By Dan Scanlan
Staff writer
A new digital
telephone antenna is behind Jeffrey Smith's house on Catrakee
Drive in Mandarin,
but he says the city had no right to allow it to be built.
The city's Building
and Zoning Division allowed Sprint PCS to replace an
existing power
pole with a new and much taller pole on June 6, then erect
its antenna
atop it. Now Smith says the whole structure sits too high in
the sky in plain
view of his neighborhood.
The city said
the new pole and antenna are allowable under city law, as do
Sprint officials.
But Smith says the new construction violates
Jacksonville's
2-year-old tower ordinance, which he said should have only
allowed that
antenna atop the existing power pole, not a new one.
''They have stuck
up a big new pole to support the antenna, then reattached
the existing
power cables to the new poles. Then they look you straight in
the face and
say the principal use of this pole is for power and the
antenna is just
an ancillary use. It is pretty strange,'' said Smith, an
attorney. ''They
seem to be saying that you can add to the existing
structure. I
think that is just baloney.''
Sprint PCS is
planning to start digital telephone service in the
Jacksonville
and Gainesville areas later this summer. The Mandarin antenna
was built atop
a new power pole on a Jacksonville Electric Authority right
of way behind
the Autumn Glen Estates community, just south of Loretto
Road. City Building
and Zoning Division records show the Jacksonville
Electric Authority
authorized the replacement pole in a May 6 memo, then
the city granted
the building permit.
Sprint spokesman
Dan Wilinsky said they needed to build a taller power pole
because the
existing pole was too short. He said the taller pole was needed
to ensure the
best reception for their customers, and believes everything
was done legally.
''We believe
this tower meets height requirements and we have been working
with the city
to make sure this meets height standards,'' he said. ''We
have also had
discussions with the folks concerned about the tower and we
welcome the
opportunity to meet with concerned residents.''
And City Building
and Zoning Division Chief Tom Goldsbury said his office
granted Sprint
PCS a permit for a new pole because it is allowable under
the tower ordinance.
''We made a determination
on the plans that were submitted, that what they
were doing was
legal,'' Goldsbury said. ''It was questioned thereafter and
we went to the
city attorney and they upheld our opinion.''
The city's tower
ordinance was the result of a massive influx in requests
to erect digital
telephone towers around Jacksonville in 1996, after the
Federal Communications
Commission approved a new radio frequency for
digital telephones.
Faced with the prospect of hundreds of digital
telephone towers
being built around the city, the City Council crafted a
new ordinance
that limited telephone tower heights and prohibited them
within 250 feet
of a home.
But after hearing
from Smith, City Councilman Dick Kravitz, whose district
includes the
Marbon Road area, said the city had no right to allow a new
pole to be installed
and claim it was only a change to an existing
structure. The
councilman says he plans to meet with city attorneys as soon
as this week
to change the basic ordinance so that what happened can't be
used again.
''I don't know
if it will help this one ... But I am in agreement with the
citizens out
there that a permit should not have been given,'' Kravitz
said. ''That
is a replacement pole and the ordinance is quite clear on what
can be done
to a replacement pole. But the administration gave Sprint
permission to
put up a new pole and put the tower on the new pole which is
wider and bigger.''
Smith met with
Goldsbury on June 8 to learn if the new antenna was legal,
and said he
was told the taller pole was allowed under a provision of the
zoning code
because it is part of an existing structure, namely all of the
power poles.
Smith said his understanding of the ordinance says otherwise,
and he will
continue to fight what he called the city's ''Through the
Looking Glass,
Alice in Wonderland-kind of,'' decision.