Money for
Nothing and Your Clicks for FREE
By James L. Marciano Recently, I got a call from the
president of a major content provider --
one of those services that personalizes
information for "portals" such
as ISPs and search engines. He was
interested in developing his own
revenue-sharing program to drive users to
his website. It was obvious, he said,
that the revenue-sharing model could
dramatically lower his cost of
acquisition and allow him to all but
eliminate his traditional marketing and
advertising budget. What he wanted to
know was how to structure the deal.....
1998 has been
proclaimed "The Year of
E-Commerce." Amazon.com now has a $4
billion valuation ($1.7 billion MORE than
Barnes & Noble), CDNow and Music
Boulevard each raised tens of millions of
dollars in their respective IPOs, and
Yahoo! (with a $7 billion valuation) just
purchased Viaweb (which hosts 1000 small
e-commerce sites) for $49 million.
Much of these
astronomical valuations is based on a
vague concept of Internet presence: with
no physical stores or inventory, many of
these online retailers are essentially
Marketing companies -- worth their weight
in page impressions. To extend the
visibility of their brand and increase
online sales, many of the larger
retailers have embraced a revenue-sharing
model, giving away a percentage of the
sale to grab all-important marketshare.
By paying individual
website owners commissions for sales that
they help drive, a site's cost of
acquiring new customers can be reduced
substantially. For these retailers, the
decision to give up 5% to 20% of the sale
price is a no-brainer.
Not surprisingly, a
growing number of online retailers are
following pioneers like Amazon.com and
One and Only Internet Personals into the
fray. Refer-it (http://www.refer-it.com)
lists hundreds of programs that offer
everything from free streaming content to
hundred-dollar bounties for new accounts.
It would seem that the latest mantra of
e-commerce might be "It's
revenue-sharing, stupid!" But
finding the right formula for both the
site owner (the affiliate) and the
e-commerce provider (wholesaler/retailer)
is less obvious.
There are two major
types of revenue-sharing programs --
affiliate (also called associate)
programs and bounty (also called
referral) programs. Music, book and
vitamin retailers tend to offer affiliate
programs, telling their associates,
"I'll pay you a percentage of the
sale when a visitor to your site clicks
through and buys one of my
products." Sites like Music
Boulevard, Autoweb and Darwin Keyboards,
which pay website owners anywhere from a
5-15% commission, best exemplify the
affiliate model.
The advantages of
affiliate programs are that, in theory, a
site owner can continue to earn money
from the same "customer." That
is, if a visitor continues to come to an
affiliate's site to make his online
purchases, the site owner will earn a
commission on every sale. Well, maybe.
And this is where it gets tricky -- who
owns the customer? This is the hardest
question to answer in this model. Some
programs pay forever, others only for the
first 90 days, others only on the FIRST
purchase. And what if the visitor clicks
through to the retailer's site,
"window-shops" only, then
returns directly to that retailer's site
10 days later and makes a purchase? Does
the referring site still get the credit?
Not only must the above
policy questions be answered, but the
technology behind them must be developed.
No small feat when you consider that
Amazon.com has more than a million items
for sale, and over 40,000 affiliates.
Keeping track of which affiliate the
customer comes from, what he buys, and
when he buys it can quickly become more
complicated than building the storefront
itself!
Enter the bounty model
-- one that has existed in the off-line
world, formally and informally, since the
beginning of time. Bounty program
managers say, "I'll pay you a fixed
price for bringing me a new customer or a
'hot lead.'" Let's pretend you own a
florist shop and you partner with the
local undertaker. For every grieving
family he sends your way, you pay him a
one-time bounty of $25. After that,
presuming your crocusses didn't wilt,
that family will return to you the next
time there is a bereavment.
It works just as well
online as it does off. WebCards
(http://www.printing.com), which puts
homepages on postcards, is a good (and
more cheery) example in the online realm.
They pay the website owner $1.00 every
time a visitor to his site clicks through
and fills out an online form requesting
further information. It's the site
owner's job to deliver the person to
them; it's WebCard's job to convert the
lead to a paying customer.
With a bounty program,
that's all there is to it. No issues
about who owns the customer (WebCards
does), tracking individually priced items
(it's always $1.00), or trying to lure
the customer back to buy from you instead
of the retailer. And from a technology
standpoint there's no contest -- any
small retailer or business owner can
easily develop and maintain this type of
program. The obvious difference for the
website owner is that she needs to
continue to attract NEW visitors to her
site -- she can't "retail" this
particular offer to the same visitor
again.
I was glad to see that
that web executive from the content
provider was giving some serious thought
to his revenue-sharing plan. With the
e-commerce boom, the idea-of-the-moment
is often portrayed as a quick fix,
requiring little thought to magically
turn silicon into gold. The fact is,
revenue-sharing isn't web alchemy, it's
real business. And those who set about
implementing such a program should pause
to consider the strategic implications.
For your business, it could be the
difference between IPO and R.I.P. (I know
a good florist...)
Brought
to you by: World Wide Information Outlet
- http://certificate.net/wwio/, your
source of FREEWare Content online.
James
L. Marciano is the CEO of Up-Set, a NYC
new media company founded in August 1996.
In addition to building online
communities (or "intersets")
such as TheSquare - http://www.thesquare.com, for Ivy
League grads, and i-Site - http://www.i-site.org, for the
blind, Up-Set has created Refer-it - http://www.refer-it.com the
definitive guide to revenue-sharing
programs on the Internet. Prior to
founding Up-Set, Mr. Marciano was a
strategy consultant for seven years; he
received an AB in Social Psychology from
Harvard College in 1988, and an MBA in
general management from The Amos Tuck
School at Dartmouth College in 1993.
|