EASTERN ALL-STARS
Manager: Tony Sumlak, TOR
- Maury Wills, SS, CIN*
- Charlie Gehringer, 2B, ATL*
- Lou Gehrig, 1B, TOR*
- Babe Ruth, OF, NYY*
- Roy Campanella, C, ATL*
- George Foster, OF, CIN*
- Mule Haas, OF, NYY*
- Pete Rose, 3B, CIN*
- Walker Cooper, C, BOS
- Willie McCovey, 1B, BOS
- Tony Lazzeri, 2B, TOR
- Carney Lansford, 3B, NYY
- Billy Rogell, SS, NYM
- Rickey Henderson, OF, NYM
- Kenny Lofton, OF, ATL
- Frank Robinson, OF, TOR
- Billy O'Dell, P, TOR*
- Mort Cooper, P, TOR
- Ralph Terry, P, NYY
- Don Drysdale, P, NYY
- Mike Garcia, P, NYM
- Pete Richert, RP, NYM
- Eddie Watt, RP, BOS
- Ray Narleski, RP, NYY
- Paul Assenmacher, RP, NYM
- Eddie Rommel, RP, NYY
WESTERN ALL-STARS
Manager: Terry Pair, STL
- Lou Klein, SS, CHI*
- Bobby Avila, 2B, DET*
- Carl Furillo, OF, SEA*
- Al Simmons, OF, STL*
- John Blanchard, C, LA*
- Mike Epstein, 1B, HOU*
- Roger Maris, OF, LA*
- Joe Rudi, 3B, LA*
- Elston Howard, C, SEA
- Eddie Murray, 1B, CHI
- Jim Gilliam, 2B, SEA
- Al Rosen, 3B, STL
- Jimmy Dykes, SS, STL
- Jackie Robinson, OF, SEA
- Earle Combs, OF, CHI-HOU
- Red Murray, OF, HOU
- Bob Gibson, P, STL*
- Nelson Briles, P, SEA
- Jim Palmer, P, HOU
- Sandy Koufax, P, LA
- Mike Cuellar, P, SEA
- Rollie Fingers, RP, STL
- Bill Stafford, RP, STL
- Don Mossi, RP, SEA
- Dick Hall, RP, CHI
- Don Larsen, RP, DET
* denotes starter