SPECIAL FROM CANADA
E-mail us at: artcanada@canada.com Att: Valerie Constand
_____________________________________________________________________
CANADIAN ARTISTS: WE
ARE CONCERNED BUT NOT ALARMED! WE DO NOT CALL PEOPLE MORONS AND BASTARDS!
Dear
Erica:
We
are concerned but not alarmed. Canadian artists do not call others morons and
bastards! We are artists not politicians. We do not wish Canadian politicians
statements to affect our business with the Americans. We have a lot of thing
going on in the United States and we do intend on preserving a good term
relationship with the American people. Both views and both sides of the story
should be made known to your readers and audience. Press clipping and our
statement are provided to be published in your magazine.
Yves
Marchand, Alain Chretien, Bernadette Rival, Tim Byron and many friends through
out Canada (Ontario, Ottawa, Quebec, etc.)
Will
do.
Parrish's apology still doesn't stifle critics
Opposition
compares comments to the Ducros 'moron' incident
|
The
Ottawa Citizen |
|
Friday, February 28, 2003
|
|
|
CREDIT: Bruno
Schlumberger, The Ottawa Citizen |
|
|
|
Rebecca
Willems, 17, who has dual Canadian-U.S. citizenship, asked Defence
Minister John McCallum how he could urge Canadians to support the U.S.
after the remarks Ms. Parrish made. |
|
|
|
|
|
Liberal
MP Carolyn Parrish apologizes for her comments about Americans in the
House of Commons, Thursday. (CP/Jonathan Hayward) |
Liberal MP Carolyn Parrish apologized to United States ambassador
Paul Cellucci yesterday for anti-American remarks she made leaving a Parliament
Hill scrum the day before.
But
while a U.S. Embassy spokesman said Mr. Cellucci accepted the apology, Ms.
Parrish's fellow parliamentarians and even one outraged Ottawa high school
student weren't so understanding. Many MPs, even inside her own party, called
her remarks unacceptable and some demanded her removal as chairwoman of a
committee on the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
The
opposition Canadian Alliance charged the Wednesday incident, when Ms. Parrish
muttered the words: "Damn Americans. Hate those bastards," after
addressing possible U.S. military action against Iraq, was part of a trend of
anti-American rhetoric within the Liberal government.
Despite
the wave of criticism about the Ontario MP's conduct, there was less agreement
on what had provoked it and what implications the resulting scandal would have
outside Canada.
"I
rise on a point of privilege," Ms. Parrish said yesterday in the House of
Commons, "to express my regret over inappropriate comments that I made
outside this House yesterday.
"These
are difficult and frustrating times for everyone," she added. "I share
a fear of imminent war experienced by many Canadians. That fear and frustration
does not justify my comments. I sincerely regret having made them and have made
a full apology to Mr. Cellucci, the ambassador to the United States."
Ms.
Parrish then avoided the reporters gathered in the lobby of the House, but the
controversy she had sparked dogged the government throughout the day.
An
Ottawa student with dual Canadian-U.S. citizenship forced Defence Minister John
McCallum to address the flak from Ms. Parrish's comment at a meeting earlier
yesterday of the Conference of Defence Associations.
Seventeen-year-old
Rebecca Willems asked Mr. McCallum how he could urge Canadians to support the
U.S. after the remarks Ms. Parrish made.
"Above
all, as American difficulties increase, we should resist any temptation to
become smug and superior," said Mr. McCallum, also quoting former prime
minister Lester Pearson.
"This
message is a particularly good message for members of Lester Pearson's party --
my party," Mr. McCallum told Ms. Willems.
"These
are dangerous times, difficult times. As Lester Pearson said, it is particularly
when the United States is at times of difficulty that we in this country should
refrain from being smug.
"We
have our differences with the Americans, as Lester Pearson did, over, for
example, Vietnam. Butwhatever our differences may be, we are friends or
allies."
Joe
Volpe, one of Ms. Parrish's fellow Ontario Liberal backbenchers, joined the
ranks of those saying her remarks weren't representative of the party at large.
Mr. Volpe suggested Parrish's comments about the looming conflict in Iraq may
have been rooted in the anti-war -- and anti-American -- feelings of a
generation of Canadians that came of age during the Vietnam War, three decades
ago.
But
Alliance foreign affairs critic Jason Kenney scoffed at such an explanation for
anti-U.S. anger.
"You
can come up with all the excuses you want," Mr. Kenney said. "When you
are a member of Parliament, operating at the national stage, you don't have the
liberty to use hate-filled language as though you were some sophomore college
member of the campus Trotsky club. This is not acceptable speech for a member of
Parliament in the government of a G-7 country."
Mr.
Kenney compared Ms. Parrish's comments to those of Françoise Ducros, the former
communications director to Prime Minister Jean Chrétien who resigned last fall
after she was overheard by reporters calling U.S. President George W. Bush a
moron.
"Just
like with Françoise Ducros, this remark is going to get coverage in the United
States," Mr. Kenney said, adding critical comments were treated differently
than largely positive speeches, such as one Mr. Chrétien made this month on a
visit to Chicago.
"Colourful,
particularly explicit statements of hatred for the United States are going to
get picked up in the United States in a way that a bland foreign policy speech
never will," Mr. Kenney said. "So, (Ms. Parrish's remark) will
resonate in the United States. But even if it didn't, an expression of hatred
for a national group, let alone that of our closest friend and ally is totally,
totally unacceptable and it's not good enough just to say that she has
apologized, it's behind us. This is part of a pattern from senior Liberals, from
members of their caucus and the prime minister has to exercise leadership."
A
spokesman in Mr. Chrétien's office said the prime minister would not be issuing
a statement. Mr. Chrétien did not stop to take reporters' questions about Ms.
Parrish during his state visit yesterday to Mexico.
In
the U.S., conservative pundit Pat Buchanan, told of Ms. Parrish' comments, fired
back at what he saw as a deteriorating Canadian-American relationship.
"Americans
don't pay a great deal of attention to Canada," Mr. Buchanan told Global
National, "but the truth is every time we hear from Canada, it's something
like the Americans are called bastards, or the president of the United States is
a moron. You get the Bush bashing, the Yankee baiting again and again. I think
Americans are coming to believe that maybe the Canadians don't like us."