Caribbean should brace for US recession
If a process is unsustainable, it will stop. This is the simple description
of the United States' economy offered by Erik Nilsson, Senior International
Economist of the Bank of Nova Scotia, Canada, during a visit to the Caribbean
last September.
Nilsson was addressing the local business community on developments affecting
the region's economies in the short to medium term. In his presentation, he also
noted that the extent to which the Caribbean is affected by a correction in the
US economy will depend on how hard the US economy hits the brakes when its
current economic situation falls apart.
"There has been tremendous growth on Wall Street, particularly in technology
stocks, but the new economy will also face the same fundamentals when investors
get over their love affair with the Internet and begin to separate the good
stocks from the chaff and the losers fall off.
"One of the main indicators of the looming US economic problem is the balance of
payment figure. Although a valiant effort is being made to reduce the Government
debt, the balance of payment deficit continues to grow at a rapid pace. And, no
one seems to be paying any attention to it.
So far, the economic growth that the US has been experiencing has been funded by
the inflow of foreign currency and investments. Foreign investors, in
particular, have been bullish about the US economy and they are buying up stocks
and creating the boom on The Street.
However, almost all of the inflow is being used to purchase foreign goods and is
immediately flowing back out of the system. The fundamentals are, therefore,
weak and the economy will begin to pull back.
The only problem - particularly for the Caribbean, is that the longer the
situation persists, the harder the correction will be and the more extended the
recession that follows.
He said there was an opportunity for the Federal Government to deal with the
problem, but its efforts at slowing the economy have seen only limited success.
This is because the effect of adjusting economic tools, such as the money supply
and interest rates, may not be as effective, because the US economy is more open
than it has been in the past.
The Federal Government will also have to estimate when the economy has slowed
enough and loosen interest rate restrictions on a timely basis, as they would
not want to trigger a recession.
"What has delayed the inevitable recession has been the persistent strength of
the US dollar. Many American tourists in Europe are shocked when they see how
inexpensive things are, in France and Germany in particular."
He said despite the economic situation, the US dollar's strength is a direct
result of deliberate actions of European and Far East Governments. They consider
a strong US dollar to be important for their own economic prosperity. Thus, they
have been buying US dollars to maintain the monetary status quo.
"By buying the dollar, it remains strong against their own currencies. Doing
this makes their goods more attractive to American buyers. However, it also
prevents the market system from automatically adjusting for the US balance of
payment deficit, when the dollar should be devalued against other world
currencies.
"Caribbean people can enjoy their good fortune now. However, when the correction
sets in, it will also affect our economies, as the US has traditionally been a
major trading partner for most countries in this hemisphere.
"Foreign goods will become more expensive and, therefore, less competitive.
Preparation for this inevitability must begin now. It is important to do the
basics - to explore ways to cut costs, improve quality, and retool to become
even more competitive, while seeking out new markets where you may have a
competitive edge."
He said that emerging economies or those that show underlying strength that have
strong currencies should be considered. Thus selective countries in Latin
America and Europe should be good targets.
Coaxed on by the uncertainty of the US presidential elections and high fuel
costs, the first signs of the recession came with the recent dramatic declines
on Wall Street, a larger than expected contraction of key economic indicators
and initial reports that the Christmas sales forecasts will not meet retailers'
targets.
Saying the American economy is "not as healthy as people think," a US
manufacturing group also urged the Federal Reserve (Fed) to cut interest rates
as early as last December to stop the nation from sinking into a recession.
"We think that the Fed's interest rate policy is more than the economy can deal
with as it begins to slow down," said Jerry Jasinowski, president of the
National Association of Manufacturers, at a news conference in early December.
"The chances of this economy going south are greater if we continue to ignore
what is happening on the economic front and we are going to see this situation
deteriorate a lot more."
Agreeing with Nilsson, Jasinowski pointed to the recent, steep drop in stock
prices, higher energy costs, uncertainty over the presidential election and the
high value of the US dollar against other currencies as issues posing a threat
to the US economy.
The Fed, citing a strong risk of inflation sapping the strength of the
blockbuster US economy, jacked up interest rates six times between June 1999 and
last May, raising short-term rates to the highest level in nearly a decade.
The Fed's rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee was scheduled to meet on
December 19 amid widespread expectations that it will leave interest rates
unchanged for the fifth meeting in a row.
But Jasinowski said this action will not be enough by the Federal Reserve. Its
post-meeting statement should at least drop the language that the powerful
central bank was still worried about inflation. This wording signals it may need
to raise rates even further.
"We would be extremely disappointed if they didn't remove that bias," he said.