What's CD-R? CD-RW?
CD-R is short for
"CD-Recordable". Recordable CDs are WORM (Write Once, Read Multiple)
media that work just like standard CDs. The advantage of CD-R over other types
of optical media is that you can use the discs with a standard CD player. The
disadvantage is that you can't reuse a disc.
A related technology called CD-Rewritable
(CD-RW) allows you to erase discs and reuse them, but the CD-RW media doesn't
work in all players. CD-Rewritable drives are able to write both CD-R and CD-RW
discs.
All CD recorders can read CDs and CD-ROMs,
just like a standard CD-ROM drive.
Are they identical to normal CDs?
The CDs you buy in a store are pressed from
a mold. CD-Rs are burned with a laser. They may look different (often green,
gold, or blue instead of silver), they're less tolerant of extreme temperatures
and sunlight, and they're more susceptible to physical damage. Whether CD-Rs or
pressed CDs last longer is difficult to answer.
While they're not physically identical,
they work just the same. Some CD players and CD-ROM drives aren't as good at
reading CD-R and CD-RW discs as they are at reading pressed CDs, but by and
large they work just fine.
By the way, you can't record on pressed
discs, so you might as well throw out all those AOL CD-ROMs you've been
accumulating. Buying a bunch of old CDs in the hopes of writing new stuff onto
them is a bad idea. You have to buy blank CD-R or CD-RW media.
Can I create new audio and data CDs?
Yes. You can create CD-ROMs from data on
your hard drive, and you can create new audio CDs from anything you can record
into a WAV or AIFF sound file. With an audio-only CD-Recorder, which hooks up to
your stereo system instead of your computer, you can record directly from CD,
cassette, DAT, or whatever.
The CD-ROMs you produce will play in
ordinary CD-ROM drives, and the audio CDs you create will work in your home or
car CD player.
Writing to CD-Rs and CD-RWs requires a
special drive. You can't write CDs with an ordinary CD-ROM drive.
Can I use it to copy my CDs?
Yes, both audio and data CDs can be
duplicated. You can even create audio CDs that are compilations of other audio
CDs (perhaps a personal "best of" disc).
Bear in mind that most CDs are protected by
copyright laws.
How much can they hold?
About 74 minutes of audio, or about 650MB
of data.
Some CD-R blanks can hold 80 minutes of
audio, or about 700MB of data
Can I just copy files onto a CD-R like I
would to a floppy?
Yes and no. The process can be a bit more
involved than that, and requires special software that (usually) comes bundled
with the drive.
With "packet writing" software,
and a recorder that supports it, you can treat a CD-R or CD-RW disc like a
floppy. Generally speaking, you can only write to each part of the disc once, so
deleting files doesn't gain any space. There are other limitations as well.
With more traditional software -- necessary
if you want the broadest possible compatibility -- you usually end up writing
everything to the disc all at once. When you're doing the writing you can't
interrupt the drive, and you can't reclaim the space you've used. If you want to
write your files in smaller bunches, you lose a fair bit of space every time you
stop and start again.
Can I copy DVDs with a CD recorder?
Not directly. CD and DVD are very different
formats, so you can't write DVDs with your CD recorder. You may be able to
convert the contents into a lower-quality format though.
How long does it take to burn a CD-R?
It depends on how much data you're going to
burn, and how fast your drive is. Burning 650MB of data takes about 74 minutes
at 1x, 37 minutes at 2x, and 19 minutes at 4x, but you have to add a minute or
two for "finalizing" the disc. Remember that single speed is
150KB/sec, double speed is 300KB/sec, and so on. If you have half the data, it
will finish in (about) half the time
If recording fails, is the disc usable?
That depends on what was being recorded,
how it was being recorded, and how far along in the process things were.
If it failed while writing the lead-in,
before any data was written, the disc probably isn't usable. Some drives,
notably certain Sony models, have a "repair disc" option that
forcefully closes the current session. This would allow you to add extra data in
a second session on the disc, but anything written in the first session will be
unavailable.
Failures when finalizing the disc may be
correctable. Sometimes the TOC gets written before the failure, and the disc can
be used as-is. Sometimes you can use a "finalize disc" option from a
program menu that will do the trick. Other times the recorder will refuse to
deal with a partially-finalized disc, and you're stuck.
Failures in the middle of writing result in
a CD-ROM that probably isn't worth trusting. Some of the data will be there,
some won't. The directory for the disc may show more files than are actually
present, and you won't know which are actually there until you try to read them.
Audio CDs recorded in disc-at-once mode are
a special case. Because the TOC is written up front, the disc is readable in a
standard CD player even if the write process doesn't finish. You will be able to
play the tracks up to the point where the recording failed.
If you were using a packet writing program
like DirectCD, the experiences of people on Usenet suggest that you are either
100% okay or 100% screwed. The ScanDisk utility included with DirectCD 2.5 may
help though
How do I erase or format a disc?
If you're using CD-R media, and you're not
using a packet writing program like DirectCD, you can stop reading now. You
don't need to prepare CD-R discs for conventional recording, and you can't erase
them no matter how hard you try. (Note for the nit-pickers: "erase"
means removing the data so that the disc can be re-used. Procedures involving
microwave ovens and belt sanders don't qualify.).If you want to erase a CD-RW
disc, use the software that came with your CD-ReWritable drive. Somewhere in the
army of applications and mountain of menus is the command you're looking for. If
you're going to be using packet writing, a little formatting will be necessary.
The application should offer to do this automatically the first time you insert
a blank disc. The fixed-packet formatting that DirectCD does for CD-RW discs
takes about 50 minutes on a 2x rewritable drive. The difference between
"erase" and "quick erase" is that the former erases the
entire disc, while the latter just stomps on the Table of Contents (TOC). It's
like erasing the directory off of a floppy disk. The file data is still there,
but since there's nothing pointing to it, the disc appears empty. (Some people
have asked if it's possible to recover data from a quick-erased disc. The
general answer is, "don't count on it".)The difference between
"format" and "fast format" (such as is offered on the
HP8100/Sony CRX100) is of a different nature. Both format the entire disc, and
both operate at the same speed, but the "fast" format allows you to
use the drive before formatting has completed. After a few minutes, you are
allowed to access the drive while the formatting process continues in the background. Incidentally,
most conventional (pre-mastering) software will refuse to record on a disc that
has been formatted for packet writing. In some cases the error message may be a
confusing remark that insists the disc isn't writ able.
Can I record an audio CD a few tracks at a
time?
That depends on what you're trying to
accomplish. There are two issues that complicate matters:
- Most audio CD players only play tracks
from the first session on the disc. (Most CD-ROM drives will play all
sessions.)
- Most audio CD players only play tracks
from a closed session. (In general, only a CD recorder can play from an open
session.)
Suppose you record three tracks onto an audio
CD, using track-at-once recording. If you don't close the session, you can add
more tracks, but you can't play the disc. If you close the session, you can play
the disc, but you can't add more tracks.
Some people have CD players that will play
songs from every session. If you do, and compatibility with other players isn't
important, you can write each group of tracks into its own session. The down
side of this approach is that there is an appreciable amount of overhead when
opening a new session (23MB for the first and 14MB for each additional one).
If your hard drive has enough space, you
can just keep the WAV files on the drive, and burn the disc all at once. If it
doesn't, you can write the tracks to a CD-R or CD-RW disc as WAV files on
CD-ROM, and record from there. Write a new CD-R or CD-RW every time you get more
tracks. (The advantage to using CD-ROM is that additional error correction is
used.)
Is it better to record at slower speeds?
It depends on your recorder, media, and who
you talk to. For example, some informal testing with the venerable Yamaha
CDR-100 determined that it worked best at 4x speed with media certified for 4x
writes. 1x worked almost as well, but 2x would occasionally produce discs with
unrecoverable errors.
With audio CDs, the results are more
subjective. Some people have asserted that you should always write at 1x, others
have stated that 2x may actually be better. It depends on the recorder, media,
player, and your ears. Try it both ways and listen.
CD-R media is written by heating up tiny
sections of the disc. When the disc spins faster, the laser has less time to
shine on a particular spot, so the laser has to be controlled differently.
Different formulations of media may require a different "write
strategy" at certain speeds, and each recorder may adjust its write
strategy differently to accommodate those speeds. This can potentially result in
combinations of recorder and media that work perfectly at one speed but fail
miserably at another.
Put simply, there's more to writing at high
speed than just spinning faster. There is no One True Answer to this question.
Do what works best for you.
Can CD-Rs recorded at 2x be read faster
than 2x?
Of course.
The only possible basis in fact for the,
"if it was recorded at 2x, you can't read it faster than 2x" rumors is
that some drives have trouble reading CD-R media. Discs that are hard to read
when spinning at 12x may become easier to read when spinning at 4x. It has also
been noted that some recorders will write more legible discs at certain speeds
(e.g. the Yamaha CDR-100, which works better at 1x or 4x than it does at 2x).
None of this should lead anyone to conclude, however, that the write speed and
read speed are tied directly together. The reader, writer, and media all have a
role in determining how quickly a CD-R can spin and be readable.
It's also the case that discs written at
high speed (say 8x) can be read by drives *slower* than 8x. So if you're
distributing discs to people with old 4x CD-ROM drives, you don't have to worry
about them not being able to read at 8x. Of course, if the CD-ROM is poorly
constructed, or the writer is producing marginal discs at high speeds, you might
see evidence to the contrary, but there is no technical barrier to reading discs
recorded at 8x or 12x on a slower drive.
Do I need to worry about viruses?
Absolutely. Infected CD-ROMs are every bit
as nasty as infected floppies, if not worse: you can't disinfect the source
media. It is prudent to scan your files before creating a CD-ROM for
distribution, and it's not a bad idea to scan the CD-ROM afterward (in case
somebody has cleverly infected your CD writing software).
The dangers of boot sector viruses on
bootable CD-ROMs are probably low. Because the boot sector is created directly
by the recording software, and can't be modified after it has been written, the
opportunity for infection is small.
How do I clean my CD recorder?
In general, you don't. The only reason
you'd need to clean a recorder or (for that matter) a CD-ROM drive is if you
went and stuck your finger on the lens. Cleaning kits and well-intentioned
Q-tips are unnecessary and potentially dangerous.
If you have an overwhelming desire to clear
the dust out of your recorder, and can't or don't want to send it to a service
center, use gentle(!) bursts of compressed air.
[ I've never had to clean a lens in *any*
CD player, including a flip-up top-loading boom box that I've had since
mid-1990. I can *see* the dust inside, and I can see the lens, but it has no
problem playing discs. I can't imagine how a recorder that's only a year or two
old is going to collect enough dust to fail. ]
How do I put photographs onto CD-ROM?
The first thing you have to do is get them
onto your computer. There are three basic approaches: use a scanner to convert
printed photographs, use a video digitizer to pull images off of a video tape,
or use a digital camera to take pictures that can be transferred directly.
Once you have the photograph on your hard
drive, you may want to touch it up a bit. You can use software to correct for
over- and under-exposed snapshots, remove "red eye", and crop off bits
that weren't supposed to be in the frame. Cameras and scanners should come with
image manipulation software that will help you manipulate and manage the image.
Once you've got the images in a reasonable
state, save them in a widely accepted format such as JPEG or TIFF, and write
them to a CD-ROM like you would any other files. You may need to use an
"Export" function rather than "Save As...", because consumer
photo software authors tend to use proprietary image formats as the default.
THERE ARE MANY QUESTIONS THAT I HAVE NOT
ANSWERED ON THIS PAGE. I SUGGEST THAT YOU TAKE THE TIME TO READ THE MANUAL THAT
CAME WITH YOUR CD-RECORDER. MOST OF YOUR QUESTIONS WILL BE ANSWERED IN THERE. IF
YOU CAN NOT FIND THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION PLEASE EMAIL ME AND I WILL DO MY
BEST TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION.
|