We all started walking back to the cars we came in, Aj and Theresa glancing at each other every once an a while, while Nick and I stayed good distances from each other. We were both still kind of embarrassed about the haunted house thing. I decide to see if I could talk to Theresa while we walked so I slowed and pulled her back with me.
"Theresa, you will never believe what happened to me." I sighed as she glanced at Aj’s ass and grinned up at me.
"What? Did you and…"
"No, shit I wish. Well we were in the haunted house and Nick scared the shit out of me and then the lights went off. Well, Kev told me to grab his hand and Nick’s hand so we could get out of there. Well, when I reached out for Nicky’s hand, I didn’t grab it…" I paused, waiting for her to figure out what I was saying.
"What did ya grab?" She asked, puzzled. I just gave her a look and she started cracking up. "You felt him up?"
"Well, if that’s what you wanna call it. Yeah."
"Well, is he big?" She asked, always one minded.
"My God is he blessed!" I started giggling too, until Nick, Kevin and Aj turned around to see what we were laughing about.
"What’s so funny?" Aj asked, stopping to walk in between us.
"Not a thing." We both said in unison. Aj stood in front of us.
"Really, you’re lying to me, but I bet I know how to make at least one of ya tell." I saw him head towards Theresa and stepped in his way.
"Oh no ya don’t. You ain’t gonna get her to talk so back up Buster!" I smirked, keeping him and Theresa separated. Nick and Kevin both walked up and frowned.
"Aww, come on, I’m your favoritest cousin! Please." Aj begged, stepping back a little. I shook my head.
"We ain’t gonna tell ya J! So sorry!" I smiled innocently until both Nick and Kevin came towards us. They both started tickling us, in the middle of the carnival in front of a bunch of people.
"Okay, okay, we’ll tell." I heard Theresa screech out of breath from laughing. I turned and looked at her as she gave me a certain look. "We were discussing which one of the Backstreet Boys would look best in spandex."
"It would of course be me." Kevin grinned, cockily, flexing his muscles.
"Nah man, it’s me, and you know it." Aj said in the same tone. Nick just laughed and them both and met my eyes.
"Theresa, I think Nick would definitely look the best in it…"
**********
Once we got back to Alex’s house, all the guys decided to head home, except Nick. We had decided to wait and go to a club tomorrow night, since everyone was tired from such an ‘exciting’ day. Nick, Aj, Theresa, and I all laid out on the couches in the family room, trying to find something to do.
"Hmm, how about a small game of truth or dare?" Theresa grinned evilly, pulling her light blond hair up into a ponytail at the top of her head.
"That is so middle school, Theresa. And plus, I don’t trust you after the last game we played." I stated, getting a laugh from her. Nick and Aj looked puzzled but decided it was best not to ask.
"Aww, come on Cousin, live a little…" Alex smirked, not minding that cute little Blondie wanted to play a game where anything could happen.
"Alright, but only if Nick will play too, that way there’s more people for her to pick on." I demanded, nudging Nick with my foot.
"Hey I’ll play. I’m all up for it." Nick smiled.
"Okay well just stay down until we get the game started, okay." Theresa giggled at her own joke. Nick just blushed a little and Aj and me snickered.
"Let’s get this game started shall we, who should go first?" Aj asked, removing his sunglasses and placing them on the coffee table in front of him.
"Well, since Theresa thought of it, we’ll let her go first." I suggested, then wished I hadn’t said anything, because as soon as I said that Theresa grinned at me.
"Okay, if that’s what ya want, Steph, truth or dare?" She smirked, her eyes twinkling mischievously.
"Oh I hate you. I guess, umm, truth."
"Okay, who do you have a crush on?" She smirked, waiting for me to spill the BSB member I had had an infatuation for from the start.
"Hmm, I’d have to say Seth Green, ‘cause he just so adorable." I grinned back when she frowned at me.
"I meant which Backstreet Boy you have the hots for!" Theresa fussed, glaring at me.
"Oh well, you should have been more specific. Only one question per turn." I smiled triumphantly. The game progressed little by little, each of us opening up more.
"Okay, Nicky, truth or dare?" Theresa smirked, as Aj played with her hair.
"Dare!" He said, getting sudden courage.
"Uh oh, we gotta one brave soul. Hmm, well, since Steph got to feel you up in the haunted house, I think it’s only fair if you get to feel her up too." She grinned slyly towards Nick and me.
"What!" I shouted, almost ready to beat up my best friend.
"Oh, don’t me such a baby Steph, it is only fair." She smirked again, as Aj just stared at us shocked.
"What do you mean you felt Nick up!" He stated, staring at Nick then at me.
"It was an accident, the lights were off and neither of us could see. It was an accident." I explained, feeling my face get hotter by the second.
"Anyway, come Nick’s gotta do the dare. Let’s go." Theresa urged, climbing up onto Aj’s couch.
"Fine. Come on Nick, let’s get this over with so my cuz doesn’t have a major heart attack." I sighed, standing up in front of him. Nick seemed a bit shy at first but pulled my down onto his lap. His hands started slowly at my neck, going down my shoulders. I shuddered slightly when his fingers barely grazed the curve of my breasts.
"Oh come on Nick. Boring." Theresa urged on again, as she faked a yawn and laid back into the couch.
He met my eyes for a moment and locked them there as he got into what he was doing. His hands slipped down to my legs, then up my thighs to my hips. His strong fingers barely massaged my butt as he smirked up at me. I swear, sometimes Nick can be so sexual it scares me. His warm hands suddenly slipped up my tank top, caressing my tummy and up my ribcage. Without warning his hand cupped my breast, causing me to jump slightly and my heart to beat faster. All of the sudden his lips caught mine and I felt the couch against my back. I was doing something most girls’ only dream of and I have to admit I was definitely enjoying myself. When his finger tricked the front catch of my bra and caressed the bare skin, I vaguely heard Theresa.
"Damn you two, get a room if you’re gonna fuck. I just told ya to feel her up, not bring her to a freaking orgasm!" With that sentence from her Nick reluctantly pulled away, leaving my lips burning and hooking my bra back into place.
"Alright then, Theresa truth or dare?" Nick challenged, still hovering over me. He helped me back into sitting position and wrapped an arm around my shoulder, drawing me against him.
"Uh-oh, hmm, dare. Hit me with your best shot Baby." She smiled innocently. Nick looked over at me for help. I smiled and leaned into his ear.
"We gotta get her back. She gets slightly embarrassed when she has to dance for one person so, the Thong Song and have her dance for Aj." I whispered, accidentally brushing my lips against his ear. I felt him shiver and grinned again.
"Okay, Girlie, you gotta dance, for Aj, to the ‘thong, thong, Thong Song." Nick smirked, watching Theresa blush a little.
"Stephanie, I’m gonna kill you."
"Nah, you’ll thank me later." I promised, giving her a wink and resting my head against Nick’s shoulder.
Theresa just stuck out her tongue at me and stood up in front of Aj. Nick got up and put the cd into the player and turned up the volume. When the song started Theresa seemed a little shy but quickly got into the movements of the song. I could almost swear Aj was drooling over her, then again any guy in their right mind would. She was very pretty, definitely pretty than me, but it was her attitude and sexual vibes that the guys wanted her for. Suddenly she started to pull off her shirt.
"What in the hell are you doing Theresa, the dare was to dance not put the poor boy into a coma." I teased as she pulled her shirt all the way off. "Theresa, we didn’t ask for a strip tease!" Then it hit me. She could hear me over the music. I quickly got up and turned off the sound. "I repeat we didn’t ask for a strip tease. Put your clothes back on girl. Save that until after I’ve left the room."
"Then leave the room! You and Nicky can go get freaky in your room and I’ll continue with Aj down here." Theresa sighed, falling back down on to the couch.
"How about NO! Now behave." Theresa just glared at me and pulled her baby blue shirt back on. Suddenly a loud rumble shook the house and a burst of lightening streaked outside the window.
"Holy shit!" Theresa and I shrieked, jumping about a foot in the air. I clung to Nick, while Theresa buried her face against Aj’s shirt.
"Well we can tell who don’t like storms around here!" Nick chuckled, rubbing his hand down my back.
"Nicky, will you do me a favor?" I muttered quietly, still cuddling against him.
"What?"
I looked up at Theresa, noticing her inconspicuously kissing Aj’s neck, still acting like a frightened child, then met Nick’s eyes.
"Could you maybe spend the night? I don’t want to sleep by myself during a storm." Aj looked up surprised, giving me a confused look while sending Nick the famous, ‘Don’t you dare try anything with her’ look.
"SURE!" Nick cheered, a little too enthusiastically.
Anywhere For You
Kit Kat's Stories
