| Won | Defeated | Date | where | Comments |
| Dark Side Assassins | Unstoppable Force/House of Pain | 10/26/03 | Halloween Riot III PPV | 3 way dance for the titles. This is the Dark Side Assassins 4th title reign and last, as the Tag Hardcore Titles are being retired. |
| Unstoppable Force | Dark Side Assassins | 09/12/03 | Friday Night Inferno | Unstoppable Force's first title reign. |
| Dark Side Assassins | House of Pain | 08/15/03 | Friday Night Inferno | Dark Side Assassin's third title reign. |
| House of Pain | Dark Side Assassins | 05/09/03 | Friday Night Inferno | House of Pain's third title reign. |
| Dark Side Assassins | House of Pain | 10/31/02 | Halloween Riot II | Darkside Assassins' second title reign |
| House of Pain | Dark Side Assassins | 09/13/02 | Friday Night Inferno | House of Pain's second title reign |
| Dark Side Assassins | 3rd Earth Klique | 06/30/02 | Bad Blood III | Titles were vacant... Dark Side Assassins' first title reign. |
| House of Pain | Electricity | 04/06/01 | Friday Night Heat. | HOP's first title reign. |
| Electricity | Looks 2 Kill | 12/22/00 | Prophecies II: The Second Coming. | The title was vacant. Electricity's first title reign. |
| Party Animals | Soul Assasins | 06/06/00 | Tuesday Night Fights | Party Animals first tag title reign. |
| Soul Assasins | Night Crawlers | 05/12/00 | Friday Night Heat | Suicidal Juvenal and Night Crawler were scheduled to have a fight for the titles, NC quit so SJ won the match and the belts via forfeit. His new partner, Punisher. |
| Suicidal Crawlers | Cory Theriot and Lord Von Draven | 04/30/00 | Deadly Revenge II PPV | Titles were vacant, Suicidal Crawlers won tournament. NC's and SJ's first title reign. |
| Texas Outlaw & UFO | Cory Theriot | 02/28/00 | Insane Massacre PPV | Outlaw and Theriot faught for the titles, the winner will keep both belts and choose a partner of their own. Cory Theriot's last match in the ICWF. |
| Cory "Two Much" Theriot & Texas Outlaw | Total Annihilation | 01/18/00 | Tuesday Night Fights | none |
| Total Annihilation | Fixxxer | 11/30/99 | Prophecies: End of Days PPV | 2nd title reign for TA |
| Fixxxer | Total Annihilation | 10/31/99 | Halloween Riot PPV | 3rd title reign for Fixxxer |
| Total Annihilation | Jack Jeckel and Domination | 10/22/99 | Friday Night Heat | none. |
| House of Pain | Fixxxer | 9/29/99 | Extreme Measures PPV | Jack Jeckel and Domination hold belts for HOP. |
| Fixxxer | Scorpion & Ralphass | 9/17/99 | Friday Night Heat | Earlier that night Scorpion defeated Mozz to gain 1/2 of the Tag Titles. He then went ahead with Ralphass and tagged with him only to turn on Ralphass and leave him to get pinned. |
| Cheese and Cracker | Fixxxer | 9/7/99 | Tuesday Night Fights | none |
| Fixxxer | Kroller & Everlast | 8/26/99 | Clash of the Champions PPV. | The belt was vacant. Stone Cold and the Rock were the champions, SCSA retired and the Rock forfeited the belts after becoming the World Champion.
|
| Bad Blood | The Eliminators | ?/?/99 | Friday Night Heat. | Stone Cold defeated The Eliminators in a handicap match, and then asked who wanted to be his partner, Madness responded, who later on that week gave the Rock the title and then left. |
| The Eliminators | Hell Freaks | 6/1/99 | Tuesday Night Fights. | none. |
| Hell Freaks | X-Treme Inc. | 5/4/99 | Tuesday Night Fights. | none. |
| X-Treme Inc. | The Misfits | 4/12/99 | Deadly revenge PPV | Title was vacant, became first ever ICWTF Tag Hardcore Champions. |
