WWF Wrestlemania 2000 ranked # 2 in GameFan Online's Games of 1999. Every staff member picked their top 5 games of 1999. The Wanderer and Hi-Fi picked WWF Wrestlemania 2000 as the second best game of 1999. Here is the two staff member's listing from GameFan:
Hi-Fi's Picks (Editorial Manager)
5. Berserk - DC
4. Zombie Revenge - DC
3. Soul Calibur - DC
2. Wrestlemania 2000 - N64
1. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater - PS
The Wanderer's Picks (Associate Editor)
5. Mario Golf 64 - N64
4. Sonic Adventure - DC
3. Worms Armageddon - PC
2. Wrestlemania 2000 - N64
1. Super Smash Brothers - N64
