1. "Noah and Stagecoach Sally" (Melissa)
2. "Free Slaves" (That's what Noah was doing) (Alli)
1. "Rachel and Lou" (Melissa)
2. "Rachel" (Alli)
1. "Jimmy's Imposter" (Melissa)
2. "Wannabe Jimmy Hickok/Cody & the Spirits" (Shelley)
1. "Cholera Epidemic" (Melissa)
2. "Plague" (Joanna)
3. "Cholera" (Shelley)
1. "Indian Captives" (Melissa)
2. "Thompkins' Kin" (Jackie)
1. "Ike and the Little Boy" (Melissa)
2. "Ike's Dream with a little boy" (Shelley)
1. "Kid and the Crooked Sheriff" (Melissa)
2. "No Reason Hanging - Mystery" (Beth)
3. "Kid's trouble with Lambret" (Shelley)
1. "Kid and Lou" (Melissa)
2. "Cody's Hero" (Beth)
3. "Kid & Lou: Together at Last!" (Shelley)
4. "Hezikia Horn" (Jackie)
1. "Jimmy Kills a Woman" (Melissa)
2. "Sh*t Town" (Ann)
3. "Jimmy Shoots Woman" (Shelley)
4. "Jimmy Takes on the Badge" (Kristin)
1. "Christmas" (Melissa)
2. "Christmas Show w/tennis" (Shelley)
3. "Gold Fever" (Beth)
4. "Christmas" (Kristin)
1. "Cody Acts" (Melissa)
2. "Cody's Theater" (Shelley)
3. "Herrick Traveling Theatrical Company" (Kristin)
1. "Cody and the Bounty Hunters" (Melissa)
2. "Bride w/ 7 Husbands" (Shelley)
3. "Gideon the Avenger" (Kristin)
1. "Noah and the Slaves" (Melissa)
2. "The Silver Saddle" (Kristin)
3. "Noah's Teacher" (Shelley)
1. "Jimmy and the Peacemakers" (Melissa)
2. "Jimmy & the Peacemakers" (Shelley)
1. "A Girl Named Trouble" (Melissa)
2. "Kid & Lou Break Up" (Shelley)
1. "Kid and the Schoolteacher" (Melissa)
2. "Lou & Jimmy--Night on the Town" (Shelley)
3. "Kid & Black Woman - Lou & Jimmy" (Beth)
1. "Ike's Revenge" (Melissa)
2. "Karl Shaddock alias Ben Rawlings" (Kristin)
3. "Ike wants Revenge/Camel monster" (Shelley)
1. "The Mission" (Melissa)
1. "The Bank Robber & The Bounty Hunter" (Melissa)
1. "Buck and the Ambush" (Melissa)
1. "The Exchange Part 1" - got this one right! (Melissa)
2. "The Kangaroo Kid Part 1" (Ann)
3. "Kangaroo Kid" (Joanna)
4. "Kangaroo Kid & Amanda" (Kristin)
1. "The Exchange Part 2" - got this one right (Melissa)
2. "The Kangaroo Kid Part 2" (Ann)
3. "Kangaroo Kid rides again..and again" (Joanna)
4. "Kangaroo Kid & Amanda" (Kristin)