By Jeni
Brock Steele
special
to the News
St. Lucie
County's Board of Adjustment toppled a communications tower
Wednesday
by unanimously rejecting a variance needed for its construction.
Aero Communications,
an Orlando-based company, requested a variance to
build
a 125-foot tower to provide cellular phone service to Nextel
Communications.
After two
hours of discussion, the board rejected its employees'
recommendation
to approve the tower at 5014 N. U.S. 1, a small piece of
property
the company would have leased from Affordable Storage.
The variance
was needed for construction because the nearest residence is
125 feet
from the proposed tower. A county ordinance prohibits towers
within
750 feet of a residence.
Barbara
Guettler Debus' residence is 262 feet away and she said her Old
Dixie
Highway house has been in her family for four generations. She told
board
members the tower did not fit in with the property where her family
raised
and still cares for many native fruit trees.
Bill and
Jeanne Hearn live across the street from the proposed site on
Tozour
Road. The Hearns live within 500 feet of the tower.
Jeanne
Hearn told board members she also represented the interests of her
82-year-old
mother, Mildred Tozour, who lives next door to them.
Tozour
wrote the county's Planning and Zoning Commission of her opposition
in May,
when Aero Communications's petition for the tower went before the
Planning
and Zoning Commission. A public hearing was scheduled before the
Planning
and Zoning Commission in June, but was postponed so the Adjustment
Board
could rule on the variance.
Tozour
told the Planning and Zoning Commission about a similar radio tower
that fell
across her property last year.
Jane Morrell,
another nearby resident, said if that tower had fallen to the
east it
would have interfered with U.S. 1 traffic.
Board members
were not given the package of information by county staff
that included
seven letters of opposition and a letter from Frank Spain,
owner
of Microwave Service Corp., a company with a 400-foot tower less than
two miles
north of the proposed site.
Spain's
tower already accommodates the service of BellSouth, the FBI and
the U.S.
Coast Guard, and he notified county staff there was space
available
on his tower to service Aero Communications needs.
Adjustment
Board members asked Planning Manager David Kelly why they did
not receive
the comments from opponents of the tower.
''We furnished
it to the Planning and Zoning Commission, but didn't think
it would
be necessary at this meeting,'' Kelly said.
Board member
Bob Bangert challenged Kelly on his decision to recommend the
petition
to the board.
''It is
your job to protect, enhance and make possible development to
ensure
that the wants of this community are fulfilled,'' he said. ''There
are times
when it is my feeling that you feel like your job is not
community
development, but economic development.''
Board member Howard Pancoast agreed.
''I just
have to wonder why you all are saying "yes,' when the community is
saying
"no,''' he said.
Kelly said
he thought approving the tower was in the best interests of the
entire
community, and not just the neighborhood affected.