| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Pac | Clark Connors, Malakai Black, and Miro | Chicago, IL | 6/26/22 |
| 2. | Orange Cassidy | Pac | Toronto, ON | 10/12/22 |
| 3. | Jon Moxley | Orange Cassidy | Chicago, IL | 9/3/23 |
| 4. | Rey Fenix | Jon Moxley | Queens, NY | 9/20/23 |
| 5. | Orange Cassidy | Rey Fenix | Independence, MO | 10/10/23 |
| 6. | Roderick Strong | Orange Cassidy | Greensboro, NC | 3/3/24 |
*This was a four-way tournament final to crown the first champion.