PROPOSITIONS FOR A LIBERTARIAN CONSTITUTION - Part A
by Kirk Brothers
CLICK HERE to return to Index
INTRODUCTION Some time--just for the sake of a practical experiment in the psychology of partisan (or party) politics--ask a few of your best friends for their opinions on a simple, brief Constitutional amendment, like this one: The official language of the United States shall be standard American English. The above 12 words can (and do) provoke passionate argument on totally irrelevant issues--perceived prejudice/discrimation, for one--producing smoke but no fire, and resulting in utter lack of either unity of opinion or decisive action. In a nutshell, as soon as a man identifies himself with a political PARTY--NOT with the good of the PEOPLE AS A WHOLE--his opinion on any question is influenced less by the merits of a proposal than by its perceived effects upon his special-interest group (party for short). Imagine, then, what a storm of controversy would greet a proposition for an entirely new Constitution intended to replace the fictitious Constitution of 1787! In THE REVOLUTIONARY RIGHT it was shown that our so-called Constitution is nothing more than an historic scrap of paper-- only occasionally honored by a Court, and when upheld it is by default rather than under any legal compulsion. For details, please re-read, if necessary, the first three chapters entitled SOCIAL SECURITY--OFFICIAL EXTORTION, ABUSE OF DISCRETION--INVI- SIBLE TREASON, and THE TIME BOMB IN OUR CONSTITUTION. If the salient points of those chapters are clear in your memory, let's go on. THE NEED FOR A CONSTITUTIONAL PLEBISCITE In THE REVOLUTIONARY RIGHT, specifically in the chapters sub-titled WHY AND HOW AMERICA MUST COLLAPSE, and AMERICA'S HEALING CRISIS--KILL OR CURE?, it was shown that our present regime is so corrupted by self-serving politicians who--due in large part to routine abuse of discretion by Federal Judges--are immune to peaceful redress of grievances for past abuses, that our nation must suffer the ravages of bloody civil war in two or three decades at the most. It was also shown that the American people as a whole are either too stupid, or too lazy, or both, to either learn from history or to take any decisive action to bring about revision of the 1787 Constitution through the clumsy and nearly-impossible means deliberately mandated by that document. Therefore, when the sinking ship of the American state can no longer be kept afloat by short-term expediencies invented by those in undeserved power, right-wing militias, and countless other Americans belatedly awakening to the truth of Libertarian principles, will see armed warfare as the only possible solution to the crisis. The pen is mightier than the sword only when both sides use pens. I'll have further comment on this crisis period, and the ensuing transition to law and order, in Part 3 of this chapter-- but for now prefer to move on to the more urgent problem of the Constitutional plebiscite that must in due time come about. When Americans as a whole accept the eternal truth that power ALWAYS corrupts those who hold it, it follows that the people will then see small government as a good servant, and big government as the worst possible master. To change our form of government from the disguised but real tyranny of the present to an ideal form envisioned by some of our patriot forebears (but not realized by them), it will be obvious that a new Constitution is the one and only solution to prevent future tragedies for future generations. To choose a new Constitution will mandate a plebescite to select from a number of conflicting documents which will be pro- posed, all touted as the ideal new form for the supreme law of the land. It is hoped that one option will be a Libertarian Constitution--of which this is intended as a rough draft--and that it will be approved by at least a plurality of the voters, as being the best available choice. ORGANIZATION OF THIS CHAPTER Because of the length of my thesis, it has been divided into three major subdivisions, as follow. (1) A list of propositions for the various sections of a Libertarian Constitution; (2) A parallel section of comment and argument in defense of each proposition--some very brief and some of necessity more detailed; and, (3) An examination of the crucial civil war and transition period that must link the old with the new. WHY "PROPOSITIONS" ONLY? Because the 12 words of the above proposed amendment could be debated for hours by glib shysters for purposes of barratry, I shall not propose final language for an entire document, which is presented here in outline form. Instead, I shall offer merely a series of "topics" which outline essential premises, principles, logic, and flow from one section to the other--as a skeletal framework rather than a finished structure. Because these topics are arranged in order of what seems to me to be relative importance--from the highest priority to the lowest--there may appear to be "jumps" in continuity, which will make sense only when the entire outline is viewed in retrospect. A certain amount of repetition of key points was found to be necessary for both emphasis and clarity. It is hoped that the reader will bear with me through the lengthy series of proposi- tions--which of necessity will be highly controversial. If and when a Constitutional plebiscite is called for, it is inevitable that competing proposals will be presented by the special-interest groups called political parties--all of which must be vigorously rejected in order to eradicate the ROOT CAUSE OF ALL GOVERNMENTAL CORRUPTION--which is party politics. Instead, a Libertarian Constitution, transcending all party loyalties in favor of eternal truths, must fight for acceptance by those who in general are too stupid, or too lazy, or both, to read history and/or understand what they are voting for. It is my hope that these propositions will be most carefully studied by young Americans--who have the greatest stake in the future--and that the concepts and precepts stated here will be widely recotnized as the one and only sound basis upon which any future government of the United States may be established. If this outline stimulates serious debate on its merits, it shall have served its purpose--which is to get people thinking about really important problems, and not the fictitious crises manufactured by our bureaucrats for self-serving ends. PART I - THE PROPOSITIONS PROPOSITION ONE - STATEMENT OF ORIGINAL INTENT a) We, the people of the United States, in order to correct past abuses of power by previous legislative, executive and judicial branches of government so as to corrupt the Constitution of 1787 for selfish gain, do hereby declare this document to be the one and only valid Constitution in and of the United States of America. b) This Constitution, when ratified by a plebiscite vote of at least a plurality, shall take effect as written for as long as at least forty-one percent (41%) of the people vote not to amend it in any way. Each and every seven years thereafter, another pleb- iscite shall be held to amend any provision(s) hereof in any manner that at least sixty percent (60%) of the people shall demand. If no amendments be approved by at least sixty percent of the people, this Constitution, as then in effect, shall be deemed ratified for the next seven years. c) This Constitution is a contract among the people of the United States collectively--by which document they agree to the creation of a new and incorruptible government to replace the old. Government is not a party to this contract, because it is created only by statutes enacted pursuant to this contract. Thus the people of the United States collectively, by ratifying this Constitution and/or its amendments by plebiscite each seven years, hold sovereign power, which government may not claim. d) All prior Constitutions, including those of the several states are hereby nullified. There shall be but one set of laws binding upon all citizens is all states, and states shall share powers which were formerly the exclusive domain of the Federal government. No state shall secede from the United States, and any declaration of secession by any state shall be deemed an act of war against the United States and shall be punished as treason. e) Treason in other situations shall be defined as giving aid and comfort to the enemy in time of war. PROPOSITION TWO - LANGUAGE CONVENTIONS a) The official language of the United States shall be standard American English. b) This Constitution, in its entirety, shall be the supreme law of the nation. c) This Constitution in its entirety, and all laws enacted pursuant thereto, shall be strictly construed. d) All words shall be used in their common meanings as defined by Webster's and other dictionaries of comparable authority and repute, and easily comprehended by laymen of normal intelligence. e) The word "shall" in any proposition denotes a MANDATORY provision, with which government MUST comply. The word "may" in any proposition denotes that the provision is PERMISSIBLE, at the discretion of government. f) The phrase "in and of the United States" shall be construed to mean government at the Federal level and at the lower level of the several States. PROPOSITION THREE - EXECUTIVE AND JUDICIAL IMMUNITY a) Willful disregard of any provision of this Constitution by any government official shall be grounds for civil suit by any citizen seeking a Declaratory Judgment on a claim of abuse of discretion, to be heard in a new Constitutional Court. b) A claim of executive or judicial immunity shall not debar a suit claiming abuse of discretion. A claim of judicial immunity shall debar suits claiming only reversible error, and normal appeals procedures shall apply in such cases. c) Any official or judge found on trial to have abused his discretion shall be forthwith removed from office, forfeit all benefits, and be permanently disqualified from future public office. PROPOSITION FOUR - THE SOCIAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL CONTRACTS a) Society cannot exist without law and order, which is the first priority of government. b) The social contract is unwritten, but established by long tradition based upon natural law, including the right to life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, property, and due process as established in Common Law. c) Government is a coercive (police) force which by its mere existence infringes some freedom of action by citizens. The purpose of a Constitution is to define those areas in which government may restrict some individual freedoms in order to uphold the social contract without which no nation may survive. d) This Constitution is a written contract by which the people of the United States create a government and delegate some of their natural and Common Law rights to elected and appointed officials. Government officials thereby possess power within carefully-written limits to perform only those tasks which the institution of government can perform better than individuals acting for self-serving (profit) motives. PROPOSITION FIVE - POWERS DELEGATED TO GOVERNMENT BY THE PEOPLE Government shall have power to enact laws which are both necessary and proper to provide the following services for each and every citizen equally and without prejudice: a) National defense and disaster relief; the several states may form regional associations for mutual aid and assistance in times of disasters typical of their geographical area--such as floods, hurricanes, or earthquakes. b) Environmental protection, recycling and waste disposal, and sanitation services. c) Establishing and maintaining Courts of Common Law for civil redress of actual injuries and punishing criminal offenses. d) Establishing and maintaining essential police and fire- fighting forces, prisons, and related services. e) Establishing and maintaining institutions for the mentally and/or physically handicapped. f) Establishing and maintaining rural communes of agricultural and/or other self-supporting nature for able-bodied persons who are indigent and unemployed. g) Establishing and maintaining public transit services, and regulating corporations engaged in such commerce. h) Establishing and enforcing standards for a new monetary system which cannot be manipulated in any fashion; in addition thereto, to provide for orderly conversion of all bank accounts and all debts, public and private, from the old monetary system to the new during the transition period, so as to maintain fiscal integrity and solvency of financial institutions, and the credit of the government. i) Regulation of corporations--especially banks, insurance companies and securities exchanges--to prevent fraud and other crimes against consumers. j) Creation of ombudsmen charged with investigating cases of apparent child abuse by their parents, in which cases ombudsmen shall act in loco parentis on behalf of an abused child against his natural parents, and said child may become a ward of the state, to be properly cared for in foster homes. k) Government may establish a ghetto in any municipality, perhaps contained within a solid wall, for the express purpose of confining prostitution and other sex-related business activities --which activities may be prohibited outside said ghetto on grounds of public disorder/nuisance. Government may likewise establish special beaches for nude swimming or sun-bathing, which may be prohibited except in specially designated areas for thse persons choosing a "naturist" life style. k) The above provisions may be expanded at any time by the new process of Constitutional Amendment by plebiscite at seven-year intervals. PROPOSITION SIX - SANCTIONS UPON GOVERNMENT RELIGIOUS NEUTRALITY a) The government of the United States of America shall be a secular institution, which tolerates each and every religion equally, but abets/endorses NO religion to any degree whatsoever on any pretext whatsoever. b) While the majority of Americans might adhere to Christian or Jewish beliefs, the United States shall NOT be held to be a Christian or Jewish nation, and the Bible shall be of no legal interest. Neither the Bible nor the word "God" shall be used in any legal ritual, nor shall "God" appear in any statute, anthem, motto, or other quasi-official utterance, in any manner which comprises a tacit endorsement of monotheism. c) Religious motives shall receive no preferential treatment in law, nor shall members of any clergy have any privileged status. Because moral beliefs are part of one's religious beliefs, moral standards may not be legislated. Government shall establish no standard for orthodox behavior nor prosecute unorthodox behavior, unless the behavior of any citizen either causes actual injury to the rights of another citizen, or is shown beyond reasonable doubt to have comprised an actual public disorder/nuisance. d) Because the United States of America shall be absolutely secular, no symbol of the United States--including its flag-- shall be deemed or implied to be "sacred" and therefore to be "protected" from "desecration" by acts clearly intended to express political dissent. Actions popularly described as "disrespect to" or "desecration of" the flag shall not be actionable offenses, despite the arguable poor taste of such expression of dissent. BALANCED BUDGET a) Except in time of war, the government of the United States and the several states shall operate within the limits of funds on hand. Government, at any level, shall not guarantee payment of any debts except its own. b) Each and every spending bill shall be based upon precise and conservative calculations and projections of the long-term costs and potential problems of any such program, and never upon merely the short-term apparent benefits. c) The national debt shall be converted from the old monetary system to the new as soon as possible, and the first financial obligation of government shall be to retire and eliminate all debt within a period of fifty (50) years. To this end the Secretary of the Treasury shall show once each fiscal year that, first, the interest on the debt was paid and, second, that at least two percent (2%) of the principal retired. This mandate may be abrogated only in the event of war. TAXING POWERS a) The Federal government of the United States may levy a tax on personal income not to exceed ten percent (10%) on individuals or fifteen percent (15%) on corporations. b) State government may levy a tax on real estate and retail sales within its jurisdiction, and may also sponsor one or more lottery games to benefit specific government programs. SOCIAL WELFARE a) Government, being essentially a police force concerned with maintaining law and order by enforcement of civil and criminal laws, shall have narrow and precise legal interest in problems of a social nature. b) To encourage individual savings for old age, the present IRA and Keogh pension plans shall be continued. c) Because of its power to provide disaster relief, government may assist the indigent by such means as mobile kitchens serving simple but nutritious meals to any citizen who seeks it, and cater such meals to the elderly and home-bound. Needy families having their own homes may receive rations of groceries and clothing, but in no case shall assistance be provided in the form of a government check. With the exception of humanitarian aid in urgent cases, government shall have no legal interest in the economic welfare of any citizen, save matters relevant to any bankruptcy proceeding. EDUCATION AND HEALTH CARE a) Government shall have no legal interest in either the health care or education of citizens, such matters being within the purview of individual responsibility, including the freedom to choose alternative health care methods and alternative education, and/or voluntary social group activity. b) Government may continue to require safe working conditions, especially in jobs involving hazardous materials, and continue its regulation of sanitary conditions, especially in the food industries. c) Government may, through the National Centers for Disease Control, inform the people and medical professions as to current epidemic or other serious diseases, and may recommend--but shall not dictate--any particular treatment for same. SEXUAL PRIVACY a) Government shall have no legal interest in any sexual acts of any consenting adults in private. b) A person shall be deemed a sexual adult when he/she has passed through the changes of puberty, and is capable of sexual relationships and desire. THE BILL OF COMMON LAW RIGHTS a) Since the Virginia Enactment of 1776, Common Law has been the legal philosophy in and of the United States. This document does not supplant Common Law, but embodies it. b) The first purpose of government is to protect the natural and Common Law rights of each and every citizen. c) Each and every citizen shall be deemed absolutely equal in rights to each and every other citizen, group or association. d) This bill of rights does not create rights, but acknowledges and guarantees each and every natural and common law right which has pre-existed for centuries under English Common Law. e) Natural and common law rights shall in each and every case be construed as intentionally broad and general--not as vague or imprecise. f) There are two pre-eminent rights which imply all others, and these two rights shall be vigorously protected from infringement. These pre-eminent rights are (1) the right of self-determination in each and every decision; and (2) the right to be left alone, free from government intrusion, except if a citizen's action or negligence has caused actual injury to some other citizen, or comprises an actual public nuisance/disorder. g) No right shall be abridged by government either on grounds of poor taste, or on the pretext of protecting any mentally- competent citizen from some hypothetic harm that might befall himself in consequence of his own errors. Nor may incompetence be legally presumed except in the case of an infant or one shown to be mentally defective. SPECIFIC RIGHTS a) Each and every citizen shall be entitled to free practice of his religious/moral beliefs, and free expression in speech, the press, and/or any artistic medium. b) Each and every citizen shall be entitled to possess and bear arms for self-defense. c) Each and every citizen shall be entitled to security in his person, home, papers or effects, including any vehicle, against unreasonable searches and seizures. No warrant shall be issued except on probable cause, supported by affirmation which particu- larly describes the place to be searched and the persons/things to be seized. Property so seized shall not be disposed of by government except after the conviction of the original owner of a felony, and only to the degree that a felon may be deprived of felonious gain or subject to punitive damages as prescribed by law. d) Within one year of the ratification of this Constitution, there shall be one uniform criminal code and one uniform set of procedural rules governing trials in each and every court in an of the United States. Within two years of the ratification of this document, there shall be one uniform civil code for trial of torts and other civil injuries. During the transition period to the new statutes, previous rules and statutes unchallenged by this Constitution may be followed, but in each and every case the rules of Common Law shall prevail over statutory law in event of conflict. e) No person shall be held to answer for a crime unless on presentment or indictment by a Grand Jury, except in cases involving military personnel. No person shall be in jeopardy twice for the same offense. No person shall be compelled in a criminal case to be a witness against himself. Private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation. No person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law, as established in the Common Law tradition. Specifically, the Common Law rule of corpus delicti shall be rigidly upheld; no prosecution for crime shall fail to prove beyond reasonable doubt that an actual injury to some person's rights has occurred as the result of a criminal act, and the fact that a statute may have been violated shall not comprise the legal element of injury. f) In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall have the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury. The accused shall be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, and shall be confronted with the witnesses against him. The accused shall have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense. g) In cases of Common Law, no fact tried by a jury shall be re-examined by any Court except as provided for in Common Law. h) Excessive bail shall not be required nor excessive fines imposed, excepting that bail may be denied a person accused of an atrocious crime. i) Cruel and unusual punishments shall not be inflicted, but capital punishment per se shall not be deemed either cruel or unusual, if it be uniformly applied in cases of similar crimes. Safe and moderate corporal punishment shall not be deemed either cruel or unusual, and may be deemed proper discipline in schools, the armed forces, penal institutions, and may be imposed by criminal courts in cases of physical violence by a criminal against a victim, or malicious vandalism of property. Medical sterilization of genetically-defective persons, habitual violent criminals, or unfit parents who abuse their children shall not be deemed cruel or unusual punishment. Castration of violent sexual criminals shall not be deemed cruel or unusual punishment. j) Though other rights are not specified herein, this Bill of Rights shall be deemed to include each and every other Common Law right as recorded in Blackstone's Commentaries and other equally authoritative writings on English Common Law. PROPOSITION SIX - DIVISION OF GOVERNMENTAL POWERS a) The powers of government are comprised of legislative power, executive power and judicial power. Each of these powers shall be assigned to a separate branch of government, each of which is charged with upholding this Constitution and thereby act as a check on abuse by either of the other two branches. In addition, citizens may assume an adversary role against government in cases of alleged abuse of discretion. b) Legislative power shall be divided among the several states in a manner to be described below. c) Executive power shall be vested in a President, Vice- President, a cabinet, and enforcement agencies to be primarily located in Washington, D.C. d) Judicial power shall be vested in the Courts, which shall be divided into District Courts, Circuit Courts of Appeals, the Supreme Court of the United States, and a separate Constitutional Court which shall hear by original jurisdiction all cases which question either abuse of discretion, or Constitutionality of statute. e) All elected officials shall run as independent candidates, representing all the people as a whole, and shall not be members of any political party. Political parties shall not nominate a slate of candidates, but may endorse any candidate for any public office in any district, and function as a political action and public education organization. THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH a) The President shall serve as the Chief Executive Officer of the United States, and the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces in keeping with our tradition of civilian control of the military establishment. As Commander in Chief the President may ask the Senate to declare war, in which event a majority vote by the Senate shall suffice instead of the usual 60% required to enact a law. The President shall appoint a cabinet with the advice and consent of the Senate, and shall in addition appoint Judges to the Federal Courts with the advice and consent of the Senate. The Vice President shall serve ex officio as President of the Senate. b) Candidates for President, Vice President, and the cabinet shall be native born, at least forty years of age, of good character, with an intelligence of not less than 130 IQ. c) All officers and employees of the Executive Branch shall be paid a salary from time to time as shall be established by the United States Senate. d) The President and Vice President shall serve not less than one year and a day, and/or as long as they retain the confidence of the Senate. Should the Senate, by a vote of sixty percent (60%) vote No Confidence in the President and Vice President, said President/Vice President shall step down and a new election held within 30 days. The President/Vice President may seek re- election. During the 30 days prior to the election, the present order of successiong to the Presidency shall be retained. THE JUDICIAL BRANCH a) Judges appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate shall serve during good behavior, and shall have judicial immunity against a suit for reversible error, in which cases normal appeals procedures will apply. Candidates for a judicial seat shall demonstrate superior scholarship in matters of natural and common law, and the history and philosophy of jurisprudence. All judges shall have an intelligence of not less than 130 IQ. Judges shall have no immunity against a suit for abuse of discretion, which shall be heard by the Constitutional Court. b) The Senate shall enact legislation to create any new Courts necessary, pursuant to the intent of this Constitution. c) All Judges and other employees of the Judicial Bransh chall be paid a salary from time to time as established by the United States Senate. THE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH a) Legislation shall be initiated in the several states--each of which shall have a Governor, a Lieutenant Governor, and a uni- cameral legislature--all of whom are elected by direct popular vote on a nationwide uniform proportional basis. Governors may have a cabinet as provided for by the legislature of that state. b) Candidates for Governor, Lieutenant Governor, and the state legislatures shall be of good character, have an intelligence of not less than 130 IQ, be at least 30 years of age, and have no affiliations with any political party. c) The Governor and Lieutenant Governor shall serve not less than one year and a day, and thereafter as long as they retain the confidence of 60% of their state legislature. A vote of no confidence by 60% of the legislature shall force the Governor and Lieutenant Governor to step down, and a new election held within 30 days. The Governor and Lieutenant Governor may be candidates for re-election. d) All officers, legislators and state employees shall be paid a salary from time to time as established by each state's legislature. e) Members of the state legislature will be divided into seven groups. Upon ratification of this Constitution, the first group shall be elected for one year, the second group for two years, and so on. Upon the completion of their first terms, legislators shall be elected for seven years uniformly, so that one-seventh of the body is re-elected each year. State legislators may serve two full succsssive terms, after which they shall step down for at least one year. They may seek re-election to the legislature after they have been out of public office for not less than one year. f) The legislature of any state may draft a bill for submission to the United States Senate for a vote to approve or disapprove. g) The Lieutenant Governor of each state shall ex officio serve as United States Senator. Compensation shall be legislated by the Senator's home state, and paid from state funds. h) The U.S. Senate shall convene in Washington, D.C. for the purpose of debating proposed legislation, and negotiating any compromises necessary. Each Senator shall have power to make such compromises in the name of his/her state, and each Senator shall have one (1) vote. i) A bill shall become law if sixty percent (60%) of the U.S. Senate concur with the final compromise version. j) The President shall have no veto power. k) Bills affecting only one or a regional group of states shall become law within such limited jurisdiction if approved by the legislatures of all states involved, providing that any such bill may be challenged in the Constitutional Court by any citizen who questions the Constitutionality of said bill. PROPOSITION SEVEN - ELECTION PROCEDURES a) Any citizen at least 18 years of age, having an intelligence of not less than 100 IQ, shall be qualified to vote in any or all elections, except when incarcerated in a penal institution or confined in a mental hospital. b) Any citizen may join any political party for the purpose of advocating legislation, and educating the general public to the alleged merits of such legislation, and parties may endorse any candidates they choose from the slate of candidates for any elected office. c) Candidates for each and every public office shall be chosen by direct popular vote. In the event that no candidate attains more than fifty percent (50%) of the popular vote, a run-off election shall be held between the two candidates having the greatest plurality, provided that multiple candidates do not score within the same two percent (2%) of the vote cast. If three or more candidates score pluralities within two percent of each other, all such candidates shall be included in the run-off election. (TO BE CONCLUDED)