| 2002 Nominees |
| Handy Man* |
Dark Side Assassins |
Brett Archer |
Andrew Logan |
Derek Mobley* |
| El Linchador* |
Killa Kali* |
Scott Syren |
The Mozz* |
Silver Freak |
| *Second Nomination |
| 2001 Nominees |
| Handy Man |
Alec BeGrod |
Anthony Logan |
Killa Kali |
Suicidal Juvenal |
| Warrick Hill |
John Steel |
Mozz |
House of Pain |
Playboy G |
| 2000 Nominees |
| Electricity |
Steve Strong |
Milo Decadent |
William Haynes |
Party Animals |
| Kingpin |
Jake Navaja |
PIC |
Derek Mobley |
El Linchador |
| 1999 Nominees |
| Stone Cold Steve Austin |
Enigma |
Vic Vulgar |
Ruff Ryder |
Scorpion |
| Razor |
Reid |
Chyna |
Scott Hall |
Chris Stevens |
