| CITY | ADDRESS | NOTES |
| Adrian | 802 W. Maumee St. | Closed 2019, now Hungry Howie's |
| Allen Park | 16173 Wick Rd. | Closed ca. 2006, later Nino's Pizzeria, now Sizzle Salon |
| Ann Arbor | 401 E. Huron St. | Closed 2013, torn down along with adjacent buildings for 413 E. Huron complex |
| 3395 Plymouth Rd. | Closed ca. 2017, later Hungry Howie's, now vacant | |
| Battle Creek | 1571 Capital Ave. NE | Vacant |
| Bay City | 202 N. Walnut St. | Closed August 7, 2011, became VetMed Veterinary Clinic 2015 |
| Big Rapids | 215 E. Maple St. | Closed ca. 2010, now Jet's Pizza |
| Brighton | 114 W. Grand River Ave. | Now Sushi Zen |
| Clarkston | 5899 Dixie Hwy. | Closed 2019, vacant |
| Commerce Township | 1203 N. Commerce Rd. | Closed 2019, vacant |
| Dearborn Heights | 4055 S. Telegraph Rd. | Closed 2022, now Detroit Pizza Factory |
| Detroit | 18474 Livernois Ave. | Closed ca. 2015, vacant |
| East Lansing | 1219 E. Grand River Ave. | *Operated ca. 1998 as Papiano's due to naming conflicts with an existing, unrelated Papa John's restaurant in Lansing. *Closed 2008, became Topper's Pizza December 2008; closed 2011, later Papa's Pizza, now Conrad's Grill. |
| Eastpointe | 18640 E. 9 Mile Rd. | Torn down after 2012 for CVS/pharmacy |
| Farmington | 34527 Grand River Ave. | Now Bunchy's Chicken |
| Fenton | 603 N. Leroy St. | Now Spa Naturelle |
| Flint | 2113 S. Ballenger Hwy. | Closed ca. 2010, now Domino's |
| 3849 Davison Rd. | Closed before 2008, later Papa Garrett's, then Michael Angelo's, then Passport Pizza, now Laredo's | |
| Flushing | 765 E. Main St. | Opened late 1990s in former Domino's; closed before 2008, later Krispy Chicken & Fish, then Bella Birches, now Cops and Robbers |
| Grand Blanc | G-6044 S. Saginaw St. | Closed 2009, now Enterprise Rent-a-Car |
| Howell | 1009 E. Grand River Ave. | Former Sunoco station; later Duke's Pizza, then Scratch Sweet Shop, now Griff's Grill |
| Kalamazoo | 1710 W. Main St. | Closed 2019, vacant |
| Lincoln Park | 2556 Dix Hwy. | Closed late 2020, vacant |
| Midland | 2311 Washington St. | Previously Chick-n-Joy and Baskin-Robbins. Moved to 1520 N. Saginaw St., torn down along with adjacent former Ponderosa Steakhouse and Wolverine Bank for CVS/pharmacy |
| Mt. Morris | 7098 N. Saginaw St. | Moved 2002?, now Liberty Tax |
| G-6044 N. Saginaw St. | Opened ca. 2002 in former KFC; closed ca. 2010, now Little Caesars | |
| Muskegon | 770 W. Summit Ave. | Opened late 1990s? in former Spad's Pizza; closed before 2009, later Screamers, now Seaway Liquors |
| Owosso | 426 E. Main St. | Originally Burger Chef, later Hardee's until 1989, then a donut shop until late 1990s. Opened 2001, closed before 2007, later Rib Shack, now Cash Depot. |
| Pontiac | 1101 E. Walton Blvd. | Closed 2019, later Toarmina's Pizza, now vacant |
| Port Huron | 915 24th St. | Later Passport Pizza, now Jimmy John's |
| 3853 Pine Grove Ave. | Now Northgate Liquor & Wine | |
| Portage | 5140 S. Westnedge Ave. | Closed 2019, vacant |
| South Haven | 570 Broadway St. | Closed ca. 2011, now Johna's Seafood |
| Sturgis | 415 S. Centerville Rd. | Later Cottage Inn Pizza, now vacant |
| University Center (Saginaw) |
Saginaw Valley State University Albert E's Food Court (7400 Bay Rd.) |
Closed and became Panda Express 2016 |
| West Bloomfield | 4589 Haggerty Rd. | Closed 2019, vacant |
| White Lake | 9278 Highland Rd. | Closed 2019, now Little Caesars |
| Wyandotte | 364 Eureka Rd. | Now Wyandotte Drugs |
