| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Riho | Nyla Rose* | Washington, D.C. | 10/2/19 |
| 2. | Nyla Rose | Riho | Cedar Park, TX | 2/12/20 |
| 3. | Hikaru Shida | Nyla Rose | Jacksonville, FL | 5/23/20 |
| 4. | Britt Baker | Hikaru Shida | Jacksonville, FL | 5/30/21 |
| 5. | Thunder Rosa | Britt Baker | San Antonio, TX | 3/16/22 |
| 6. | Toni Storm | Britt Baker, Jamie Hayter and Hikaru Shida** | Chicago, IL | 9/4/22 |
| 7. | Jamie Hayter | Toni Storm | Newark, NJ | 11/19/22 |
| 8. | Toni Storm | Jamie Hayter | Paradise, NV | 5/28/23 |
| 9. | Hikaru Shida | Toni Storm | Tampa, FL | 8/2/23 |
| 10. | Saraya | Hikaru Shida, Britt Baker, and Toni Storm*** | London, England | 8/27/23 |
| 11. | Hikaru Shida | Saraya | Independence, MO | 10/10/23 |
| 12. | Toni Storm | Hikaru Shida | Inglewood, CA | 11/18/23 |
*Rose won a Casino Battle Royale to earn her way into the inaugural title match, while Riho was able to defeat Hikaru Shida to earn her spot. This match determined the first champion.
**Rosa was put out due to injury, and Storm became Interim Champion by winning a Four Way Match. Eventually Rosa decided to relinquish the belt, and all interim reigns were made official.
***This was a Four Way Match.
Title Defenses
1. Riho
---pinned Dr. Britt Baker, Dynamite: 10/16/19
---pinned Emi Sakura, Full Gear: 11/9/19
---beat Nyla Rose, Dr. Britt Baker and Hikaru Shida in a Four Way Match, Dynamite: 1/1/20
2. Nyla Rose
---pinned Kris Statlander, Revolution: 2/29/20
3. Hikaru Shida
---pinned Penelope Ford, Fyter Fest: 7/1/20
---pinned Thunder Rosa, All Out: 9/5/20
---pinned Big Swole, Dynamite: 10/14/20
---pinned Nyla Rose, Full Gear: 11/8/20
---pinned Anna Jay, Dynamite: 11/25/20
---pinned Abadon, Dynamite: 1/6/21
---pinned Ryo Mizunami, Revolution: 3/7/21
---pinned Tay Conti, Dynamite: 4/21/21
4. Britt Baker
---submitted Nyla Rose, Fyter Fest: 7/21/21