8. Teacher's rôle. The teacher then did not play
the rôle of instructor or supplier of grammatical rules.
The assumption was that the patterns of the language are implicit
in the expression of meaning and that provided there were enough
examples of the different ways of using English, the students
would become aware enough of the right way to use language without
being explicitly told about them. The rôle was rather to
be advisor, critic, stimulator and perhaps referee (if we think
of the scheme as being similar to an organised sport in that
there were rules which prescribed the limits of behaviour).
9. Non-linguistic aims. There were of course other aims
than linguistic. In societies which are in a state of even more
rapid change than the British there is a need for creative people
able to adapt to changing circumstances and develop new economic
and other activities. It can be argued that some ways of organising
education tend to produce people who are happiest at following
rules and being told what to do - a favourable interpretation
of this kind of education might be that in a static or slowly
changing society such people are useful and necessary. African
and other non-European societies are changing at a rate difficult
for outsiders to imagine. The schools set up before Independence
were intended to produce middle level administrators rather than
creative thinkers or entrepreneurs suitable for managing rapid
change. The English Block was also intended to help correct this
tendency and could have provided a model for the kind of methods
which encourage creative ideas.
10. Prabhu How does this scheme compare with Prabhu's
Bangalore Procedural syllabus which has received so much academic
attention? Prabhu was dealing with the needs of different kinds
of student, much closer to being beginners than the East Africans.
Moreover, the politico-linguistic contexts are different as the
status of English as a Second Language is more uncertain in India.
There, government language policies move closer to making English
a Third Language (after Hindi) and the public use of English,
in competition with vigorous mother tongues, is less common than
in East Africa.(3)
(3)N.S.Prabhu Procedural Syllabuses ESP 5A/9
|