| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | El Mesias | Chessman* | Guadalajara, Mexico | 9/16/07 |
| 2. | Cibernetico | El Mesias | Moterrey, Mexico | 3/16/08 |
| 3. | El Mesias | El Zorro*(2) | Orizaba, Mexico | 12/6/08 |
| 4. | Dr. Wagner Jr. | El Mesias | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/13/09 |
| 5. | El Mesias | Dr. Wagner Jr. | Ciudad Madero, Mexico | 12/11/09 |
| 6. | Electroshock | El Mesias and Mr. Anderson*(3) | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/12/10 |
| 7. | Dr. Wagner Jr. | Electroshock | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/6/10 |
| 8. | El Zorro | Dr. Wagner Jr. | Zapopan, Mexico | 12/5/10 |
| 9. | Jeff Jarrett | El Zorro | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/18/11 |
| 10. | El Mesias | Jeff Jarrett | Zapopan, Mexico | 3/18/12 |
| 11. | El Texano Jr. | El Mesias | Zapopan, Mexico | 12/2/12 |
| 12. | El Patron Alberto | El Texicano Jr. | Zapopan, Mexico | 12/7/14 |
| 13. | El Texano Jr. | El Mesias*(4) | San Luis Potosi, Mexico | 3/23/16 |
| 14. | Johnny Mundo | El Texano Jr. and El Hijo del Phantasma*(5) | Monterrey, Mexico | 3/19/17 |
| 15. | Rey Wagner | Johnny Mundo | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/26/18 |
| 16. | Jeff Jarrett | Rey Wagner and Rey Mysterio Jr.*(6) | Monterrey, Mexico | 6/3/18 |
| 17. | Fenix | Jeff Jarrett, Brian Cage and Rich Swann*(7) | Mexico City, Mexico | 8/25/18 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
*(2)The title was vacated when Cibernetico left AAA. This was a Ladder Match for the vacant title.
*(3)This was a Three Way Match.
*(4)The title was vacated when Patron left the company. This match determined the new champion.
*(5)This was a Three Way Match.
*(6)This was a Three Way Match.
*(7)This was a Four Way Match.