Title: ALTER POSSESSION , By: Tennant, Agnieszka, Christianity Today, 00095753, 9/3/2001, Vol. 45, Issue 11Database: MAS Ultra - School Edition
ALTER POSSESSION
A DEMON--OR A SPLIT SELF?
Some 'demons' are better left unexorcised. ANY RESPECTABLE EXORCIST has heard about--if not agonized over--dissociative identity disorder (DID), an illness that sometimes resembles demonization. Consequently, many "dissociatives" stumble into the offices of exorcists and spiritual warfare counselors, who, they insist, must do something about it. Formerly known as multiple personality disorder (MPD), DID results in a person's enactment of two or more selves, sometimes called "alters." Persons with DID may have tens or hundreds of selves, more or less developed: some speak with distinct voices, and have different names, likes, and dislikes. The alters' drawings, handwriting, and accents may differ. Some of them identify themselves as demons, causing well-meaning ministers to try to cast them out.
Psychologists explain the controversial disorder in four ways, says John E. Kelley, director of Biola Counseling Center in La Mirada, California:
1. DID results from a severe trauma, which usually takes place in childhood and often surfaces through controversial "recovered" memories. DID leads to fragmentation into at least two selves (one of whom is often an abused child). That is why survivors of alleged ritual abuse are often diagnosed with DID.
2. DID is a role-playing phenomenon that may or may not be based in a real-life trauma. "Dissociatives" play different roles because they are affirmed for doing so.
3. DID is faked by people who want attention.
4. DID is born in therapy. The disorder is brought on by therapists who use suggestion (intentional and unintentional) through which they end up convincing their patients that they have dissociated identities.
A DEMON--OR A SPLIT SELF?
People with DID often attempt suicide, hear voices, see things that other people don't, and speak in strange voices that sometimes identify themselves as demons or Satan. No wonder some ministers mistake dissociation for demonic harassment.
Deliverance ministers began to learn about DID from therapists in the 1970s. One of these therapists is Jerry Mungadze, head of a group of Christian clinicians in the Dallas area who treat severe cases of dissociation and ritual abuse. Having grown up in Zimbabwe, Mungadze is no stranger to power encounters. He believes demons may harass people, but rarely. If someone exhibits symptoms of DID, suffered a trauma in childhood, shows no supernatural powers, and hasn't made pacts with the Devil, there is no need for exorcism. A deliverance session may only "antagonize the created personas," Mungadze says.
But DID and demonization aren't mutually exclusive. By detaching a person from his or her personality, the disorder may open the door to demonic harassment. Even then the safer healing route is restoration of mental health, which gives the afflicted the strength to resist demonic attacks, Mungadze says. Spiritual warfare counselors are wise to distinguish psychological disorders from demonization. But many question the so-called recovered memories of satanic ritual abuse (SRA).
"In the '80s, many dissociative patients began telling of satanic ritual abuse," Kelley says. "And once most started talking about SRA, there was a bias on part of the therapists to look for this phenomenon," Kelley says. "If genuine SRA wasn't there, the doctors would help them find it." (See "Pandora's Box of SRS," p. 54.) In counseling DID patients, Kelley became suspicious; it seemed that other therapists clearly had been suggesting fabrications to their clients. When he challenged some of them on it, at least one therapist began spreading rumors that he was a "dirty" doctor. A psychiatrist friend and a secretary confirmed that this therapist was accusing him of being a cult member.
Besides the doctor-induced cases, most DID patients Kelley treated in the 1990s seemed to be role-playing. Few of these cases were grounded in reality. Genuine trauma-based DID is much rarer than many in the deliverance scene think, Kelley says. Along with other skeptics, Kelley believes that some cases of DID could have also been "suggested" by the mass media and other forms of publicity. Rare instances of apparent dissociation were first described in the 1800s, but unprecedented numbers of DID patients were diagnosed after releases of the movie Three Faces of Eve in 1957 and the 1973 book Sybil by Flora Rheta Schreiber, so that cases peaked in the 1980s and 1990s. .~~~~~~~~By Agnieszka Tennant
Copyright of Christianity Today is the property of Christianity Today International and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.Source: Christianity Today, 9/3/2001, Vol. 45 Issue 11, p51, 1p
Go to:
Home
Main Index
Back to Commentary
