11-9-2005

Ms Fanny Law's replies

I wrote an e-mail message, quite a long letter actually, to Ms Fanny Law, the Permanent Secretary of the Education and Manpower Bureau, on the last day of August and another on the fourth of this month. Her prompt replies reached me in a few days respectively. Her efficiency and willingness to take the trouble to send personal replies to an unknown teacher really touched me.

The first letter, with a letter to the editor of SCMP attached, is about encouraging social leaders, especially teachers, to read English books and watch English films. The letter to the Editor was published in SCMP on 3-9-2005. The second one sent to her is about specific suggestions.

The letter to the Editor of SCMP (8-2005)

Despite the poor standards of my students¡¦ English and the obvious difficulty in helping them to get high marks, the SBA, which is the new Cert English syllabus component accounting for 15% of the total subject mark requiring candidates to give four oral reviews about two books and two films has my full support. At last, the reform is taking our future generations in the right track in language learning. However, there is no funding for resources such as books and films, for all things related to filming candidates¡¦ assessments as records for marks moderation, or for technical and clerical support. Guidelines are far from clear and there are also loopholes in ensuring fairness of marking. The practical side is not thought out well. I hope that a well-intentioned change will not result in a mess, which is nothing but mere additional burden on both the teachers and students.

Reading English books and watching English films are how I built and have been further strengthening my English foundations. These two ways are not just for students. If I were the Education Head with the goal of improving the English standards of Hong Kong people in mind, I would put forward an incentive scheme to encourage all government officials, members of the Executive and Legislative Councils, and teachers, especially English teachers, to read English books and watch English films regularly. Set an example for our students in the interest of both themselves and the children.

Everyone says reading broadens our horizons, but I wonder how often our social leaders read! Recently, I started a paid website in which I put my book and film reviews and other essays to share my thoughts and feelings. I am going to tell my students about that in the hope of arousing their interest in reading and writing. Action always speaks louder than words. If I were the Education Head, I would also start a club for teachers to share their response to their favourite books and films, or even those that they don¡¦t like. Start with teachers. If I were a student, I would enjoy watching my teachers sitting together exchanging their views, and I would pick up the books and videos to see if they are really that impressive or terrible.

3-9-2005
Ms Fanny Law's reply to my first e-mail message

Dear Ms Kung,
Thank you for sharing with me your letter to SCMP. I salute you for setting an example for your students by reading and writing book reviews.

Teaching also involves role-modelling as the Chinese saying goes "¨¥¶Ç¨­±Ð". If every teacher (and parent) reads, encourages students to read and also shares reflections with and among students, I am sure students' literacy, language proficiency, as well as learning effectiveness will be enhanced.

I'll be interested to know what kind of "incentive scheme" you think would be effective in encouraging government officials, ExCo and LegCo members and teachers to read. Would extrinsic motivation be sustainable?

Reading requires discipline and time management which are generic skills which all workers must master in the rapid pace of life of the 21st century. Schools today have plenty of resources available for deployment at their discretion. Investment in learning resources is a worthwhile investment which I hope schools will accord a high priority, but every school has different needs. I shall consider, together with HKEAA, your concern about the cost of filming school-based oral examinations. Thank you for your suggestions.

Sincerely,
Fanny Law

11-9-2005
Ms Fanny Law's reply to my second e-mail message

Dear Ms Kung,
Thank you for your message. I apologise for not having replied earlier as I have been away on a duty visit to Australia. I read your message through the palm but found it too difficult to write a message using the mini keyboard.

There is a book by ASCD (Association of Supervision and Curriculum Development) on "What works in schools" which I would recommend to all principals and teachers. Ultimately, the school leadership has to drive change in order for change to occur, and teachers must learn from teachers. The government can provide direction and support, but we are dealing with adults who have their own ideas and priorities. We must nurture our students (and teachers) to be self-directed learners. To break old habits, there have to be both pressure (sense of urgency and need) and support (incentives). Pressure without support creates frustration; support without pressure leads to complacency and slow (or no) progress.

I have no objection to you putting my reply on your website. My message to students is "know yourself, be yourself, and build a future for yourself. There is no harvest without hard work." On this, a Sunday immediately following the Teachers' Day, I pray that God will bless all our teachers to give them the wisdom and strength to nurture a new generation of young people, who are global citizens and have the aptitude and skills for lifelong learning.

Best wishes,
Fanny Law

Other essays

Return to the first page