| Offense |
| 1st Team |
2nd Team |
| OL-Sean Kennedy, Jr. (Coe) |
OL-John Beck, Sr. (BVU) |
| OL-Jim Milner, Sr. (Loras) |
OL-Ryan Johnson, Jr. (Central) |
| OL-Jon Stavast, So. (Luther) |
OL-Drew Dennis, Sr. (Coe) |
| OL-Ross Parker, Sr. (Simpson) |
OL-Adam Welbes, Sr. (Loras) |
| OL-Andy Heitman, Sr. (Wartburg) |
OL-Tom Power, Jr. (Wartburg) |
| QB-Joe Brannen, Sr. (Coe) |
QB-Mark Isaacson, Sr. (Central) |
| RB-Chad Pearson, Jr. (BVU) |
RB-Neil Suckow, Fr. (Coe) |
| RB-Tyler Sherden, So. (Luther) |
RB-Jeremy Brown, Sr. (Loras) |
| WR-Jesse Schmidt, Jr. (BVU) |
RB-Dan Hammes, So. (Wartburg) |
| WR-Kyle Pearson, So. (Luther) |
WR-Brad Ryals, So. (Central) |
| WR-Dusty Kain, Jr. (Simpson) |
WR-Nick Brown, Sr. (Loras) |
| K-Kyle Wickwire, Jr. (Luther) |
WR-Chris Winter, Sr. (Wartburg) |
| P-Chris Kemmerer, So. (BVU) |
TE-Cody Angle, Sr. (Coe) |
| RET-Neil Suckow, Fr. (Coe) |
K-Joe Greenley, So. (Loras) |
|
P-Keith Wasoba, Sr. (Central) |
|
RET-Brett
Scheetz, So. (Luther)
|
| Defense |
| 1st Team |
2nd Team |
| DB-Thoni Oriental, Jr. (UD) |
DB-Nick Cross, Sr. (Central) |
| DB-Sam McDonald, Jr. (Luther) |
DB-Tyler Staker, Jr. (Coe) |
| DB-Kyle Westphal, Sr. (Simpson) |
DB-Clint Miller, Sr. (Loras) |
| DB-Brian McIntire, Sr. (Wartburg) |
DB-Nick McFall, Jr. (Simpson) |
| DL-Ross Dillavou, Jr. (Loras) |
DL-Matt Mullen, Sr. (BVU) |
| DL-Scott Romens, Sr. (Luther) |
DL-Rick Ohlinger, Jr. (BVU) |
| DL-Jason Ripke, Jr. (Simpson) |
DL-Rodney Sundine, Sr. (Central) |
| DL-Noah Junge, Jr. (Wartburg) |
DL-BJ Bengard, So. (Simpson) |
| LB-Michael Irvin, Sr. (BVU) |
LB-Brant Pfantz, Jr. (Coe) |
| LB-Mark Sanger, Sr. (Central) |
LB-Chris Buesing, Jr. (Loras) |
| LB-Blake Borrett, Sr. (Coe) |
LB-Jeremy Scott, Sr. (Simpson) |
| LB-John Jaeger, Sr. (Luther) |
LB-Alex Pollock, Jr. (Wartburg) |
