Sparky Gets HonestYou love fanfic, right? Can't get enough, not to mention can't get enough time to read it all! So you read at Acacia, TSN and a few recommendations. Where's the #1 place to go for recommendations? Of course it's Sparky's Doghouse! Who knows more about X-F fanfic than Sparky?! Quite possibly no-one! So who's the best to ask about fanfic? It could be no-one other than Sparky herself. So - on with the questions!
Q. For the record, are you a Noromo or Shipper, or do you have leanings towards other pairings? What are your thoughts on the Noromo / Shipper debate?
Regarding the whole Shipper / Noromo debate, part of me finds it extremely
laughable. I've come to the decision that it's a lot like political parties
-- a necessary evil. Every fan wants to make his or her opinion known,
whether through fic or online discussions. And it's an awful lot easier to
align yourself with like-minded individuals -- people who see the show and
the characters the same way you do. It's a way of bonding, it's a way of
arguing, it's a way of proclaiming identity through instant recognition of
opinion.
Again, as in politics, there are bad side effects of such cut-and-dried
alignment, however. I think we all know how nasty the debate can get. What I
think people forget, though, is that MANY readers don't give a whit one way
or the other. They are merely looking for a story that entertains, makes
them think, or gives them a vicarious thrill. To continue the political
analogy, I think of these people as the Independents in a world focused on
Democrats and Republicans -- a largely ignored but important demographic.
;-)
Q. Where do you read fanfic? How much do you estimate you read
a week?
Q. What do you think a likely breakdown of fanfic writers is,
in terms of Shipper / Noromo status, age and gender? Do you think
this changes if you narrow it down to "good" writers (ie more
older Shipper men, less younger Shipper females? I hate to
generalize, but ... )
I consider a Shipper someone who likes the idea of Mulder and Scully
romantically involved. Many of them would like to see it on the show -- some
of them would not, preferring a romantic involvement after the show ends or
in the movies. A smaller number truly love the idea of them together, but
never want to see it, or don't think it would be feasible.
A Noromo, on the other hand, doesn't want Mulder and Scully to get
romantically involved, preferring to see them as a uniquely bound pair of
individuals who have an intense, platonic relationship. Many Noromos like
the banter and UST common in the earlier seasons of the show, and also don't
mind that in fanfic. Heavy UST, though, such as in Season 6, is not as
enjoyable.
Wow! Note the sweeping generalizations! But I had to start somewhere, right?
Now I can get to the questions. :-) I think an overwhelming amount of fanfic
writers are Shippers -- perhaps around 75%. Why? Because an overwhelming
amount of fanfic is written for one purpose only -- as self-fulfilling
fantasy. The fan sitting at home who is dying to see Mulder and Scully in
a relationship is much more motivated to write fanfic -- because they're not
getting the "fix" they crave. The show itself is basically in a Noromo
atmosphere -- therefore the fan who likes the status quo
(relationship-wise), isn't as motivated to write fanfic.
Now -- note that no standards of "quality" are mentioned in the above
paragraph. Yes -- most fanfic being posted is geared toward MSR. But,
honestly speaking -- most fanfic being posted isn't very good. If fanfic
quality were plotted on a graph as the x-axis, and Shipper leanings were
plotted on the y-axis, as quality improved the amount of romance would fall
-- leaving you with a nice graphic of a good ski slope. :-)
Now regarding your question of age, here's where I'm really risking offense.
Fact: A lot of young people (junior high, high school) are writing fanfic.
Most of them I'd have to say are Shippers. (Oh, the optimism of youth! *G*)
How many? There's no way to tell in such an anonymous world. One writer I
swore was barely in high school turned out to be 25; another that I would
have staked my reputation on as being at least in her late 20s has turned
out to be 19.
I think having young writers in the fanfic world is wonderful. In a
perfect world, the fanfic community would be encouraging, helpful, and kind
towards these writers, who are just beginning to experiment with sharing and
writing fiction. However ... we're spoiled. We want to read the good stuff
-- stuff that's written well, that doesn't call out for much critical
commentary. So younger writers, although often unpolished yet extremely
eager for feedback, get ignored. This makes me sad, since I can't highlight
them for the most part. And I'm not sure even if there was someone out there
willing to run a site devoted to new writers (e.g., The Hatchery) that there
would be much of an audience for it.
Now, having said that -- let me state that I've read some marvellous
fiction by writers who are in high school. MSR and otherwise. Fantastic
stuff. I've highlighted talented young writers before at the Doghouse, and I
always will. I've probably highlighted more than I even realize, merely
because there's no true way to know how old someone is. In the end, quality
and talent speak for themselves, age notwithstanding.
The last data breakdown is easier to talk about -- and hopefully less of a
potential hot button. :-) Sex! Here the waters are muddy, and all I can do
is guess. Many screen names are sexually ambiguous, some are downright
deceptive (gender-wise), and no one has to be who they say they are. Once I
accidentally publicly called a writer who goes by "Vehemently" a "he" -- god
knows where I got that from, but Vee is actually a "she." See how hard it
can be? :-) I think there are a smattering of male slash writers, a
smattering of male Shipper writers, and an even larger amount who would
prefer not to be categorized. All in all, though, men are still not drawn to
fanfic in the numbers women are. And the ones who do write tend to be more
talented, on average -- perhaps because they are writers first, not fans
first. Who knows. I'd love to hear comments from male writers on this topic,
though.
Q. Any Noromo authors or specific stories you highly recommend?
Q. What are some generalizations you would make about Shippers
and Noromos?
Q. Who are some of your favourite authors?
Shipper or Heavy UST:
Slash:
Can't Pin 'Em Down:
Please note that these are my favorites, not Doghouse favorites. Names
mean nothing at Sparky's Doghouse -- quality is the only deciding factor.
I will never recommend a story just because I happen to like the writer.
Q. Any other comments on fanfic?
Q. Any other comments in general ...
Well! That just about says it all, doesn't it?! MANY MANY thanks to Sparky for taking the time out of her very busy scehdule to do this for me! I for one found it to be very helpful. I trust you will all take her advice and send FEEDBACK now! I got most of the author links from this page. Of course, the Doghouse - you want to read some quality fanfic, then this place is absolutely guaranteed! Sparky's Doghouse - http://members.xoom.com/The_Doghouse/newweek.html NOROMO VALUES by Brianna L (noromo_values@start.com.au). Let me know if something looks wrong, or if you have comments, critisism, praise, suggestions. Not in frames but table-heavy so Netscapers, tread lightly. Sitemap, disclaimer. Spoiler free for Australian teev. Lawyers and Shippers, fuck off, everyone else, enjoy. Visited link ... ... ... Unvisited link. |