Manager: Tony Sumlak, TOR

• Larry Doyle, 2B, NYY*
• Bing Miller, OF, BOS*
• Lou Gehrig, 1B, TOR*
• Babe Ruth, OF, NYY*
• Duke Snider, OF, TOR*
• Bobby Morgan, SS, BOS*
• Jim Davenport, 3B, ATL*
• Mickey Cochrane, C, BOS*
• Johnny Bench, C, CIN
• Willie McCovey, 1B, NYM
• Carlos Baerga, 2B, LA-NYM
• Jim Thome, 3B, TOR
• Maury Wills, SS, CIN
• Jessie Levis, OF, ATL
• Stan Musial, OF, BOS
• Tommy Davis, OF, ATL
• Mike Garcia, P, BOS*
• George Mullin, P, ATL
• Christy Mathewson, P, NYM
• Ed Killian, P, NYY
• Rube Marquard, P, CIN
• Ray Narleski, RP, NYY
• Pete Richert, RP, NYM
• Harry Breechen, RP, ATL
• Jim Corsi, RP, NYM
• Al Severinsen, RP, BOS

Manager: Andrew Clarke, DET

• Joe Morgan, 2B, NYM-LA*
• Mickey Mantle, OF, DET*
• John Blanchard, C, LA*
• Boog Powell, 1B, STL*
• Ty Cobb, OF, CHI*
• Willie Mays, OF, SEA*
• Jimmy Dykes, SS, STL*
• Orlando Cepeda, 3B, CHI*
• Elston Howard, C, SEA
• Hank Greenberg, 1B, SEA
• Bobby Avila, 2B, DET
• Joe Rudi, 3B, LA
• Eric McNair, SS, LA
• Albert Belle, OF, DET
• Carl Furillo, OF, SEA
• Reggie Jackson, OF, STL
• Mike Cuellar, P, SEA*
• Ed Summers, P, LA
• Sandy Koufax, P, LA
• Ray Washburn, P, STL
• Early Wynn, P, CHI
• Wilcy Moore, RP, DET
• Will McEnaney, RP, SEA
• Joe Hoerner, RP, HOU
• Don Larsen, RP, DET
• Jose Mesa, RP, LA

* denotes starter