| First Team |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Matt Trickey, So. (Ripon) | DL-Chris Staley, Sr. (Beloit) |
| RB-Adam Wallace, Sr. (Grinnell) | DL-Zach Fletcher, Sr. (Grinnell) |
| RB-Justin Berrens, So. (Lawrence) | DL-Willie Thompson, So. (Illinois College) |
| RB-Luke Hagel, Sr. (Ripon) | DL-Matt Lerner, Sr. (Monmouth) |
| WR-Nate Edwards, Sr. (Beloit) | LB-Joe Kostiha, Sr. (Beloit) |
| WR-Tom Neagle, Jr. (Knox) | LB-Anthony Balthazor, Sr. (Knox) |
| WR-Zach Michael, Jr. (Lawrence) | LB-Casey Urlacher, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
| WR-Tim Roerhig, Jr. (Ripon) | LB-Kevin Krabel, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
| TE-Nick Vraney, Sr. (Ripon) | DB-Kevin Keen, Sr. (Knox) |
| OL-Chris Terwilliger, Sr. (Beloit) | DB-Pat Gillihan, Jr. (Lake Forest) |
| OL-Ben Larkin, Jr. (Lake Forest) | DB-Travis LeRoy, Sr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Curtis Maurer, Sr. (Ripon) | DB-Joe Masciopinto, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| OL-Brett Meach, Jr. (St. Norbert) | P-Pat Dunne, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
| OL-Jeremy Jackson, Sr. (St. Norbert) | ST-Joe Kostiha, Sr. (Beloit) |
| OL-Kevin O'Malley, Sr. (St. Norbert) | ST-Joe Masciopinto, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| K-Pat Dunne, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
|
| Ret-B.J. Harvey, Jr. (Illinois College)
|
| Ret-Ryan Schneider, So. (St. Norbert)
|
| Second Team |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Rob Purlee, Jr. (Monmouth) | DL-Andy Wagenbach, So. (Illinois College) |
| RB-Jon Dupuis, Sr. (Beloit) | DL-Vince Srejma, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
| RB-Vince Singleton, Sr. (Knox) | DL-Tobias Dickerson, Sr. (Monmouth) |
| RB-Todd Sabean, So. (Monmouth) | DL-James Stirewalt, Sr. (Ripon) |
| WR-Dustin Devening, Jr. (Illinois College) | LB-Stephen Hawf, Sr. (Knox) |
| WR-Jesse Abbott, Jr. (Knox) | LB-Ian Thompson, Sr. (Lake Forest) |
| WR-Mike Fitzgerald, Sr. (Lake Forest) | LB-Rob Rogers, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| WR-Nathan Gaskill, Jr. (Monmouth) | LB-Ben Creamer, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| OL-Steve Smart, Sr. (Carroll) | DB-Devin Brewer, Jr. (Beloit) |
| OL-Sam Jones, So. (Grinnell) | DB-Jim Schueller, Sr. (Grinnell) |
| OL-Ryan Van Aken, Sr. (Illinois College) | DB-B.J. Harvey, Jr. (Illinois College) |
| OL-Cory Bonstead, Jr. (Knox) | DB-Seth Kopf, Jr. (Knox) |
| OL-Andy Shaffer, Jr. (Lake Forest) | DB-Drew Holman, Jr. (Lake Forest) |
| OL-Tony Bouressa, Jr. (Lawrence) | DB-Luke Hansen, Sr. (St. Norbert) |
| OL-Jon Newcomb, Jr. (Monmouth) | P-Curt Miller, Sr. (Carroll) |
| OL-Chris Dumke, Jr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Dan Lutter, Jr. (Ripon) |
| K-Chris Griffin, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| Ret-Nathan Gaskill, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| Honorable Mention |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Nate Skelton, Fr. (Beloit) | DL-Adam Kujath, Sr. (Carroll) |
| QB-Don Lackey, Jr. (Lake Forest) | DL-Jeremy Tabor, Sr. (Knox) |
| QB-Chris McGinley, Sr. (Lawrence) | DL-David Bleitner, So. (Lake Forest) |
| QB-Ryan Hartman, Jr. (St. Norbert) | DL-Tom Starnicky, Jr. (Lake Forest) |
| RB-Ed Williams, Sr. (Beloit) | DL-Steve Heindl, Jr. (Lawrence) |
| RB-Tony Salvage, Jr. (Carroll) | DL-Mike Jacobs, Jr. (Ripon) |
| RB-Ed McCracken, So. (Monmouth) | DL-Chris Koonce, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| RB-Nick Marcelle, Jr. (Ripon) | DL-Ryan Reader, Sr. (St. Norbert) |
| RB-Alec Getschow, So. (St. Norbert) | LB-Mike Dempsey, Sr. (Beloit) |
| WR-Andy Poch, Sr. (Carroll) | LB-Mike Herbin, Jr. (Grinnell) |
| WR-Jacob Peterson, Jr. (Grinnell) | LB-Rich Stott, Sr. (Illinois College) |
| WR-Dan Holden, Sr. (Illinois College) | LB-Jeff Burke, Jr. (Knox) |
| WR-Tyler Snyder, Jr. (Monmouth) | LB-B.J. Burlowski, Jr. (Lawrence) |
| WR-Jacob Banks, So. (Ripon) | LB-Andy Uecker, Jr. (Ripon) |
| WR-Dave Archibald, Sr. (St. Norbert) | DB-Ted Serafini, So. (Beloit) |
| WR-Nick Llanas, Sr. (St. Norbert) | DB-Greg Lowder, So. (Illinois College) |
| TE-Chris Weller, Sr. (Illinois College) | DB-Ryan Magruder, Sr. (Knox) |
| OL-Greg Huebner, Jr. (Grinnell) | DB-Justin Oertle, Sr. (Monmouth) |
| OL-Nate Ray, Sr. (Grinnell) | DB-Zack Reblin, Sr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Tom DeBetta, Jr. (Knox) | DB-Ty West, Sr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Troy Paulsen, Jr. (Lake Forest) | P-Willie Thompson, So. (Illinois College) |
| OL-Brad Day, Sr. (Ripon) | ST-Jim Schueller, Sr. (Grinnell) |
| OL-Ryan Reigle, Sr. (St. Norbert) | ST-Scott Stanton, Sr. (Monmouth) |
| Ret-Rob Brester, Sr. (Carroll) |
| | Ret-Collin West, Fr. (Ripon) |
| | | | |
