Subject: We Wish You a Delhi Christmas: Jaipur, Delhi, Pushkar
Jaipur boasts one of the most pleasant old cities in
India. Instead of the usual dense maze of narrow
alleyways, there are wide avenues with raised
sidewalks on either side, and the whole thing is laid
out in a sensible grid. Trees grow in the medians, and
there are fountains at the centers of some of the
bigger intersections. Rajasthan's pink-painted capital
is, in fact, a planned city, established in the 18th
century by the brilliant astronomer, scientist, patron
of the arts and military leader Jai Singh, the first
maharaja (and namesake) of Jaipur.
I make a point of this because city planning has such
a curious history in India. The Indus River Valley
civilization, one of the earliest in the world,
planned their cities in immaculate detail. Cities
hundreds of miles apart were laid out in exactly the
same way down to the smallest details, as if some
prehistoric architecture firm had faxed the same set
of blueprints to builders from Afghanistan to
Baluchistan to the Punjab.
The decline of the Indus civilization is shrouded in
mystery, but when they disappeared, they took the art
of city planning with them; according the historian
John Keyes, theirs was the last example of urban
design until the 18th century, when the British and
other colonial powers reintroduced the idea.
To be fair to the Indians, it's not as if 16th-century
Paris was a convenient place to park. And the
elaborately dense, organic old cities -- Delhi and
Varanasi are good examples -- are typically much older
than Jaipur. They give one an enveloping, sometimes
claustrophobic sense of being inside a very old, very
strange animal. Jaipur by contrast feels rational,
sophisticated, cool. The Jai Singh dynasty were
promoters of art and science, close allies of the
Mughals yet resolutely Hindu, tolerant and
forward-thinking. The current maharaja still lives in
part of the palace, and another part has been
dedicated to masters of traditional Rajasthani crafts,
whose work is supported by an endowment from the royal
family.
In fact, the old feudal maharajas have played a vital
role in the modern history of India. When India became
independent in 1948, it was easy enough for the
British to hand their territories over to the new
governments of India and Pakistan. But the British
were in direct control of only a portion of the land;
the rest was still officially in the hands of
independent (though always compliant) maharajas. An
agreement was reached in which the maharajas would
retain their residencies and some official status,
including stipends, in exchange for joining their
territories to the new states. (In India, those powers
were largely curtailed during the Emergency period of
Indira Gandhi's rule in the 1970s.) Each maharaja was
given the right to choose whether he would join
Pakistan or India. In Kashmir, even though his
subjects were predominantly Muslim, the Hindu maharaja
chose to join India, and this has been a centerpiece
of India's argument that it owns the disputed
territory. India's position would be more persuasive
had India itself not annexed a chunk of Gujarat when
the Muslim ruler decided to join his largely Hindu
realm with Pakistan. To this day, Kashmir and Gujarat
are focal points of the Hindu-Muslim tension that
dominates the politics of the Subcontinent.
Jaipur manages to have a mixed population of Hindus
and Muslims with relatively little tension, and this
again might be attributable to the wisdom of the
Singhs, who managed to align themselves with the
ruling Mughals but were never subsumed by them. Among
their relics are a phenomenal set of palaces and
monuments. A few kilometers outside Jaipur is Amber
Fort, the prior home of Jai Singh. It's a marvelous
maze of passageways and halls and stairs and ramps
that seem to fold in upon themselves in a way that M.C.
Escher would have liked. The main gates are all
fantastically painted with vines and flowers in bright
colors, and the most prominent building is a small
vaulted hall completely covered in shimmering mirror
inlay. The effect is somewhere between Versailles and
Hearst Castle, with a bit of Pink Floyd concert thrown
in.
In the heart of Jaipur is the Hawa Mahal, or Palace of
Winds, little more than a facade of elaborately
screened windows behind which the ladies of the court
could watch the action on the main boulevard of Johari
Baazar. Nearby is the City Palace, which is now a
museum. Among other things, you can see the clothes of
one of the maharajas who just happened to be 7 feet
tall and 250 kilograms. His jacket looks like a tent
for a baby elephant who needs room to turn around.
There are paintings of him in a boat with about six
people on the other end to act as counterbalances.
There are, fortunately, no paintings of him with his
many wives.
But the most fascinating of Jaipur's
sights is the Jantar Mantar, or astronomical
observatory, created by Jai Singh. The instruments of
masonry and marble look like some kind of weird
modernist sculpture park, but our guide carefully
explained and demonstrated how they all worked. Giant
sundials told the time precisely; a whole series of
devices helped to identify rising signs for newborns;
azimuths and zeniths and a lot of other things I don't
quite understand could be measured as well.
*
Sights are fascinating until they're not. While we
enjoyed seeing these exotic palaces and forts and
observatories, there comes a point when it all blurs
together, like when you've spent too much time in the
Metropolitan Museum of Art and can no longer tell
whether you're looking at a Rembrandt or a mummy or a
fire extinguisher. To some extent we relieved this
burnout with shopping, but that too can get wearisome,
especially as stepping into a shop in India means
having an intense relationship, entirely one-sided,
which goes as follows:
"Yes, hello! Have a look! We have more inside. What
you like? Look, see, have a look, this one. Okay, this
one. You like that one? Here, I have many more. No?
Why no? Leaving? Why? What happened? Please, wait! I
have many more! Very cheaper price! Wait! What's
wrong? Hello!"
I remember that on my last trip to India, the stretch
from Varanasi through Agra and Jaipur was one of the
loneliest. They're big cities where it's awkward to
talk to strangers, even other Westerners, just as it
would be weird to go up and say hi to a random
backpacker in New York or London. This time Jenny and
I had each other, but by the time we finished up in
Jaipur it had been weeks since our last non-commercial
conversation with anyone else. What with the holidays
and the isolation, Jenny was feeling pretty depressed.
(For me, the lack of Christmas here is something of a
relief; the holiday blues hit me in September, not
December.) We decided to go back to Delhi on Christmas
Eve so that we could have a festive dinner (and
festive margaritas) at TGI Friday's.
Unfortunately, Christmas Day started out badly. On our
way back from breakfast we stopped to consult our
Lonely Planet and, as usual, were surrounded by
faux-helpful Indians who typically either want to
guide us to their travel agency or else just poke the
funny white monkeys. In this case, it was a bunch of
rich young men of the sort who get involved in "Eve
teasing," India's euphemism for sexual harrassment.
They began pestering Jenny with personal questions
while I was consulting the book, and when we began to
walk away they shouted at us. "Why are you so *rude*!"
they cried. "You don't talk to Indians? You're too
good?" It's a totally obnoxious and all-too-common
ploy that plays on Western liberal guilt, which it
shouldn't: we talk to Indians plenty, but we don't
talk to crowds of strangers on busy city streets, and
neither would any self-respecting Indian under similar
circumstances. Still, it was enough to reduce Jenny to
tears.
When she thought it through later, Jenny decided that
it wasn't the rudeness or the attempt at making her
guilty that made her feel so rotten, but the way that
India required her to be nasty to people. I agreed.
India is exhausting, and the worst of it is suspecting
absolutely everyone you meet of having threatening
motives. Jenny wasn't sure she could handle another
three months of it, and frankly neither was I. But
having traveled here before, I knew something that
Jenny didn't: I knew the transformative power of
Pushkar. "We'll go there," I told her, "and we'll meet
other travelers, and we'll have conversations, and
we'll relax. We can think things through once we get
there."
The rest of Christmas was in fact an improvement. We
met two Scotsmen in kilts and Santa hats who were off
in search of liquor and the new James Bond movie,
because "it wouldn't be Chraistmas without James
Bond." Just that little conversation cheered us up
enormously, and we spent the rest of the afternoon
shopping with the hoards of Indians who had the day
off.
*
By the afternoon of December 26th, we were in the
charming little town of Pushkar, and life here is
decidedly good. There are sunsets over the lake, made
all the more pleasant by the crowds of hippies and
backpackers who gather there each night, by the fine
ensemble of Indian and Western drummers who play
underneath the great tree between the Sunset Cafe and
the ghats, and by the special green lassis served up
by the Sunset's laid-back waiters. It's changed in the
last five years. The crowds are bigger, and the Sunset
has an elaborate new facade of curlicue arches plus a
cement patio. But much has remained the same, too.
Joseph David, Christian from Kerala (as he always
introduced himself) is still on the staff, looking a
little bit grayer. And there is still that
super-mellow, aimless vibe that feels so good after
the jangly bustle of the big cities.
These days Pushkar seems to be something of a
way-station for long-term Western travelers who've
spent the early season in the mountains of Himachal
Pradesh, living among the Tibetan refugees at
Dharamsala, and who will spend the late season on the
beach in Goa, but don't want to be there for the
overblown Christmas-New Year's scene. There are a
surprising number of families with small children,
most of whom seem to be well cared for. As in
California, the "alternative lifestyle" scene here is
now old enough that the first and even second and
third waves now have kids, and it changes the dynamic.
When you've got a baby, you become less interested in
which gurus throw the best orgies and more interested
in which temples have the best ayurvedic doctors.
Still, India remains a destination for the aimless:
where else can you waste so much time for so little
money? There are plenty of naive kids fresh from
college or army service floating around here -- I was
one of them the last time I visited -- and they're
very much into the hippie versions of preening and
posturing: making loud noises on their Royal Enfield
motorcycles, twirling poles or fire-sticks, beating
their drums, wearing their cloaks and bell-bottoms
dashingly. It's all very high school in its way.
(Daniel, I'm not sure if you'd love it or hate it, but
I'm guessing that if you played your cards right, you
could have scantily clad European girls worshipping
you like a god in no time.)
The crowd tends to divide by age. There are the
world-weary baby boomers who've been doing this for
decades, know exactly what they think of everything,
and have absolutely no interest in hearing anything
new from anyone younger. They tend to sit up by the
cafe rather than down on the ghats, and they have
old-people-on-the-porch conversations about how it
used to be better and cost less, and how Ibiza is such
a *scene* these days, not like it used to be. The next
bracket down are the older Gen-Xers, who like to
gather and spew angry outsider leftist vitriol at each
other for fun, always assuming that everyone will
agree with whatever conspiracy theory they propound.
If you used to read Common Cause in the '80s and miss
it, you should come here; they all hate Reagan just as
much as Jello Biafra and Dennis Miller did.
Jenny and I are in the age group between the Gen-X
Leftists and the preeningly graduated. We like to get
together and talk about the artful ways in which we've
been laid off. We're still a starry-eyed bunch, but a
lot of us are actually in the process of doing things
that mean a great deal to us, no longer adrift but not
yet disillusioned.
The night before last we had a long conversation with
a couple who are on tour with Princess Superstar. He's
a dj who's worked with the Chemical Brothers, she's a
former London fashion-mag editor who went to interview
Princess Superstar and immediately became her best
friend. (And who's Princess Superstar? She's a New
York hipster phenomenon, a sort of Lawn-Guyland
Italian trash-talking princess type who happens to be
a badass rapper and has worked with just about every
other super-cool New York hipster musician.) So when
Princess Superstar went on tour, she invited this
woman along, and they've been touring the world with
this bizarre, wild novelty act and meeting cool people
wherever they go.
So this couple is doing something absolutely cool.
Five years ago I might have felt jealous or pathetic
talking to them, but I don't now. Jenny and I agreed
that they definitely out-hipped us (and after a year
in Korea, it feels so good to be around people hipper
than us!), but they didn't particularly out-cool us.
It's a subtle distinction, but it matters. Yes, they
hang around people like Beck, Jon Spencer, Kool Keith,
Prince Paul, Chuck D, and that's very, very hip. (If
you've never heard of any of these people, just nod
and smile and pretend you like their music very much.)
Suburban Korean children and their teachers are not
typically a very hip crowd, but it turns out that
hanging out with them for a year is pretty
spectacularly cool. And if you spend all your time
with record company executives, expat kindergarten
teachers probably seem that much cooler.
I guess Jenny and I are lucky to have so many friends
who are doing very cool things that are pretty much
what they wanted to do: producing and directing their
own plays and movies, sewing wings for Victoria's
Secret models, practicing law, doing social work,
playing in a Judas Priest cover band, taking foster
kids into their home, raising their children. And some
of it is the luck of being American: we get a lot of
opportunities, something you realize when you see
children every day who are so poor that they'll
probably never get to play with a kite. In any case,
it's good to be past that first wave of anxiety that
comes with stepping into the adult world.
It's also good to hear what the other backpackers have
to say. For weeks we've been cocooned in our own
experiences, with no reference point against which to
judge them. Now at last we can talk to other people
and find out what they like, what they hate, how they
cope. We met a young Dutch man who got away from the
tourist hype by looking at his map, looking at his
Lonely Planet, and going to towns that were in the
former but not the latter. He said he got stared at by
great crowds, and some nights he ended up sleeping on
the floors of temples, but that it was great. I don't
know that Jenny and I will end up doing something like
that, but it's an approach we hadn't even thought of.
Other travelers have shared more conventional
intelligence about which towns they liked, where there
was good food, where it was beautiful and where it was
ugly. It's gotten us excited about being here again.
We're now half-way through our travel, and we're ready
to plunge back in for an even better second half,
armed with all the knowledge and experience we've
gained so far.
Well, almost ready. For now, it's good to have an
aimless week or two to just sit and absorb what we've
done so far. We've been reading a lot, playing a lot
of chess, sitting and staring a fair amount, then
heading to the Sunset in the afternoons to do all of
the above in a more social setting. I'm on a very
tight schedule, and it's now sometime in the
afternoon, so I think I have to wander back to the
hotel now and get ready to wander somewhere else and
eat. Or something. Whatever it is, it'll be mellow,
and that feels very, very good.
More relaxed than ... um ... whatever's more uptight
than me,
=====
Subject: My Global New Year Long ago I decided never to do something on New Year's
Eve that I wouldn't enjoy doing on some other day of
the year. This is one reason why I have never chosen
to huddle in a crowd of hundreds of thousands of drunk
people in the freezing cold in Times Square. There
were periods of my life when I had to bundle up and
slog through crowds in Times Square as part of my
daily commute; why would I want to add alcohol to that
scene and do it at midnight?
So for this New Year's Eve, Jenny and I did pretty
much what we've done every other day in Pushkar: we
went to the Sunset Cafe. It's a great place to sit for
hours on end, chatting with whatever tourists happen
to be floating through, gazing out at the lights of
the village reflected in the lake, and eating
surprisingly good Italian and Indian food. They'd put
up a sign up promising a buffet, a New Year's cake,
live music and fire juggling, but we would have been
there even without the sign.
As evening came on, the usual crowd of tourists
gathered at the edge of the lake, but with some
differences. The hardcore party element -- the
fresh-from-the-army Israelis in purple pants, the
Europeans fleeing the pressures of uni, the
Renfaire-cloak hippies from Australia and North
America -- were conspicuously absent. Pushkar is a dry
town, so the serious chemical extravaganzas were held
at random spots out in the desert nearby. (Also absent
was the Bicycle Man, a terrifyingly underfed Indian
whose nightly act involves posing in various ways on a
moving bicycle; suspending the bike dangerously over a
little girl, possibly his daughter, who looks bored to
death; taking off his shirt, smearing his body with
paraffin, then lighting an inner tube on fire and
rubbing it all over himself; and, as a finale, eating
of a fluorescent lightbulb. It's the sort of act that
actually disperses crowds that are standing nearby.)
To replace the party crowd, we had an influx of
middle-class Indian couples and families on short
holidays from Delhi and Agra and Jaipur -- the sort of
people who choose to go to a dry town near home to
celebrate New Year's. So it was a mellow crowd that
huddled in the cold and waited for something to
happen.
Eventually a crash of drums signalled that the live
performance was about to begin. We had been expecting
Rajasthani gypsies or something, but instead we got a
group of Aussies practiced in the hippie arts. Two
didgeridoo players accompanied a few drummers, while
the black-clad, face-painted jugglers dribbled motor
oil onto their tools, careful not to let any polluting
substance drip on the ground. Then they set fire to
their poles and their balls on chains, twirling them
impressively to trace circles of fire in the air. Each
crescendo was met by Indian-accented cries of "Bravo!"
and "Brilliant!" and "Wo-o-ow!" The Western gypsies
have been in India long enough by now to have become a
tourist attraction for Indians.
By the time the twirling came to an end, it was close
to eleven and very, very cold. Jenny and I slipped
away and passed the Moment buried in our blankets back
at the hotel. We could hear fire-crackers exploding
over by the Sunset, and then booming techno music that
kept up until about three, but we were happy enough to
go to sleep, praying that the beginning of 2003 would
be at least a little warmer than the end of 2002.
A foreigner who can juggle dependent clauses but not
fire,
=====
Subject: A Note on Geography When I last visited India, I met a man on the beach in Puri who insisted that America was flat. Then he asked me, "What is tree of America?" That America might have many environments and many varieties of tree simply hadn't occured to him.
The world is very large and very complicated, and I understand that most people in most places have no real reason to know where Moldova is or whether Botswana even has a capital. It's necessary to generalize. Still, there are a few mysteries that can be cleared up with a quick glance at a world map, so my friends and family can stop being surprised that it snows in Korea and gets chilly in India.
WHERE IS KOREA?
WHERE IS INDIA?
REALLY? IT'S COLD IN INDIA?
IS IT COLD IN ALL OF INDIA?
WHY ARE YOU TELLING ME ALL OF THIS?
WHAT'S A PEDANT?
Pedantically yours, but at least now you know where,
=====
[my global new year]
[a note on geography]
Date: Sun Dec 29, 2002
Josh
"Nothing in the country is ever quite what you expect, and the only thing to
expect is the unexpected which comes in many forms and will always want to sit
next to you." - Lonely Planet India
Date: Sat Jan 4, 2003
Josh
"Nothing in the country is ever quite what you expect, and the only thing to
expect is the unexpected which comes in many forms and will always want to sit
next to you." - Lonely Planet India
Date: Sun Jan 5, 2003
Korea is on roughly the same latitude as Japan, Beijing, southern France and the American Mid-Atlantic states. It snows in most of those places; in the Mediterranean and Europe generally, ocean currents keep the weather warmer than at other places with similar latitudes. North Korea actually borders on Russia.
India is very big. The far north reaches as high as southern Korea and the American Mid-Atlantic; the south stretches down below Vietnam. Here in the Rajasthani desert, it gets quite cold at night, just as it does in the deserts of the American Southwest during winter; we are on a similar latitude.
Yes. Really. The far northern states of Kashmir and Himachal Pradesh are not only not tropical, they're also mountainous. They're the Himalayas, after all. It snows and freezes plenty.
No. It's hot in the south. It's always hot in the south.
Because I'm a pedant.
For that, go to Merriam Webster's Collegiate Dictionary.
Josh
"Nothing in the country is ever quite what you expect, and the only thing to
expect is the unexpected which comes in many forms and will always want to sit
next to you." - Lonely Planet India