"Good choices, Nicky," AJ said. He turned to Karina and placed his hands on her shoulders, leading her to the bed. He eased her down onto her back, then laid down beside her, propped up on one arm. He began to kiss her as his hand went to the back of her neck. She felt him slowly pull the string to her swimsuit top, then he pulled the top down, completely exposing her breasts. He looked into her eyes and smiled, then bent his head to suck each nipple. Karina was in awe of him. She closed her eyes and ran her fingers thru his hair. She then felt something cold running down her stomach. She opened her eyes and saw Nick pouring the Irish Cream in a little stream down her stomach. He smiled at her, then began to lick it off slowly. She gasped as he began to tickle her belly button with his tongue. She watched as both men kissed over her body. Their faces were so close together, and suddenly, their lips met. Karina was shocked to see the two men kiss. It completely blew her mind. AJ looked up and saw the shocked look on her face. He licked his lips, then kissed her deeply. She could taste the Irish Cream. She could feel Nick's hands removing her bikini bottoms. She looked up and saw him kneeling between her legs. He then poured the Irish Cream down her inner thigh, then he smiled as he bent to lick it off. She felt her body involuntarily twitch as his tongue got closer and closer to the place she desired it to be. He was teasing her... licking all around, but never right...there... He ran his hands down the outside of her thighs, then pulled her body to him. He slowly began to lick her wetness. She let out a deep sigh and arched her back as his tongue ran over her sensitive clitoris. AJ sat up on his knees beside her and peeled off his wet shorts. As soon as she saw his beautiful, naked body, she reached over and grabbed his erection in her hand.
"That's my girl," he said, laughing. As she began to pump his shaft, he reached over and grabbed the bottle of Jack Daniels, then took a long drink. He kissed her, allowing a large amount of the whiskey to run into her mouth. She quickly swallowed it. She could feel Nick's tongue teasing her, and her couldn't concentrate on anything other than him for a few minutes. She allowed her hand to drop from AJ's hardness, and she grabbed the back of Nick's head. AJ got tired of being neglected, and he pushed Nick out of the way, taking his place between her legs. AJ looked directly into her eyes as he pushed the end of his hard cock into her. He lowered his body onto hers as he pushed inside, then pinned her arms over her head. His thrusts were hard and aggressive. Karina had never felt anything like this in her life. Not at all the sweet, gentle lover that Mikayla had told her about. Mikayla... Karina's thoughts turned to her friend... but only for a moment. She quickly forgot about Mikayla as AJ brought her closer and closer to orgasm. He bent his head and began to kiss and nip at her neck, sometimes painfully. She could feel his pace quickening, and as he pumped his hot load into her, she felt herself coming also, waves of warmth and pleasure washing over her. His face was still buried in her neck, and he bit her. Hard enough to draw a little blood.
"OUCH!" she yelled. "What the hell? Are you a fucking vampire?" She rubbed her neck.
AJ just smiled as he withdrew from her and took another drink from the whiskey bottle.
Nick had moved off the bed and was sitting in a large, overstuffed chair. She could see that he was completely naked, and completely aroused. He motioned for her to come to him, giving her a lusty look. She slowly crawled off the bed and walked over to him. He pulled her down on his lap and began to kiss her. She straddled him, and lowered herself onto his massive cock, breathing deeply as she did so. She wasn't sure if she could handle him. He placed his hands on her hips and brought her down onto him. As she began to rock her body, Nick's hands on her hips guided her to what felt the best for him. She allowed him to use her... rocking her hips, then moving her up and down... until he dropped his head back and let out a long, low moan. She felt him throbbing inside her, and she knew he was spent.
Karina started laughing as she got off Nick's lap.
"What are you laughing at?" he asked, grabbing her arm.
"I don't know. This is just so ... unreal," she said, pulling her arm away from him and walking back to the bed where AJ had been watching them. He was laying on his back with his hands behind his head, and he was smiling. Karina took the bottle of whiskey from him and turned it up. The alcohol burned as it went down, and she made a face.
Nick flopped down on the bed and took the bottle from her , taking a long drink. She laid down between them and stared up at the ceiling. The room was spinning a little, and her brain was getting fuzzy from the additional alcohol. AJ rolled over on his stomach and smiled an evil smile at her. He started kissing down her shoulder to her arm, then began to run his tongue over her nipples again. The last thing she remembered before passing out was watching AJ position his body between her legs again for another go-round.
*************
The next morning, the phone woke Karina. She opened her eyes, and looked around. She couldn't remember where in the world she was. She rolled over and saw Nick asleep on her left side, and AJ was on her right. The events of the night before came back to her in a flood. She felt her heart sink as she realized everything she had done. She elbowed AJ and woke him up. He opened one eye and looked at her.
"What?" he asked, obviously not ready to get up.
"They phone's ringing," she said quietly. He quickly jumped out of bed and answered the phone.
"Hey baby," AJ said softly. "I miss you, too.... nah, we didn't do much last night. We just had some dinner and watched a movie. Does Lyric miss me?... I miss her so much. ...Kiss her for me, ok?... I know. I'm trying to get some rest. I'll call you tonight, ok? Nick and I are going scuba diving in an hour. Ok, baby. I love you. Bye."
As Karina listened to his conversation, she realized he was talking to Mikayla, and she began to feel twinges of guilt. AJ hung up the phone and walked back to the bed. He kissed Karina's lips, then went into the bathroom.
She felt Nick's hand run up her arm, and she looked down at him. She hadn't realized he was awake. He smiled a sleepy smile, then pulled her down into his arms.
"You look like you're feeling guilty," he said, smiling.
"Well, I guess I am feeling a little guilty," she said, resting her head on his shoulder.
"Don't. Whatever happens here stays here, ok? It's not like I'M going to tell Mikayla that you fucked AJ," he laughed. "God, she'd never forgive you."
"I thought he said she was sleeping with Kevin and Howie?"
"Yeah right. I don't THINK so, Karina. She's given all of us the boot except for AJ. She left us high and dry," he said, sounding a little more than irritated
"So they don't have that "unspoken thing" that he was talking about," Karina asked, feeling sick in the pit of her stomach. Nick slowly shook his head no and smiled a wicked little smile.
Karina covered her face with her hands.
"Oh, what have I done?" she asked herself aloud.
"You have fucked your best friend's fiance," Nick said, laughing. "Whoo what a Jerry Springer episode this would make..."
Karina got up off the bed and went into the bathroom, where AJ was showering. She pulled the shower door open to confront him. She stopped though, when he turned around. He was so... wet. She opened her mouth to speak, but he smiled, and she couldn't get the words out. She was in awe of his body. He reached out and grabbed her hand, pulling her into the shower with him. He covered her mouth with a hard kiss as the hot water coursed over their bodies. His hands roamed freely over her body as he pushed her back against the shower wall. He picked up one of her legs and wrapped it around his hips, then pushed himself inside her. She wrapped her arms around his neck as he pounded away at her. She rested her head on his shoulder, noticing the throbbing vein on the side of his neck. She couldn't resist running her lips over that vein, and he let out a sigh, his head falling back. They came simultaneously, as Karina felt his sticky hotness fill her.
AJ smiled, then got out and wrapped a towel around his waist. Karina got out a few minutes later and walked into the bedroom, a towel around her body. Nick and AJ were already in their swim suits and were getting ready to leave.
"We'll be back later this afternoon," AJ said. "You can stop tonight by if you want."
With that, they grabbed their gear and walked out, leaving Karina alone.
When she returned to her room, her phone was ringing. She answered it quickly.
"Hey girl!" Mikayla said. "I didn't now you were going to the same resort as AJ and Nick!"
"Umm, are they here?" Karina asked, trying to sound convincing.
"OH yeah! AJ needs a vacation, so I sent Nick with him to keep company. He's been drinking too much again, and I'm hoping maybe being down there in that relaxing place will help him dry out."
"Oh, um ok," Karina said, not sure how to respond.
"Keep an eye on those boys," Mikayla laughed. "Sometimes they tend to get into some trouble when they're together."
"Ok, I'll try," Karina said, feeling very uncomfortable talking to her. "Um, Kayla, can I ask you something?"
"Sure babe, what's up?"
"Um, have you been with anybody except AJ since you guys got engaged?" Karina asked carefully.
"Why?" Mikayla laughed.
"Oh, I was just wondering. I know how attached you were to Kevin and all..."
"No, sweetie. That's over. AJ's my one and only now. I don't think I could go back to that lifestyle. He's enough for me, anyway," Mikayla said quietly.
When their conversation ended, Karina sat down and cried. She had betrayed her best friend. But as bad as she felt, she knew she couldn't stay away from AJ...