Now im sure that some where on the net you've read atleast one or two of these theorie's.I will go on record as saying that I don't beleave in these 100% I do keep in mind that Kevin Williamson had all three movie's in mind while writting the first one.So it's possible that he had it planned for someone to be tagging along since the begining.
Neil Prescott a killer? In the first movie he was out of town on buisness.Then as the movie begin's to aproach it's climax his car is found down the road from Stu's house.Later Stu pull's his tied and gagged body up from the basement.Now Stu's parent's were out of town on the night of the party,but were they from the beginning? If not then how would Stu stash Mr.Prescott in the basement?Say he wasn't in the basement the whole time.Then where? In the school bathroom scene,the ghost faced killer wore black jeen's. Billy and Stu were seen minute's before wearing blue jeen's and cacky's.No time to change.But also in this scene you can hear Billy's voice in a whisper.So who know's???????? In SCREAM 2 he is out of te country on buisness and can't be located. SOUND'S FISHY !!!!!!!!!!!
Now here's the Randy theory.Some people seem to think that Randy Meek's faked his death in SCREAM 2 with a little help ofcourse.So could it of been Billy , Stu and Randy ? What about when Billy shot Randy at the end of SCREAM ? Was Billy a bad shot or was he aiming for that shoulder ? Again the school bathroom scene could be explained here. In SCREAM 2 Randy and Mickey had a lot of the same intrest.Could killing be one of them ? Billy and Stu wanted a sequel.Could they of gotten Randy to back them up incase their plan's got screwed up? I'm sure it must of been pretty hard on Randy to be in love with Sidney for all those year's and not be able to act on his feeling's.Randy was working on the night that Steve and Casey were killed.Randy worked in the video store,Casey rented those scary movies she was getting ready to watch,when she got a call from you know who.Why didn't Randy say anything about seeing her in the video store?Maybe she rented the movies days before,maybe Randy was on break or just didn't see her.So people say that Randy will reveale himself as the killer in SCREAM 3 and tell the whole story.Anyways,didn't we think Billy Loomis was dead,when he was atacked in Stu's parentnts room?Both of those death scenes were not shot very well.Randy's was just completely off camera.When they do somthing like that off camera,its usealy for a reason. Truthfully I think these people just find it a little hard to beleave that Randy is dead.I know I was pissed at the movie theater.
Dewey Riliey.Could Woodsboro's finest be a killer? Think about it Dewey was a police officier in Woodsboro.He had all the axcess needed.Notice in SCREAM & SCREAM 2 he never come's in contact with the unmasked killer at the end of the movie.All of the other survivour's was but not Dewey.Why? Dewey alway's only come's in contact with ghostface.He is alway's attacted but never die's.In SCREAM Dewey had a little stab in the back.Dewey and only Dewey say's it coused a severd nerve.In SCREAM 2 Dewey is stabbed all up and down his body but still walk's away(so to speak).Again this could explain the school bathroom scene.In the scene in SCREAM 2 when Dewey and Gale are checking Gale's tape's trieing to spot the killer at the crime scene's.Doesn't Dewey point up at the killer with his bad hand?
Murray Esler's Dewey theory.
SCREAM 1
Dewey has a motive. No one takes him seriously. Espescially Tatum, and in the scene in the police station Dewey shakes her violently when she calls him deputy Dewey boy. Notice that when Dewey is in the party, Tatum is killed. Billy hasn't arrived yet. The audience assumes that Stu is responsible, but when Gale watches herself leave the party on the monitor in the van, Dewey is not with her. He's only just left the garage.
When Sydney is being chased by the killer in her own house. She calls 911 via computer. She never sends her call because the killer disapears and then Billy enters the room. She is distracted. When she runs out Dewey is standing at the door with the mask. How did he know to come. And besides, she lived in the middle of nowhere. The police would take a long time to arrive on the scene.
When Sydney is at Tatum's, she recives a call from the killer. Mrs Rileybangs on Dewey's door asking him to come out. It shouldn't have taken him long. But he waits untill immediately after the killer hangs up untill he comes racing to the rescue.
Dewey and the girls get out of the car and Sydney says the town looks like "the town that feared sundown". Dewey gleafully replies that he has seen that movie. Dewey watches horror movies. He than tells the girls not to go too far. They leave and head for the supermarket. As they go past the fridge we see the killer in the reflection. The fridge is full of ice cream. The next time we see Dewey he is sucking on an ice cream. I know it's a long shot that he bought a tub, bought a pack of cones and then put one scoop of ice cream in one cone and discarded the rest, but serial killers sometimes act funny. The sherrif asks him what took him so long. Dewey replies that he was keeping an eye on Sydney. He wasn't lying, he just neglected the part about him being out of sight and in a ghost costume.
There is a forboding close up on the Sherrifs black shoes. Earlier we have seen the same shoes in the toilet cubicle. Now, there's a vague chance that the sherrif was involved but I think for all extensive purposes we can rule him out. But, Dewey would have the same shoes issued to him as the sherrif would.
Dewey was going to kill Gale when he took her into the forest, but he didn't because he kind of liked her. Even Billy thought she was dead.
All of the victims recieve pretty brutal treatment from the killers, but Dewey is only stabbed in the back. Once! He then gives the same schmaltsy act that Billy gives when he pretends to die. He calls out Sydney's name and then drops to the floor. Sydney runs to Dewey's car and hops in. The killer then from nowhere produces Dewey's keys. Where did he get them? Just stab Dewey and as he's hobling away reach into his pocket and take them?
SCREAM 2
Dewey is now a cripple. When Derek's arm is slashed Dewey saves the day and wraps him up in bandages, using his bad arm no less. And when in pursuit of a killer on a cellular phone, Dewey puts himself last and props himself up on a ledge with his arm so he can dive down on a suspect.
In a rage he tells Gale that he may be using his cute exterior as a way of fooling others into believing he is what he isn't. I think he was telling the truth.
When Randy asks him what's up with his limp as he was only stabbed in the back, Dewey aggresively replies: :"Severed nerve!" It was just a question.
I don't see a reason to get angry about it.
THE PROOF!!!!!
In Scream, Billy says to Sydney that they are going to make it look like her father shot himself in the head. Stu chimes in saying, "I thought of that part." This shows that it was not a spur of the moment descision, it was in their plan all along. But the gun belonged to Dewey. He wasn't an invited guest. They shouldn't have known he was going to be there, but if he wasn't, they had no way to shoot the father in the head. Dewey, was in on it.
Jonothon Mitchell's short Gail theory.
It is rumoured that Sidney and Gail are sisters, and that Their mom abandoned Gail when she was born. Which leads up to my killer theory I think Gail is the killer because of all the trauma she went through after being abandoned. And she wants revenge on Sidney.
Now these could be blooper's but with a cast like this and a director like Wes Craven that's almost impossible. If you have any THIRD KILLER THEORIE'S that you would like to share please Email me.Thank you
