1:What did Jesus say about homosexuality?
2:Does the Bible condemn the sexual orientation of Gays and Lesbians?
3:Is it possible to change gay people into heterosexuals?
4:Many fundamentalists suggest that Women should remain in the home,
submitting to their husbands. Does the Bible especially condemn Lesbianism?
5:Some TV evangelists act as if Homosexuality among men were the worst sin.
What biblical texts do they base this on? Is their approach legitimate?
I. Deuteronomy 23:17-18. (Cf 1 Kings 14:22-24, 15:22, 22:46, and 2
Kings 23:7.) This passage, in the most scholarly, reliable, modern translations,
refers only to (now defunct) male and female temple prostitutes. Old
translations of the Hebrew term for 'male temple prostitute' as 'sodomite' are
simply inaccurate; some scholars think these male prostitutes serviced female
customers, not males. This passage hardly applies to today's gays and
Lesbians!
II & III. Genesis 19:4-11; Judges 19:22 (Cf. Jude 6-7; 2 Peter 2:4, 6-8.)
Most people assume Sodom was destroyed due to God's judgments upon the
homosexual lusts of the inhabitants. Yet many now argue that the sin of Sodom
was lack of hospitality to the angelic visitors who stayed with Lot. How does
the rest of the Bible explain the 'sin of Sodom'? It is clear from Ezekiel
16:49-50 that Sodom's sin was primarily pride, wealth, and indifference to the
needy; it is also evident from Luke 10:10-12 that Jesus explicitly stated that
many sins would be punished more severely on the day of Judgment than the
sins of Sodom. Even if the sins of Sodom were in part sexual, it is important to
note that it is the violence of the treatment of the strangers that is condemned --
something that hardly applies to acts performed between consenting adults.
IV & V. Levitcus 18:22, 20:13-14. "You shall not lie with a man as a
woman: that is abomination" (New English Bible). This part of the "Holiness
Code" of the Old Testament, which also condemns the practice of eating rare
meat or wearing a fabric from more than one material - anyone eating a rare
steak while wearing a cotton/polyester is doubly violating this holiness code!
(Funny: these things don't seem to bother Fundamentalists.) Leviticus also
states that any man or woman caught in adultery "must be put to death" (Lev.
20:10). Preachers quick to call homosexual acts an 'abomination' are not
insisting that Jim Bakker must be "put to death"! And for good reason: the
New Testament repeatedly declares the Hebrew Holiness Code or "Law" has
been replaced by the new dispensation in Christ. Jesus said of the woman
caught in adultery : "If any one of you is without sin, let him to be the first to
throw a stone at her" (New International Version; John 8:3-11). Furthermore,
the "detestable" nature of lying "as a woman" refers to a male's assuming the
passive role in anal intercourse, which was held as an abomination because of
taking on the inferior status of women. Apparently it does not view the "active"
role in anal intercourse as an abomination, nor other homosexual acts, e.g.,
fellatio. (John Boswell's book examines this - see #7.)
VI & VII. 1 Corinthians 6:9, 1 Timothy 1:10. The key words are
translated differently in different versions: from 1 Cor.: "catamites, sodomites"
(Moffat); "effeminate, homosexuals" (ASV); "homosexual perversion: (New
English Bible); "Male prostitutes, homosexual offenders" (New International
Version) etc.; 1 Timothy is also variously translated. However, there was no
noun in Greek for homosexual; apparently the translations condemning
homosexuals are inaccurate. The Greek words suggest not "homosexual" but
"effeminate" or "morally weak or soft" or "cowardly."
VIII. Romans 1:26-27. The only passage in the Bible mentioning Lesbian
acts. Conclusion: The supposedly sweeping Biblical condemnation of
homosexuality simply doesn't hold up to close scrutiny, as it is limited to acts of
prostitute, idolatry, violent or non-consensual acts, inaccurate translations, or
outmoded prejudices against women and their supposed inferiority. How can
these be applied to a committed relationship based on love (rather than mere
lust) between two consenting adults of the same gender?
6:When homophobiac people start using the bible to attack me, How can I
verbally defend myself? Are there any passages in the bible that seem to
support gay relationships, or at least, indicate that perhaps marrying
and having children is not the ultimate christian duty?
7:How can I get more info about these topics? what books are available?
Jesus never mentions the subject of homosexuality in the Holy Bible.
Strictly speaking, the Bible nowhere condemns homosexuality as a sexual
orientation. The concept of 'sexual orientation' does not appear in the Bible; the idea
is only about a century old; the word 'homosexuality' was not even coined until the
19th century; no such word existed in the Greek in which the New Testament was
written. Certain Biblical passages do condemn particular homosexual acts. (See #5.)
There is absolutely no reputable study indicating that a permanent change in
sexual orientation is possible. (Of course it is possible for some people, at least in the
short term, to outwardly conform to others' expectations, while repressing and
denying their true and natural gay or Lesbian feelings.) It is hard to reconcile the
manipulation (sometimes involving aversion therapy, etc.) and condemnation of gays
with a gospel of love and forgiveness and faith. (See #7: "Blair.")
No. Only one passage in the entire Bible (both Old and New Testaments)
refers to homosexual activity among women: St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans (1:26).
St. Pauls' attitude towards women is generally critical; he viewed marriage as merely a
last resort against burning with (heterosexual) lust. (See 1 Corinthians 7:9.)
The supposedly sweeping Biblical condemnation of homosexuality rests almost
exclusively on only the following eight (brief) passages; all other references merely
reiterate or comment upon these eight passages, and so are merely cited in
parentheses:
There seems to be little point in arguing with people who believe the earth was
created in 4,004 B.C.; this doesn't mean that you have to accept their interpretation
of the Bible. Remember: these people are not homophobic to begin with. (You might
chide them for wearing mixed fabric or ask them if Jim Bakker must be "put to
death" - if you really enjoy arguing.) You might familiarize yourself with the many
Biblical passages (too numerous to mention here) that stress love, compassion,
forgiveness of sins, not judging others, etc.
Remember: Jesus himself never married nor had children! Other parts of the
Bible simply can't be forced into the "family values" obsession of the
Fundamentalists, for example :
The Book of Ruth sensitively portrays bonding and devotion between two
women. Also don't miss Book of Judith for a surprising overturning of
male/female roles: Judith sneaks into the enemy camps, cuts off the head of
Holofernes, the leader of the enemy army, returns and receives a hero's
welcome, and then lives out the remainder of her days with her maidservants,
rejecting all male suitors!
The "friendship" between David and Jonathan. The relevant passages: 1
Samuel 18:1-4; 20:3-4, and especially, 20:41 and 2 Samuel 1:25-26, quoted
here: "And as soon as the lad had gone, David rose from beside the stone heap
and fell on his face to the ground, and bowed three times; and they (David and
Jonathan) kissed one another, and wept with another, until David recovered
himself" (1 Sam. 20:41 New International Version). Note: It's really amusing to
see the Fundamentalists try to dismiss the obvious passion in this episode!
David speaks : "Jonathan lies slain... I am distressed for you, my brother
Jonathan; very pleasant have you been to me; your love to me was
wonderful, passing the love of women" (2
Sam 1:25-26, New International Version).
A few sources of further information are :
Blair, Ralph, "Ex-Gay" (HCC, Inc., Suite 803, 30 E. 60th St., New York, NY
10022, 1982) - A booklet that unequivocally repudiates the claim that sexual
orientation can be changed through ministries to "ex-gays." Dr. Blair is a
psychotherapist and the founder of the pro-gay Evangelicals Concerned.
Boswell, John, "Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality" (Chicago,
Univ of Chicago Press, 1981). A very scholarly, meticulously researched and
footnoted study of gay people during the first fourteen centuries of the
Christian era.
England, The Rev. Michael E., "The Bible and Homosexuality" (Beulahland
Press, 1979); a 39-page pamphlet, containing a three-page bibliography. (This
is a primary source for the discussion of specific Biblical passages here.)
Scanzoni, Letha, and Virginia Ramey Mollenkott, "Is the Homosexual My
Neighbor?" "Another Christian View" (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1980).
This book lists 4 pages of titles of recommended reading. (I've drawn from this
book in the above discussion.)
Note : Several denominations now ordain openly gay or Lesbian aspirants to the
priesthood or ministry, perform holy union ceremonies for same-gender couples, etc;
the Metropolitan Community Church ministers primarily to the gay and Lesbian
community.