N.C.A.A. Division I Men's National Champions
Men's Indoor Distance Medley Relay
| Year | School | Athletes | Performance |
| 2011 | Brigham Young | Brian Weirich, Chris Carter, Justin Hedin, Miles Batty | 9:28.28 |
| 2010 | Oregon | AJ Acosta, Chad Barlow, Travis Thompson, Andrew Wheating | 9:36.87 |
| 2009 | Oregon | AJ Acosta, Chad Barlow, Andrew Wheating, Galen Rupp | 9:29.59 |
| 2008 | Texas | Jacob Hernandez, Danzell Fortson, Tevan Everett, Leonel Manzano | 9:32.04 |
| 2007 | Stanford | Garrett Heath, Zach Chandy, Michael Garcia, Russell Brown | 9:33.64 |
| 2006 | Arkansas | Adam Perkins, Jeremy Dodson, Brian Roe, Said Ahmed | 9:37.02 |
| 2005 | Michigan | Rondell Huff, Stan Waithe, Andrew Ellerton, Nate Brannen | 9:30.82 |
| 2004 | Michigan | Nate Brannen, Darnell Talbert, Andrew Ellerton, Nick Willis | 9:27.77 |
| 2003 | Villanova | Ryan Hayden, Nicholas O'Brien, Paul Moser, Adrian Blincoe | 9:29.12 |
| 2002 | Villanova | Ryan Hayden, Michael Brown, Jason Jabaut, Adrian Blincoe | 9:31.00 |
| 2001 | Stanford | Donald Sage, Mark Hassell, Jonathan Stevens, Gabe Jennings | 9:30.01 |
| 2000 | Stanford | Gabe Jennings, Evan Kelly, Michael Stember, Jonathan Riley | 9:28.83 |
| 1999 | UCLA | Jess Strutzel, Brian Fell, Michael Granville, Mark Hauser | 9:33.17 |
| 1998 | Washington State | Eric Kamau, Guillermo Macias, Rasto Kiplanget, Bernard Lagat | 9:29.54 |
| 1997 | George Mason (VA) | Miklos Arpasi, Francis Ogola, O'Neill Duncan, Julius Achon | 9:32.27 |
| 1996 | Nebraska | Miklos Roth, Alex Lamme, Jonah Kiptarus, Balazs Tolgyesi | 9:32.13 |
| 1995 | Michigan | Nick Karfonta, Trinity Townsend, Ian Forsyth, Kevin Sullivan | 9:34.44 |
| 1994 | Arkansas | Niall Bruton, Calvin Davis, Brian Baker, Graham Hood | 9:30.07 |
| 1985 | Wisconsin | Patrick Ames, Robert Hackett, John Easker, Tim Hacker | 9:39.40 |
| 1984 | Eastern Michigan | Joe Codrington, Erik Frederick, Dan Sahmiyeh, Earl Jones | 9:40.18 |
| 1982 | Georgetown | John Pedati, Patrick McCabe, Kevin King, John Gregorek | 9:45.97* |
| 1981 | Villanova | John Borgese, Willie Snydor, Marcus O'Sullivan, Sydney Maree | 9:47.20* |
| 1980 | Villanova | John Hunter, Tim Robinson, Mike England, Sydney Maree | 9:42.22* |
| 1979 | Tennessee | Solomon Hunter, Mike Barlow, Richard Hadler, Keith Young | 9:47.1* |
| 1978 | Brigham Young | Alan Schultz, Kim Coombs, Kevin Hyde, Jay Woods | 9:46.24* |
| 1977 | Texas-El Paso | Fred Ongaga, Paul Njoroge, Frank Munene, James Munyala | 9:43.11* |
| 1976 | Texas-El Paso | Joe Gichongeri, Paul Njoroge, James Munyala, Wilson Waigwa | 9:43.16* |
| 1975 | Kansas State | Jim Hichliffe, Lennie Harrison, Ted Settle, Jeff Schemmel | 9:48.2* |
| 1974 | Missouri | Mike Rabuse, Jim Crawford, Dave Rogles, Charles McMullen | 9:44.9* |
| 1973 | Manhattan | John Lovett, Ray Johnson, JOe Savage, Tony Colon | 9:43.8* |
| 1972 | Bowling Green | Craig MacDonald, Ted Farver, Sid Sink, Dave Wottle | 9:49.5* |
| 1971 | Pittsburgh | Ken Silay, Dorel Watley, Mike Schurko, Jerry Richey | 9:45.7* |
| 1970 | Manhattan | John Lovett, Mike Kenny, Al Novell, Tom Donahue | 9:49.2* |
| 1969 | Villanova | Andy O'Reilly, Ernie Bradshaw, Chris Mason, Frank Murphy | 9:45.8* |
| 1968 | Villanova | Charles Messenger, Bob Whitehead, Tom Donnelly, Frank Murphy | 9:49.5* |
| 1967 | Kansas State | Charles Harper, Terry Holbrook, Wes Dutton, Conrad Nightingale | 9:44.6* |
