Nicky waits for the mare to come out so she can bid on it and make it her own. But then, a tiny black broken down pony, so thin he can hardly stand on his own, comes out. Suddenly Nicky's hand goes up and she is bidding, but not for her perfect pony! In pity, she buys the broken down pony.
Only one thing could make it worse. Billy Baily, her worst enemy in the world, buys the perfect pony. But is the prancing white mare really the perfect pony?