| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Cody Rhodes | Lance Archer* | Jacksonville, FL | 5/23/20 |
| 2. | Brodie Lee | Cody Rhodes | Jacksonville, FL | 8/22/20 |
| 3. | Cody Rhodes | Brodie Lee | Jacksonville, FL | 10/7/20 |
| 4. | Darby Allin | Cody Rhodes | Jacksonville, FL | 11/8/20 |
| 5. | Miro | Darby Allin | Jacksonville, FL | 5/12/21 |
| 6. | Sammy Guevara | Miro | Rochester, NY | 9/29/21 |
| 7. | Cody Rhodes | Sammy Guevara | Greensboro, NC | 12/22/21 |
| 8. | Sammy Guevara | Dustin Rhodes** | Charlotte, NC | 1/8/22 |
| 9. | Scorpio Sky | Sammy Guevara | Estero, FL | 3/9/22 |
| 10. | Sammy Guevara | Scorpio Sky | Garland, TX | 4/15/22 |
| 11. | Scorpio Sky | Sammy Guevara | Philadelphia, PA | 4/27/22 |
| 12. | Wardlow | Scorpio Sky | Rochester, NY | 7/6/22 |
| 13. | Samoa Joe | Wardlow and Powerhouse Hobbs*** | Newark, NJ | 11/19/22 |
| 14. | Darby Allin | Samoa Joe | Seattle, WA | 1/4/23 |
| 15. | Samoa Joe | Darby Allin | Dayton, OH | 2/1/23 |
| 16. | Wardlow | Samoa Joe | San Francisco, CA | 3/5/23 |
| 17. | Powerhouse Hobbs | Wardlow | Sacramento, CA | 3/8/23 |
| 18. | Wardlow | Powerhouse Hobbs | Pittsburgh, PA | 4/19/23 |
| 19. | Luchasaurus | Wardlow | Chicago, IL | 6/17/23 |
| 20. | Christian Cage | Luchasaurus and Darby Allin**** | Grand Rapids, MI | 9/23/23 |
| 21. | Adam Copeland | Christian Cage | Uniondale, NY | 12/30/23 |
| 22. | Christian Cage | Adam Copeland | Uniondale, NY | 12/30/23 |
| 23. | Adam Copeland | Christian Cage | Toronto, ON | 3/20/24 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
**Cody Rhodes was sick and unable to make a scheduled title defense against Guevara, who instead defeated his brother Dustin to become the interim champion. A few weeks later, he defeated Cody in a Ladder Match to become the undisputed title holder.
***This was a Three Way Match.
****This was a Three Way Match.
Title Defenses
1. Cody Rhodes
---pinned Jungle Boy, Dynamite: 6/3/20
---pinned Ricky Starks, Dynamite: 6/17/20
---pinned Jake Hager, Fyter Fest: 7/1/20
---submitted Eddie Kingston, Dynamite: 7/22/20
---submitted Warhorse, Dynamite: 7/29/20
2. Brodie Lee
---pinned Orange Cassidy, Dynamite: 9/23/20
3. Cody Rhodes
---time limit draw against Orange Cassidy, Dynamite: 10/14/20
---beat Orange Cassidy in a Lumberjack Match, Dynamite: 10/28/20
4. Darby Allin
---pinned Brian Cage, Dynamite: 1/13/21
---pinned Joey Janela, Dynamite: 2/10/21
---pinned John Silver, Dynamite: 3/24/21
---pinned Jungle Boy, Dynamite: 4/21/21
---pinned 10, Dynamite: 4/28/21
5. Miro
---pinned Dante Martin, Dynamite: 5/28/21
---submitted Lance Archer, Double or Nothing: 5/30/21
---submitted Evil Uno, Dynamite: 6/11/21
---pinned Brian Pillman Jr., Dynamite: 6/30/21