MAIL: ASK ERICA

SPECIAL FROM CANADA

E-mail us at: artcanada@canada.com  Att: Valerie Constand

_____________________________________________________________________

   

CANADIAN ARTISTS: WE ARE CONCERNED BUT NOT ALARMED! WE DO NOT CALL PEOPLE MORONS AND BASTARDS!

Dear Erica:

 

We are concerned but not alarmed. Canadian artists do not call others morons and bastards! We are artists not politicians. We do not wish Canadian politicians statements to affect our business with the Americans. We have a lot of thing going on in the United States and we do intend on preserving a good term relationship with the American people. Both views and both sides of the story should be made known to your readers and audience. Press clipping and our statement are provided to be published in your magazine.

 

Yves Marchand, Alain Chretien, Bernadette Rival, Tim Byron and many friends through out Canada (Ontario, Ottawa, Quebec, etc.)

 

Will do.

 

 

Mississauga MP calls U.S. 'bastards'

 

Sheldon Alberts, Deputy Ottawa Bureau Chief

Sound Off

National Post


Thursday, February 27, 2003

CREDIT: Fred Chartrand, The Canadian Press

 

Liberal MP Carolyn Parrish quickly apologized after she was caught muttering that she hated those 'damn Americans.' She had just told reporters the U.S. was unlikely to resist attacking Iraq.

 

 

OTTAWA - The Liberal government faced new accusations of anti-Americanism yesterday after an MP who is an outspoken critic of George W. Bush said she hated Americans and called them "bastards" intent on going to war with Iraq.

_____________________________________________________________

 

 

           Carolyn Parrish, the Liberal MP for Mississauga Centre, later issued a statement apologizing for the comments, which came on a day when Jean Chrétien spoke to the U.S. President in an effort to reach a United Nations compromise in the Iraqi crisis.

"Damn Americans. Hate those bastards," Parrish said after the weekly Liberal caucus meeting in Ottawa.

Parrish made the remark at the end of a media scrum in which she told a group of journalists there was no hope Canada could negotiate a deal to avoid war because the Bush administration has no interest in peace.

"Canada has a long tradition of coming up with compromises and I think if it flies, that is excellent. But I have no hopes for it," the Toronto-area MP said. "I watched Bush [yesterday] morning on television. That man is ready to go. He doesn't care. He is gunning for a fight. I think Bush is. I think he has got 150,000 troops over there, and I think he has got to do something with them."

Senior government MPs immediately distanced themselves from Parrish's statement, and Parrish sent out a news release late yesterday attempting to clarify her remarks.

"I deeply regret the comments that I made today in the heat of the moment in a private conversation," her statement said.

"My comments do not reflect my personal opinion of the American people and they certainly do not reflect the views of the government of Canada."

Parrish insisted her remarks were made in a "private conversation," even though she was speaking to a reporter in a Parliament Hill corridor where journalists normally conduct interviews with Liberal MPs.

The Liberal government and caucus have been deeply split on the question of Iraq and mired in controversy over the U.S.'s determination to disarm Saddam Hussein, by force if necessary.

During a debate on Iraq last year, Bonnie Brown, the Liberal MP for the Toronto-area riding of Oakville, said a U.S. military attack against Iraq would be comparable to the Japanese invasion of Pearl Harbor and the Nazi aggression in Europe during the Second World War.

Chrétien's director of communications, Françoise Ducros, resigned last November after referring to Bush as "a moron" for his handling of the Iraq showdown. Since then, both Chrétien and John Manley, the Deputy Prime Minister, have warned Liberal MPs to put an end to their anti-American rhetoric.

Stephen Harper, the Canadian Alliance leader, yesterday called Parrish's comments "unacceptable" and said he fears the ongoing anti-U.S. remarks will damage Canada-U.S. relations over the long term.

"We know that kind of sentiment exists in the Liberal party. It is extremely unhelpful," Harper said.

 

© Copyright 2003 National Post

 

 

SOUNDOFF!

Post your opinions….

READERS’ OPINIONS AND LETTERS………


Thanks for giving me another reason to not take another vaca...  Enos Penningtn
I am Canadian, but..........right about now I feel ashamed a...  Linda
I am an American living in Canada. I love Canada but I was ...  Kathleen
I am of the opinion that such negative comments by any polit...  Marty
Good for her. Politics is all about expressing one's opinio...  George
How do I express my anger and disgust with this women? I wr...  Carl Twigg
Just other examples of why a) the Liberal government is comp...  Eric Maginnis
I am disgusted that with the governments constant anti-Ameri...  Mel Johns
On behalf of Canadians everywhere I'd like to offer an apolo...  Doug
(1) ... I'm sorry about your beer. I know we had nothing ...  Doug
I am appauled at the lack of respect shown to our American n...  Brian
canadins should thank god,that they have americans for neigh...  ivan mirka
I would like to apologize to our American friends, for the i...  Unknown
Politics may be about expressing opinions, but it's incumben...  Jim Myers
This is another example of the ignorance of the elected Libe...  Jim Palmer
standing up for your MP is one thing but George wrote: "Goo...  mickeyo
"Damn Americans. Hate those bastards," Parrish said after th...  RustyFord
While I do not value Ms. Parrish's sentiments, we Americans ...  Dave Narosny
The immaturity of these MPs is not so surprising -- it is di...  Peter
The really scary thing is not that yet another politician ha...  A Canadian
Most of Canada's worst are situated in and around the metrop...  Sean
She should resign! Every politician represents the people...  Plankton
I agree with what both Brian and Dave said. As for this MP, ...  Joe
Typical of Canadians. "We're sorry for....." Why are we alwa...  Jerry
Kudos to Carolyn Parrish! I couldn't agree with her more!It'...  kelly stanley
Not nice. Lucky she said that to Americans they will just f...  John
P.M.S. Another bad day at the office. I think that this can ...  Zoman
Finally a politician telling the Truth,there must be somethi...  Les F
Ms. Parrish, quite simply you are a dumb ass. . . for a woma...  Mark Low
If the remarks do not reflect her personal opinion or the vi...  Tammy
Finally a politician telling the Truth,there must be somethi...  eilsel elyaf
If this woman has any decency at all. She should resign imm...  Tom
To Kelly I would love to meet you, seeing that I am an Am...  Kathleen
Mrs. Parrish's comments although upsetting were personal. Th...  Tanya S. Celestine
The MP's Comments should be put in context. It was a private...  Abdul
"HATE" is a crime, when perpetrated against a minority. MP P...  W.R.Wodlinger
It's actually quite comical It's easy to be overly critical...  jp
I wish more people would speak as frankly. The retraction d...  Judas Diomedes
Where is outrage ?. Duyya is hell-bent on visiting death & d...  Ab
I am an American. And you know what? This doesn't bother me ...  Kevin
As much as I don't like to be called a bastard, I have to sa...  Jake
You know what... If you people are gonna dwell on her statem...  J. Roberts

Ridiculous!! I think she had full right with the comments s...  Carrie
I wonder how much money is sent to Canada from the US? I'll...  Barry Boniface
If her calling us "bastards" is bad...you guys would hate to...  Doug
I always liked Canada and the Canadian people. But like your...  American
What is the issue here? I have 2 points: 1)For an MP (or any...  Pat Lawless
Hey Kelly Stanley, "Name: kelly stanley Occupation: ...  Atlanta BOB
I am American, and she was right. She has nothing to apologi...  Chuck Kallenbach
Ahh...Canadian politician's own comments don't reflect own v...  John Wade
I am a Canadian living in Washington DC, USA. I was deeply ...  Rick Smith
I am amazed at the type of words that came of this "honourab...  Christianah Olarewaju
How can the MP possibly claim that the opinion expressed was...  M Heins
You know, the US is the biggest guy on the block, so when so...  Steve Kilp
Dear Canadians, I know Canada. I love Canada. The actions...  Damon
I believe that this MP really should have apologized for get...  Brian Dorman
Good grief. Who cares what she said? I sure don't. Hell, I a...  Jeremy Reeves
Hmmm... Time to add Canada to the "Axis of Evil," right aft...  Bubba
This just proves to me that French Canadians are more French...  Col Angus
Im a Norwegian and i pee`d myself laughing reading this arti...  Gen76
This is why Canada doesn't get much respect from the U.S. an...  Rich
We teach our children to recpect each other. We teach our c...  Judy
As a Canadian by birth, and being brought up in America call...  Piers
one person one comment everybody calm down...  paul
Reason number 473 why we should annex Canada and make it our...  Spooda
My apologies to our American neighbours for the utterances o...  Laurence
Good for her, expressing what so many Canadians feel about t...  Maury Richards
The point of her comment was at our Foreign policy and leade...  Steve
I'm an American living in Canada, and I say WELL DONE. It's ...  Jaminy Jackson
As I've heard so often: "You're good people, but we're sorry...  Amerikanski
You know, I really don't care what this woman thinks. She's...  Paul
Parrish should resign or be fired A.S.A.P. We don't need id...  Gerald Clark
I think Carolyn Parrish needs to be reminded just how many t...  Gilbert Conti
As a reluctant american who is planning to move to Canada al...  Katsushiro
It seems that Canadian liberals are afflicted with the same ...  Nelson Phillips
Good for her! I'm opposed to war and politics is about opini...  Mike
I have no problem with what your MP said. For the most part...  Rayn
As an American, I wish there were more politicians here who ...  Fred Thompson
I feel that Canadians like us so long as we keep showing up ...  Heidi Kramer
Hell, she will get promoted into cabinet now that she has th...  Jay
I LOVE that she spoke her mind. as an american i hate Bush t...  Vesselle
Doug Get real and grow up with your beer, hockey and bur...  Kathleen
Well, wasn't that cute. Another self-important politician fr...  Maizan
i just want to say that most americans are bastards and she ...  andy
Comments such as these are regretable no matter who makes th...  Douglas Pierce
Attention all Canuckistanis: Please cleanup Iraq once we're...  W
I will keep my "hated american" money in america from now ow...  American
I don't see anything wrong with what she said. She didn't i...  Rev. Christian R.
I'm an American so what if she thinks we're a bunch of basta...  Scott
i am an american and i see only one thing wrong with Carolyn...  ryan
OH! You're still there Canada?! Almost forgot you existed ...  Alex
It's so nice to know that all Americans were blobbed so eloq...  Kimberly
As an American I am more insulted by this part of the story:...  Michael Hunt
I was very disturbed with the comments that we are all writi...  Dennis Green
"My comments do not reflect my personal opinion"?!?! What DO...  Mat
A politician with such a venemous attitude towards a friend ...  Alex
She should totally resign. What an ignorant thing to say! ...  Lisa
Inexusable. This lady should resign from the Parliament and...  Robert
Well...If she hates the US so much I assume that she wants n...  Chimp Jones
I may be a bastard. But I still don't look as ugly as her!...  LewisinUSA
Get over it already! and learn how to spell. You know who ...  canadian
Dear US Customs, Please do not allow Carolyn Parrish to cro...  Bryan
ask the dead gased kurds what kind of basterds supports her ...  elio polselli
I am not American or Canadian. I live in the US and I've hea...  Bharath
If we start publishing stories everytime a Canadian politici...  Peter W.
She hates us? How quaint. While I do consider the current US...  John
"OH! You're still there Canada?! Almost forgot you existed b...  amy
Please email Jean Chretien at pm@pm.gc.ca to demand that dis...  M MacDonald
To all Americans - please accept our apology for Ms Parrish'...  Mea Culpa
Let's not forget where MOST of these terrorists are getting ...  Hunter
It's time for me to give up my Canadian citizenship and beco...  Trevor Woodhouse
A bigot by any other name? Imagine if we substituted the wo...  Rose Flem-Ath
To all those Canadian and Amereican liberals, "Get off your ...  dean
She's right about my government's agressive, obnoxious, bell...  Gerald Etkind
Carolyn Parrish has an interesting view of the world. Does ...  Donald Weld
please deflate your egos and relax. A woman spoke her mind ...  melanie
I just want to comment on Doug's response. Very Well said. I...  Dan O
I am not ashamed of this person for remarking this for it is...  Colin Roth
As one of those "bastards" who also is a Canadian by choice ...  Georges Rodier
Another stupid comment by another stupid Liberal. ...  Brian Lager
If the Liberal Party can't say anything nice about our south...  O. Calhoun
Is this news-worthy? We continue to elect these stooges who...  Duffy
Why does it take only one bad apple to spoil the whole the w...  C.E.Grigg
Unfortunately it looks as if Mississauga needs a new MP. Su...  Cliff
As a Canadian citizen living in central Texas, I can only ...  Peter H. Salus
She only bashed the US government, not Americans in general....  Rob Forrest
If this woman has a shred of decency (which is doubtful), sh...  grant
Wrong choice of words correct sentiment. I think a lot more ...  ERIKA
Thats OK- 41% of Americans would like to go to war with Cana...  Larry
Ok children! Stop right there!!! Everyone take a deep breath...  Clive
Typical Liberal 'foot in mouth' disease! Thank you to all of...  Mark
Of course, Parrish's comments were hateful and meaningless. ...  Darrell
Why is this person still a MP? But then again why is J.C. st...  D Reid
After sparsely following the politics of your nation over th...  Brandon
Junk, that's the only way to describe our Liberal party. Sof...  Thomas Madill
I apologize to any Americans offended by this jackass. Furth...  Darrell
Every body up there. Relax, were used to boneheaded polit...  Dan V.
The remark made by Mississauga Liberal MP Carolyn Parrish, r...  David Brethauer
While the time and place were unfortunate, Carolyn Parrish h...  Dolores Hardtman
I'm American - She is absolutely right. George Bush is a cor...  P
I don't think we americans should make much of this(and we p...  bob
As an American, most people would say I should be offended. ...  Ryan Graham
This woman should resign immediately. She is too stupid to e...  T. Wilson
this whole thing is getting out of control. do i agree that ...  chris
part 2 i don't see bush appoligising to canada or our pm fo...  chris
This woman is a complete and utter fool. How she got voted i...  Tony Moscioni
So not just in the US but now in Canada too, people are not ...  Bill Mahaffey
How do we elect these big - mouthed , insensitive , self rig...  gerry breen
Another ignorant comment from another ignorant, holier-tha...  Jon Van Hulstein
You can't fault anyone for their opinions because they are j...  Patricia Core
I think her comments were spot on, she's addressing the admi...  mh
I am not sure what abhors me the most...her childish and pet...  Mike Deutsch
It's unfortunate that an elected official for Canada would m...  Dave
Anti-american sentiment? What, because she's not blind? I ...  Ochressandro Rettinger
Even families will have disagreements and sometimes resort t...  Don
Well Jerry from Mississauga, you write,"As far as I'm concer...  James
Once again we hear the Americans being spoken of in a very n...  Agnes Hutchison
It is despicable that a MP would dare say something like thi...  Joel Timmerman
As a Canadian now living in the States, I am deeply embarras...  Michelle
As an American, I am outraged at the constant portrayal of o...  Ally Horton
Carolyn Parrish is a stupid, lying pig. I hate her. Oh, I...  Oops, I'm a Liberal
I feel the same as this MP about the American Government. J...  Betty Henshaw
finally soneone with the balls to say something about bush a...  gerald
If the Americans are bastards, what does that make Saddam? O...  Ron
Racism is a criminal offense. If i said.. French.. bastards...  Ctyrner
I'm an American, and not to worried about the statement. Sh...  USN Sailor
I've just sat here and read a list of emotionally stirring c...  Scared stiff
I am ashamed as well and I almost feel like moving to the st...  Andrea
Well, this BASTARD won't be going to Canada anymore. I grew...  Darin Decator
The honourable MP's comments sting, but most of us in Americ...  Jack Brannelly
I appreciate the perception of Michelle [Canadian now in Flo...  John Patzwall
Americans are bastards? Is this idiot on record anywhere wit...  eric s
It wasn't right for her to call the American people bastard...  Dustin
While I do not agree with her statements, I support her righ...  Dr Caleb
to Mr. Larry from Seattle. read his comments people cause th...  Natalie
She is absolutely "right". I am a peaceloving citizen of Ca...  Shoukat Hassan
Obviously I can't speak for everyone here in the US, but I t...  Mike Hansen
Good for her expressing her opinions. Americans should look ...  Mike
Love it.And to all you Americans living and liking it here,d...  Jolly Roger
Well, truth is, we are kinda bastards. I'm sure she didn't ...  David Reed
A liberal MP from a major Canadian city says "Hate the Ameri...  Jennifer
"My comments do not reflect my personal opinion of the Ameri...  S. Cwalinski
I guess "She calls them the way she sees them" but we should...  Keith Yule
I have lived in Mississauga for 22 years and must say I am t...  unhappy
I agree with the comments made by this MP. Americans are ba...  Conrad
Thanks be to God! Another Canadian who is not willing to sac...  Paul Kauler
I have had the pleasure of visiting Canada on a number of oc...  Keith
Hey, that guy is a bastard, and I'm American. More people sh...  Dumar Field
Hmmmm, Mr. Kauler, perhaps you should consider cutting off o...  David Reed
Is it wrong to be dissenter or have a strong opinion north o...  John Molseed
I live in Vancouver (I am currently visiting the U.S.) and...  Kim
Bush is a bastard, and keep in mind that we Americans didn't...  Lisa
I can't believe how hostile some Americans are. Relax this i...  Judith
makes you wonder what the average canadian thinks as she is ...  dan
And to think they had a cow about OLD EUROPE....  Justin Time
posted previously: >Name: > D Reid > E-mail: >...  Proud Canadian
As a Canadian I am ashamed that such a person is an Member o...  Steven Ivanyi
Damn Polititians, I hate those Bastards! Please MR. Bush, af...  Darren
What are your politicians smoking Ontario? Get with it and v...  Robert Anderson
All of you socialist liberals whining about this war being a...  Gary Bateman
I think what Parrish said was wrong. However Americans need...  Geoff
This Member of our government ought to really know what she ...  Henry Walker
That comment is just another example of the uneducated, inex...  Greg
Nobody wants a war. Peace can only work through the realisti...  Tom Trussell
That MP is an idiot. The US should bomb Iraq and then tur...  Stephen
That MP is an idiot. The US should bomb Iraq and then tur...  Stephen
I have reviewed many of the sounds offs directed to this sto...  Free thinking Canadain
americans and canadians have always been saying rude things ...  na
FREE SPEECH? What a joke. We hear our politicians talk ofte...  Dave Wong
Politics is about Diplomacy, NOT FREE OPINION!...  Ryan W.
This MP should be thrown out for such a remark. I persona...  Stephen
You know I've read some of these responses, and It's amazing...  C_Mr_Anderson
You know I've read some of these responses, and It's amazing...  C_Mr_Anderson
WarMongers? Killing innocent people.....arrogant....hillbill...  john
Here is my two cents: It was unprofessional and political...  Kim in AZ
Consider the source. A backbench MP who has no authority or...  jartann
That finishes Carolyn Parrish's career. The liberal caucus ...  Jim Butterfield
To my friends up North, Fear not, Americans who think don...  Jim
Can you imagine if a U.S. congressman/congresswoman or senat...  tom
I wonder what would happen to someone who expressed similar ...  Mark Huson
I would want to know from the responsible authorities of Can...  A.S. Kang
It's fine if she disagrees with Bush and dislikes the Americ...  Tracy Smith
When will Canadian politicians stop putting there feet in t...  Derek
Thanks to all our good brothers and sisters up north who exp...  steph
I am always amazed at how arrogant and small minded these so...  Don Mills
Wow, let me see, our largest trading partner is preparing fo...  eric lange
As an American, I apologize for some of the reactionary comm...  Greg
Why don't you send this MP your comments here is her email a...  SB
RELAX you Conucks and fellow Yanks! She's just reverting to ...  Harold
Good for her. It's about time us Canadians hold the fort ag...  Cory
Here we go again Is there any politicians in Canada that don...  Lowell Kinnee
I couldn't agree more! Bush hasn't tried for peace - he real...  Owen Wiltshire
I will not apologize for this mp. she made her bed she can l...  Rene
I am a PROUD American married to a Canadian living in the GT...  Lisa
I am an American. we are awful. Destestable also. I despise ...  Patrick Evans
I am a PROUD American married to a Canadian living in the GT...  Lisa
Well...Ms MP...not all Americans are "bastards" and not al...  jim sandrin
Politics and diplomacy are based on FREE OPINION, dummy....  Gregory
I'm an American, and I think it's great that someone, somewh...  Dan
I can't believe how many ignorant Canadians there are. Firs...  Cameron
I wish our government would have more of a backbone and do s...  LJ
I'm sorry to hear that you hate us. Maybe you'd like us more...  John
She's a member of the gov't. It's obvious she said those rem...  Mike
Thanks! Another great Canadian polititian stating the truth...  Frank Furter
I find it hard to believe that the Canadian Governm...  Michael Farling
I find it hard to believe that the Canadian Governm...  Michael Farling
Parrish, do us all a favour and resign. Should have happened...  RH Berrrras
Canadians are upset about the comments made by Parrish becau...  Nichola McEwan
I think she should be charged with hate propaganda against A...  monkeywrench
She should be sent to the front line with the US Army. Comme...  Keith Pugsley
Remember1812 .........  Joe Canuck
The guy who is STILL talking about their hockey win, the sof...  Lisa
My uncle was thinking about investing over 5 million in Miss...  George
I am a Canadian living in the U.S. for the past four years. ...  BB
Canadians are just pissed because the entire international c...  Maranda
As a Canadian who happens to like my Southern neighbour, or ...  Don Harris
Granted America is the most hated country in the world, But...  Alex
To the entire pro-American camp here saying, "You'll be begg...  Doug
Who cares what she said privately? Certainly not George Bush...  Gary
In the heat of the moment Carolyn Parrish did voice her sent...  Desdemona
I can't belive people are actually UPSET. Her comments were ...  Matt
With all this "God Bless America" crap creeping up in here, ...  Doug
I'm sick and tired of these childish and petty remarks by ou...  Amanda
What can we expect from this Air-Head she as all liberals ca...  Jim Brindle
SHAMEFUL and discusting. Unforgiveable remarks. This woman...  Cindy Evenwel
This reminds me of an incident where the great American auth...  Jeff Thorp
Abdul wrote "It was a private conversation..." I don't know...  George
What is it going to take to get rid of these buffoons in Ott...  Robert
I guess they should shut down the border between Canada and ...  Howard
Message to Doug #1 are you too ashamed to show you name unde...  James Brindle
RustyFord, you should get your facts right before conjecturi...  Tom V
As a proud Canadian who happens to like the American people ...  Proud Canadian
Ms.Parrish, Some of us don't care much for you either...  Peter B
I second her thoughts. Stand up and don't apologise to the m...  Irving Bush
One more thought, the French and Germans have an ult...  Michael Farling
I totally agree with her. Bush was not able to get Osma so ...  Gulzar Kanji
I'm an American and am pretty much as opposed to the war as ...  Adam B.
Nothing happens in a vacuum. Although she is in a position ...  Steve
I would like to express my deepest apologies to our friends ...  Rob Evenwel
i do not agree with what the member said ..however i am not ...  al
"Let's give 'em a fair trial & then hang 'em." "Let's send ...  Chris Damico
She's right, at least about our bosses. Most of us don't agr...  Foster Christiansen
i do not agree with what the member said ..however i am not ...  al
Carolyn Parrish is an embarrasment to canada and the canadia...  jackmaclean
Please recall your modern history. Appeasement has never wor...  Tim Rambo
Sheesh. The least she could do is grow a spine and stand be...  Edd
i'm an american, and i agree with her. americans are fat, l...  james
The leaders of any given country would kill off all of the p...  zakal
Hi, I am Brit who has lived in Canada for 30 years. I'm as...  Mike Visser
"Keep electing MPs like this and us American bastards will g...  james
I AM ASHAMED of thinking that this is the image we project ...  Louise B.
Ok, who's worse-- the first bastard, or the bastard who suck...  David
Boo-hoo to those people expressing shame over Ms Parrish's r...  Brad Dean
Carolyn Parrish got it right the Americans couldn't care a l...  WEB
I hope that someday Canada (my native country) doesn't need ...  E. Burrock
Americans are bastards?! Hey im American, and DAMN proud of ...  Sally
Enos from the US: Boo-hoo...stay home....  Brad Dean
So when are they (us gov't) bastards,is it when they have st...  irvin walkes
This is just another typical disgusting and shamefull comm...  joe lyons
How dare you call us bastards?! I am an American and DAMN pr...  Rebecca
This completely embarasses me. 95% of the people I speak to...  Indyglow
What do you expect from a party that lacks intestinal forti...  Rick Martin
I can understand where the frustration comes from. I hope t...  Jill
She's a moron, but then so's her leader and every liebral in...  George
Here is the email address of the member of Canada's Parlimen...  Ed
Bush - you go girl I love Americans. They have great manne...  Sarah T
TYPICAL USELESS POLITICIAN, another pig feeding from the tax...  T.Ryan
Shamed again by another empty headed anti-American Liberal ...  TMuir
Living in Detroit I (we) feel an "brotherhood" of sorts with...  Scott
To all the kind Canadians on this forum who have repudiated ...  John
Quote: "Carolyn Parrish got it right the Americans couldn't ...  Lessa
Living in Detroit I (we) feel an "brotherhood" of sorts with...  Scott
It is sad to see that an MP has to apologize for his/her hon...  brian Tynedal
One of Canada's liberal back bencher said something that sho...  concerned
"Damn liberals"-"I hate those bastards"! *oh..opps sorry .....  robertcummings
I can't accurately express my anger at Canada without cursin...  Craydon
As an American I am happy that our Candian neighbors enj...  Martin Wade
Free speech is cherished in North America,however I take exc...  Rick
To the anonymous "Canadian Engineer" who believes that "most...  Anthony Leva
WE SHOULD ATTACK CANADA INSTEAD OF IRAQ. YOU BUNCH OF SELFI...  Ted Abrams
It's hard to believe we have let these elected fools go on f...  Sean Mullin
She has the right to say her opinion but it has to be more p...  Laith Ali
AMERICANS, Please save us from ourselves. We love the stat...  Lynda
Never mind being angry, I'm *grateful*. Canada should be pro...  Laughing Boy
One question who prevents Canada from being invaded? and s...  Larry
I think this knuckle brain Liberal government should be utte...  Whirler
I wish to apologise to my American neighbors for the stupid ...  Anselm
An American in Dundas. I was so sad to read about the commen...  Nan Garbett
It's time this country made a stand. A war will kill Canada...  Jason Perry
You know, she's right. Just plain correct. In world politics...  damian wendy
It's time this country made a stand. A war will kill Canada...  Jason Perry
Just another family characteristic common to both the U.S. a...  Tom Pehl
We don't much care what kanadian politicians think of us. ...  A D Buck
To Rebecca; blindly supporting your president does NOT make...  momma
Big Deal, she is only telling the truth. And to me "bastard...  O. Hofer
And I see that your politicians are fat, ugly bastards. Oh ...  DAve Sifers
We have endured a lot in our country since 9\11. Terrorist a...  BobbyD
Lets breed your ugly fat bastard MP with our bastard Clinto...  dave
How dare you? Placed in a public position and knowingly whi...  Tony
I feel embarassed and ashamed to hear our honarable M.P. mak...  Shadab E. Khokhar
Canadians,don't feel bad about Ms Parrish's remarks. She's a...  Another one of those ignorant bastards
quit now! my tax dollars were not intended to pay someone t...  derek
This is another example of what a laughing matter our politi...  James
It is about time politicians in Ottawa aren't bending backwa...  Chelsea
Bravo to Carolyn Parrish on her comments on the american ad...  b clayton
I am so sorry that someone actually dared to criticize the A...  Cathy
I am an American, I have a boorish President that shoots his...  Joseph Burke
What I would like to know is where are all the protesters ag...  Jim
George the farmer, learn how to spell "liberal" and "wait", ...  Canadian
I was certainly disappointed with her statement, but after r...  Miles Lunn
From where I sit I see no reason for her to appologize to p...  Georges Dubois
I can assure you that if she would have made those comments ...  E Robichaud.
Americans have long felt strongly about free speach. Give u...  G
I would hope that most of our friends to the south would rea...  Rob
What is wrong with our politicians!!!She IS supposed to be a...  wendy
My daughter's Spring Break from college is next week. We ha...  Susan
Carolyn Parrish obviously knows the rules when speaking in p...  j robinson
To all those people out there who have stated in this Forun,...  Louise
Bullies , Bastards and Cowards they act like the school yard...  Stan
Fire her ass. I mean how much good can a closed minded old w...  Steve
So someone has shown disresepect to America? I'm pretty sure...  Matt
she is absolutely right, dont judge her,americans are the ag...  tonia
Before anyone criticizes this woman too deeply, consider Don...  Levi Haynes
As an American living in Canada for 25 years. I have run int...  Harold Lampcov
You idiot, Parrish....  Vaughn Faithe
I am shocked and appalled by Ms. Parrish's comments. She sho...  Rob McLennan
I am a Cdn living in the US and am embarrassed by these rema...  Paul Gover
I think she must have been misquoted. I think what she proba...  Jeff Critch
While I regret the remark directed at the American people; i...  momma
Wow. Somebody is bashing america again? no suprise. While i ...  Erik
Remember the ASIAN CONTATION comment an Alliance hopeful mad...  Earl Porteous
I'm an American and all this fussing about anti-American rhe...  l romero
America is Canada's best friend and staunchest ally. They ar...  Dale Cockx
When Canada becomes a world superpower, and stands up for hu...  Dave
It's about time someone spoke their mind. We're all thinkin...  Brad
For the third time in my life, I've agreed with something a ...  B. von Schirach
Living as close to the canadian border as i have, i have nev...  Robert Edmondson
This U.S. citizen thinks Ms. Parrish's analysis of Bush's pr...  Christopher
This U.S. citizen thinks Ms. Parrish's analysis of Bush's pr...  Christopher
And again a "reportable"Canadian has bashed the Americans. ...  Ted
As a former Canadian living in the US, I am embarassed. Sub...  Susanne Nielsen
to 'doug' 1. We DIDN'T elect Bush president.. the electo...  Hanky
I can see how someone would feel that way about Americans, a...  Martin Super
This Canadian citizen thinks Ms. Parrish's analysis of Bush'...  Patel Ramesh
I think we should not let the small things get in our way of...  NME360
This 'lady' lacks CLASS but then again her boss sets the exa...  Ralf Sellmer
A previous poster pointed out that American politicians have...  Ron
Thank you. Now I can change my bumper sticker to : FIRST IR...  Peter Barnes

 

 

MORE NEWS COVERAGE 

Parrish's apology still doesn't stifle critics

Opposition compares comments to the Ducros 'moron' incident

The Ottawa Citizen

 


Friday, February 28, 2003

CREDIT: Bruno Schlumberger, The Ottawa Citizen

 

Rebecca Willems, 17, who has dual Canadian-U.S. citizenship, asked Defence Minister John McCallum how he could urge Canadians to support the U.S. after the remarks Ms. Parrish made.

 

Liberal MP Carolyn Parrish apologizes for her comments about Americans in the House of Commons, Thursday. (CP/Jonathan Hayward)

Liberal MP Carolyn Parrish apologized to United States ambassador Paul Cellucci yesterday for anti-American remarks she made leaving a Parliament Hill scrum the day before.

But while a U.S. Embassy spokesman said Mr. Cellucci accepted the apology, Ms. Parrish's fellow parliamentarians and even one outraged Ottawa high school student weren't so understanding. Many MPs, even inside her own party, called her remarks unacceptable and some demanded her removal as chairwoman of a committee on the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.

The opposition Canadian Alliance charged the Wednesday incident, when Ms. Parrish muttered the words: "Damn Americans. Hate those bastards," after addressing possible U.S. military action against Iraq, was part of a trend of anti-American rhetoric within the Liberal government.

Despite the wave of criticism about the Ontario MP's conduct, there was less agreement on what had provoked it and what implications the resulting scandal would have outside Canada.

"I rise on a point of privilege," Ms. Parrish said yesterday in the House of Commons, "to express my regret over inappropriate comments that I made outside this House yesterday.

"These are difficult and frustrating times for everyone," she added. "I share a fear of imminent war experienced by many Canadians. That fear and frustration does not justify my comments. I sincerely regret having made them and have made a full apology to Mr. Cellucci, the ambassador to the United States."

Ms. Parrish then avoided the reporters gathered in the lobby of the House, but the controversy she had sparked dogged the government throughout the day.

An Ottawa student with dual Canadian-U.S. citizenship forced Defence Minister John McCallum to address the flak from Ms. Parrish's comment at a meeting earlier yesterday of the Conference of Defence Associations.

Seventeen-year-old Rebecca Willems asked Mr. McCallum how he could urge Canadians to support the U.S. after the remarks Ms. Parrish made.

"Above all, as American difficulties increase, we should resist any temptation to become smug and superior," said Mr. McCallum, also quoting former prime minister Lester Pearson.

"This message is a particularly good message for members of Lester Pearson's party -- my party," Mr. McCallum told Ms. Willems.

"These are dangerous times, difficult times. As Lester Pearson said, it is particularly when the United States is at times of difficulty that we in this country should refrain from being smug.

"We have our differences with the Americans, as Lester Pearson did, over, for example, Vietnam. Butwhatever our differences may be, we are friends or allies."

Joe Volpe, one of Ms. Parrish's fellow Ontario Liberal backbenchers, joined the ranks of those saying her remarks weren't representative of the party at large. Mr. Volpe suggested Parrish's comments about the looming conflict in Iraq may have been rooted in the anti-war -- and anti-American -- feelings of a generation of Canadians that came of age during the Vietnam War, three decades ago.

But Alliance foreign affairs critic Jason Kenney scoffed at such an explanation for anti-U.S. anger.

"You can come up with all the excuses you want," Mr. Kenney said. "When you are a member of Parliament, operating at the national stage, you don't have the liberty to use hate-filled language as though you were some sophomore college member of the campus Trotsky club. This is not acceptable speech for a member of Parliament in the government of a G-7 country."

Mr. Kenney compared Ms. Parrish's comments to those of Françoise Ducros, the former communications director to Prime Minister Jean Chrétien who resigned last fall after she was overheard by reporters calling U.S. President George W. Bush a moron.

"Just like with Françoise Ducros, this remark is going to get coverage in the United States," Mr. Kenney said, adding critical comments were treated differently than largely positive speeches, such as one Mr. Chrétien made this month on a visit to Chicago.

"Colourful, particularly explicit statements of hatred for the United States are going to get picked up in the United States in a way that a bland foreign policy speech never will," Mr. Kenney said. "So, (Ms. Parrish's remark) will resonate in the United States. But even if it didn't, an expression of hatred for a national group, let alone that of our closest friend and ally is totally, totally unacceptable and it's not good enough just to say that she has apologized, it's behind us. This is part of a pattern from senior Liberals, from members of their caucus and the prime minister has to exercise leadership."

A spokesman in Mr. Chrétien's office said the prime minister would not be issuing a statement. Mr. Chrétien did not stop to take reporters' questions about Ms. Parrish during his state visit yesterday to Mexico.

In the U.S., conservative pundit Pat Buchanan, told of Ms. Parrish' comments, fired back at what he saw as a deteriorating Canadian-American relationship.

"Americans don't pay a great deal of attention to Canada," Mr. Buchanan told Global National, "but the truth is every time we hear from Canada, it's something like the Americans are called bastards, or the president of the United States is a moron. You get the Bush bashing, the Yankee baiting again and again. I think Americans are coming to believe that maybe the Canadians don't like us."