the song.
Absolutely. He did a fabulous job on that.
RK: Then after Jose Feliciano did it, everybody started doing it. Like
your big band leaders, all those guys did it. It turned out that "Light
My Fire" was by far our most covered song. Again, it's a kind of
poetic-irony because if "Light My Fire" had failed to ignite on AM radio
and stiffed like "Break on Through" ... The Doors would have vanished
into oblivion.
CS: Instead, The Doors become one of the most influential rock groups
in history. Doors tunes are really just standard pop tunes underneath.
Very strong verse/chorus stuff. Each musician added a lot of their own
musicality.
RK: Well, in 1967 I was being influenced by jazz guys like Miles Davis
and Ornette Coleman, Back in 63' ... I'll tell you jazz music was a
mystery to me, you know. Yeah, I liked jazz, but I never thought I would
ever play jazz on electric guitar.
CS: So #1 you got very strong verse/chorus pop tune song structure ...
and #2, so long as Ray's keybass loop and John's kick drum we're in the
pocket then ...
RK: There's ... a great variety of musical styles, like Swamp Rock,
Latin Blues, Psychedelic Jazz, Tribal Soul, Glam Pop and even German
cabaret and traditional musical theater.
CS: One of the big questions I have is that the music of The Doors is
heavily theatrical. It's a real mastery of dynamics, far and above any
band that I can think of. It really lends itself to the poetry and
content of the lyric. Was a lot of that theatrical stuff written or
developed by your on-stage vibe, or was it pre-planned and you guys just
performed it that way?
RK: No. It was more worked up on stage. One song in particular stands
out because It started out to be a little love song that Jim and I
worked up one day ... "This is the end, beautiful friend, this is the
end."
CS: Certainly. The stuff was written through actual performing ideas.
It seems like "The End" developed a life of it's own up on the stage, is
that true?
RK: Yes, then it kept growing longer and longer and until it exploded
one night in a now mythical performance at the Whisky a Go-Go. It was
born, this little tiny song and morphed into becoming this 'Raga-rock'
epic on the stage!
CS: The Doors own 'Magnum Opus' ... your "Stairway to Heaven" or your
"Yesterday". Is it true, that night when The Doors played their song
"The End" at the 'Whisky', Jac Holzman and Paul Rothchild signed the
band immediately after witnessing the performance?
RK: Oh yeah, that was the one, but Jac Holzman and Paul Rothchild had
seen five or six shows by then. So getting discovered and signing the
record deal with Elektra didn't exactly happen 'overnight' as portrayed
in the film, but it was close.
CS: Is it true like in the film, that it's the show where the club
owners heard Jim Morrison say, "Mother, I want toooo ... FUCK YOU"
onstage and had all of you and all of your equipment physically ejected
into the gutter outside the 'Whisky' stage door on Clark St! Was it
Elmer Valentine who freaked out?
RK: No, Elmer always liked us. It was Phil.
CS: What did he say?
RK: You're fired!
CS: In looking at the whole body of work, I notice that the trademark
"Doors" thing is obviously the extended middle passages. Ray was kind of
saying, "We needed to fill some time." You were playing clubs in New
York and playing for five hours, you couldn't just have Jim singing the
whole time. You had to stretch stuff out, so that just came about out of
necessity.
RK: I don't buy that. Maybe a little bit. But we did that because it
was fun, you know. Then things grew, they started out to be just short
solos and got longer and longer. So it wasn't just to fill the time, it
was fun.
CS: They go somewhere, they just don't meander around.
RK: It's not like . The Grateful Dead.
CS: In terms of highlighting ethnic styles of music like "Spanish
Caravan" especially, you're using the Phrygian modal scale.
RK: I never learned anything about music or composition theory until
after The Doors, when I got more into fusion. I believe it's better not
to know that stuff to early in a career.
CS: Meaning what, you've got to first trust your songwriting instincts
to keep fresh ideas flowing.
RK: If you check The Doors albums out, there are hardly any bad songs
and the depth of the material. Even though there's only six albums, the
amount of good stuff is pretty amazing.
CS: I was looking through your discography and counted 25 songs, at
least. that are just all-time classics of rock. Most rock bands would
die to have written the words and music to just ONE of those songs. How
much stuff percentage-wise never made it to albums?
RK: We would pretty much record whatever we had and we wouldn't bother
recording something if it wasn't good.
CS: You approached music as artists ... not as rock stars. How did you
guys approach songs like "Alabama Song", or "People Are Strange"? These
songs are very Kurt Weil German cabaret tunes.
RK: Well, I mean obviously we were very much into Kurt Weil
...."Whiskey Bar" and all that Lotte Lenya singing. Ray had this album
and we used to listen to it endlessly. Finally one day, we tried to do
that ... that "Whiskey Bar" one, maybe even "Mack the Knife".
CS: "Alabama Song" (Whiskey Bar) has a very Slavic feel to it ... I
hear Russian music there. It sounds like mandolins or balalaikas?
RK: Yeah, that's called a Marksaphone. It's kind of like a typewriter
and you press the keys and it's kind of like a zither or something. It's
an amazing little instrument.
CS: Like a hurdy-gurdy? Where did you find these instruments?
RK: Well, at that time there was a place called Wallach's Music City
and that was actually the only place in Hollywood that you could rent an
instrument. There was no SIR. And this place had some really cool stuff.
CS: So you guys just went in there then and fooled around with sounds
and said that would be good for this tune. Did you have any preconceived
ideas to make it sound this way or say we need to find instruments that
would do this?
RK: Well, once in a while we did it that way. Paul (Rothchild) was
great at finding weird stuff like that. He was very into all kinds of
ethnic music and stuff. He was like a trained musicologist kind of guy.
CS: Like George Martin was classically trained ... wrote all the
orchestrations for the Beatles records.
RK: Paul Rothchild wasn't into writing like that but he was into
sounds!
CS: It just amazes me how you've blended all this stuff so seamlessly,
you know a parfait if you will, a mixed drink of musical styles and
sounds. Seeing how the tunes progressed throughout the career, spanning
from 1965 to 1971 ... All of the early stuff had a really raw bluesy
edge to it. Then you get into a kind of traditional 'popular' musical
style with full orchestration using the strings and the horns on "Touch
Me", complete with a saxophone solo.
RK: It was the fourth album. After that we kind of went back to raw
stuff on "Morrison Hotel" and "L.A. Woman" which was the last album and
that was very raw. "Riders on the Storm" was on that record.
CS: "Riders On The Storm" is a Rhodes electric piano, and is very
'cool' jazz, while you softly play passing guitar chords behind it.
RK: The way that song came about was when we were fooling around in the
studio, playing the old cowboy number "Ghost Riders In The Sky" and it
just kind of turned into "Riders On The Storm." Still I personally
believe it is the "L.A. Woman" album that stands alone as the
quintessential album written from the Doors communal mind.
CS: In terms of the arrangements and the way you guys made records you
definitely were not afraid to try different things ... The Doors music
made bold, creative strokes.
RK: I don't know about anybody else, but we weren't afraid to try
anything else, but nowadays, it's like the record companies kind of tell
you what they want to hear, you know?
CS: That's pretty much it. After they dress you and film you, then they
get to the music which is last on the list ... and it shows.
RK: Not like it was back then. People were really open to trying new
things. It was accepted and it was encouraged.
CS: Looking at the whole body of work - you dressed them all . and
dressed them up well. Every song is distinct in its sound and
arrangement, but it's still a 'Doors' song at its essence.
RK: It kinda happened . you know we didn't try to do it - it just came
out that way. Looking back after being in a million different band
situations afterwards ... how difficult it is composing inspired music
and lyrics. Songwriting creativity has never been that easy ... since.
It was just a magic happening - four guys that just worked well
together. It was never - ever a problem.
CS: Like the musical legacy that comes from the songs of Led Zeppelin,
or Pink Floyd, or The Beatles or U2 where all four members - you can't
take one away ... because one is not more important than the other.
RK: EXCEPT ... for the SONGWRITER !!!!
CS: People always said that Jim Morrison was The Doors irreplaceable
member. I disagree and feel it was the well written songs and musical
craft that became the irreplaceable member of The Doors. All four
members had to add to the soup. Robby had to write those songs, just as
Morrison had to sing those songs ... to become the superstars you are in
rock music history.
RK: Yeah, who knew when I first wrote "Light My Fire" ... that The
Doors whole existence, our whole history, our whole legacy and our whole
lives could have just as easily ... 'never happened at all'. The scary
truth is that 38 years ago, if "Light My Fire" hadn't become a hit
record ... we'd have vanished like a blip on a screen. The Doors music
was saved from eternal oblivion by the grace of just ONE song. That's
how important learning good songwriting technique is, and can be, to any
band. The difference between the life and death of anyone's music
career!