| Won | Defeated | Date | where | Comments |
| Josh Allen | Draco | 07/25/04 | Bad Blood V PPV | This is Josh Allen's first World Lightweight Title win, and 3rd singles title win. Also, with this win Josh Allen becomes the second ever, Unified World Champion. |
| Draco | Reggie Savage, Warrick Hill | 4/04/04 | Insane Massacre IV PPV | Title was vacant. This is Draco's 2nd single's title win and first Lightweight Title win. |
| El Linchador | Jason Blood | 12/21/03 | Prophecies III Pay Per View | This is El Linchador's Third Lightweight Title reign |
| Jason Blood | - | 12/01/03 | - | Title goes back to owner |
| Titan 3 | DeMarko Frost | 11/23/03 | Clash of the Champions III PPV | CotC Tournament. Winner gets all titles for a week. |
| DeMarko Frost | Lucius Pendragon | 11/23/03 | Clash of the Champions III PPV | CotC Tournament. Winner gets all titles for a week. |
| Lucius Pendragon | Jason Blood | 11/23/03 | Clash of the Champions III PPV | CotC Tournament. Winner gets all titles for a week. |
| Jason Blood | El Linchador, Angel | 08/08/03 | Friday Night Inferno | Jason Blood's first Lightweight Title reign and first singles title win in the ICWF. |
| El Linchador | Pit Viper | 02/24/02 | Insane Massacre 3 | Pit Viper's second title defense. El Linchador's second LW title reign. |
| Pit Viper | Suicidal Juvenal | 02/08/02 | FNH | Pit Viper's first single title win in the ICWF. |
| Suicidal Juvenal | Tim Havock, El Linchador and Jason chase | 4/28/01 | Deadly Revenge III | Suicidal's third LW title reign. First LW to ever accomplish this. |
| Tim Havock | Suicidal Juvenal | 4/17/01 | Tuesday Night Fights | Tim Havock first's title reign. |
| Suicidal Juvenal | Curt Canon | 3/30/01 | Friday Night Heat | Suicidal Juvenal's second singles title win. Second LW title reign. |
| Curt Canon | Kidd Foxx | 2/22/01 | Friday Night Heat | Curt Canon's first singles title win. |
| Kidd Foxx | Arryk Rage | 1/25/01 | Genesis 2 Genocide. | Kidd Foxx's first singles title win. |
| Arryk Rage | Jason Storm | 12/22/00 | Prophecies II: The Second Coming. | Arryk Rage won a 3 way dance to become a two time champion. |
| Jason Storm | El Linchador | 7/14/00 | Friday Night Heat | Jason Storm's first title win. |
| El Linchador | Suicidal Juvenal | 6/29/00 | Bad Blood PPV | El Linchador's first title win. |
| Suicidal Juvenal | Kid Loco | 5/26/00 | Friday Night Heat | The Title was vacant. Suicidal Juvenal's first singles title win. |
| Twiztid | Hustler | 11/2/99 | Tuesday Night Thunder | Jack Jeckel was sent to rehab, the title was vacant. |
| Jack Jeckel | Hustler, Kidd Foxx, Arryk Rage | 9/29/99 | Extreme Measures PPV | Battle Royal for the vacant title. |
| no one | no one | - | - | First Champion to be crowned at September's PPV. |
