| York First Round Draft Picks | |
| 1980 | Tim Stoddard |
| 1981 | Gary Lucas |
| 1982 | Tony Pena |
| 1983 | Steve Bedrosian |
| 1984 | Carlos Diaz (#10 pick) |
| 1985 | Michael D.Young |
| 1986 | Tom Browning (#2 pick) |
| 1987 | Reuben Sierra (#9 pick) |
| 1988 | Matt Nokes (#8 pick) |
| 1989 | Tim Belcher (#8 pick) |
| 1990 | Gary Sheffield (#5 pick) |
| 1991 | Kevin Tapani |
| 1992 | Phil Plantier (#4 pick) |
| 1993 | Royce Clayton |
| 1994 | Greg McMichael |
| 1995 | Shawn Green (#10 pick) |
| 1996 | Jason Isringhausen (#5 pick) |
| 1997 | Jason Kendall (#8 pick) |
| 1998 | Brett Tomko (#8 pick) |
| 1999 | Rolando Arrojo |
| 2000 | Ben Davis |
| 2001 | Chuck Smith |
| 2002 | Joe Kennedy |
| 2003 | none |
| 2004 | none |
| 2005 | John Buck |
| 2006 | Pat Maholm |
| 2007 | Andre Ethier (from Gle) |
| 2008 | Micah Owings |
| 2009 | none |
| 2010 | Matt Wieters (#2 pick from Kal) |
| 2011 | Domonic Brown |
| 2012 | Dustin Ackley (#8 pick) |
| Zach Britton (from VT) | |
| 2013 | Manny Machado (#2 pick from Mun) |
| 2014 | None |
| 2015 | Matt Shoemaker |
| 2016 | Michael Conforto |
| 2017 | Trevor Story (#3 pick) |
| 2018 | none |
| 2019 | Jaime Barria |
| 2020 | Tommy Edman |
| 2021 | Randy Arozarena (#6 pick) |
| 2022 | Frank Schindel (#9 pick) |
| 2023 | Jeremy Pena |