Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!
ASSESSMENT RUBRIC FOR PHASE II OF ARCHITECT'S DILEMMA



 
 
 
 
 
 

INDICATORS
 

NOVICE

 

 

APPRENTICE

 

 

PRACTITIONER

 

 

EXPERT

 

SCORE
Individual Design
 
 
 

A completed 
drawing with no description of the original design



 

A completed 
description of the original design with no drawing..
 
 

 An incomplete description of the original design with a completed drawing.

 

 

 A completed drawing with a detailed description of the original design.
0-25
*Team Proposal
Includes at least two of the criteria from the expert category. 

 

Includes a minimum of three of the criteria from the expert category. 

 

Includes a minimum of  four of the criteria from the expert category. 

 

(a) Completed drawing. 
(b) Detailed description of design. 
(c) List of materials. 
(d) Cost analysis. 
(e) Rationale which explains why this proposal is best suited for the project.
0-25
**Team Design

 

Includes at least one of the criteria from the expert category. 
 

 

Includes a minimum of two of the criteria from the expert category. Includes a minimum of three of the criteria from the expert category. (a) Modified drawing to scale based on groups description. 
(b) New cost analysis. 
(c) Material list which conforms to the new budget. 
(d) The project is within the pre-determined budget.
0-25
Completed Building  

Includes at least one of the criteria from the expert category. 

 

Includes a minimum of two to the criteria from the expert category. Includes a minimum of three of the criteria from the expert category. (a) The building reflects the original design. 
(b) The building is free standing. 
(c) Students were creative in the design and construction of the building. 
(d) The building was sturdy. 
0-25

*This proposal is prepared prior to giving the students the pre-determined budget constraints.
**Team design is the modified proposal after students are made aware of the pre-determined budget constraints.
 
 
BACK