2003
Previous Winners
| Category | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December |
| Manager | Dean | Pedro | Lady Rage and Lil Mz Fury | Erick Mason | Willie "Momo" Peterson | Miss Amber Destrix | Damien Drake | Pedro |
| Newcomer | "Invincible" Theo Mason | Kurt Fury | "The Trapper" Martyn Keech | Kevin Heat | None | Josiah | Draco/Casanova | "Pornstar" Pete Parker |
| Finishing Move | Touch of Reality | The Thrilla | Long Way Down | The Extinction | Blood Rain | X-Treme Prejudice | Ground Zero | South Central Effect |
| Most Wins | El Linchador/Killa Kali | Killa Kali | Killa Kali | The Lost Soul | The Lost Soul | The Lost Soul | The Lost Soul | The Lost Soul |
| Angle | - | - | - | - | - | - | Jack Sullivan's Stalker | The Formation of Terror Corps |
| Feud | PIC vs. Trent Steel | PIC vs. Trent Steel | ODJ vs. El Linchador | ODJ vs. El Linchador | ODJ vs. El Linchador | Titan 3 vs. PIC | ODJ vs. El Linchador | Jack Sullivan vs. Silver Cyanide |
| Most Underrated | Tommy Crimson | Mike Allen | PIC | Trent Steel | Trent Steel | Harvey Danger | Chloe Christianson | Draco |
| Most Improved | Trent Steel | Mike Allen | Killa Kali | Jason Blood | PIC | Jack Sullivan | DeMarko Frost | TLS |
| Most Charismatic | El Linchador | Theo Mason | El Linchador | PIC | Darodevil | El Linchador | Jack Sullivan | Josh Allen |
| Face | Derek Mobley | El Linchador | Derek Mobley | Jason Blood | El Linchador | PIC | El Linchador | PIC |
| Heel | Trent Steel | Killa Kali | Titan 3 | Trent Steel | Titan 3 | Trent Steel | Lucius Pendragon | Trent Steel |
| Match | "Iron Man Match" Killa Kali and Derek Mobley | "1 on 1" El Linchador vs. Derek Mobley | "The Fall from Heaven to Hell" Killa Kali vs. El Linchador | "Insane Rumble 2003" | "Acrophobia" Match Jason Blood vs. Kevin Heat | "3 Way Dance" Hardcore Tag Title Match - Unstoppable Force vs. Dark Side Assassins vs. House of Pain | "CotC Tournament Finals" Titan 3 vs. DeMarko Frost | "Hardcore Title Match" Killa Kali vs. PIC |
| Roleplayer | Derek Mobley | El Linchador | Derek Mobley | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Josh Allen |
| Wrestler | Derek Mobley | El Linchador | Killa Kali | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Titan 3 | Killa Kali |
