| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Chris Hero & Claudio Castagnoli (The Kings of Wrestling) | Milano Collection AT & Skayde* | Philadelphia, PA | 2/26/06 |
| 2. | Gran Akuma & Icarus (Team FIST) | The Kings of Wrestling | Reading, PA | 11/17/06 |
| 3. | Delirious & Hallowicked (Incoherence) | Team FIST | Reading, PA | 10/26/07 |
| 4. | Player Uno & Player Dos (The Super Smash Bros.) | Incoherence | Cleveland, OH | 9/21/08 |
| 5. | Amasis & Ophidian (The Osirian Portal) | The Super Smash Bros. | Philadelphia, PA | 10/19/08 |
| 6. | Fire Ant & Soldier Ant (The Colony) | The Osirian Portal | Nashua, NH | 9/13/09 |
| 7. | Ares & Claudio Castagnoli (Bruderschaft de Kreuzes) | The Colony | Easton, PA | 3/20/10 |
| 8. | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | Bruderschaft de Kreuzes | Reading, PA | 12/12/10 |
| 9. | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano (FIST) | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | New York, NY | 9/18/11 |
| 10. | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews (3.0) | FIST | Vaughan, ON | 3/24/12 |
| 11. | FIST | 3.0 | Lafayette, IN | 4/29/12 |
| 12. | Nick & Matt Jackson (The Young Bucks) | FIST | Philadelphia, PN | 6/2/12 |
| 13. | 3.0 | The Young Bucks | Easton, PA | 2/10/13 |
| 14. | Jigsaw & The Shard (Pieces of Hate) | 3.0 | Philadelphia, PA | 6/2/13 |
| 15. | Dasher Hatfield & Mark Angelosetti (The Throwbacks) | Pieces of Hate | Revere, MA | 7/20/14 |
| 16. | Blaster McMassive & Max Smashmaster (The Devastation Corporation) | The Throwbacks | Philadelphia, PA | 12/6/14 |
| 17. | Hype Rockwell & Race Jaxon (N_R_G) | The Devastation Corporation | Norfolk, VA | 9/27/15 |
| 18. | Ice Cream Jr. & El Hijo del Ice Cream (Los Ice Creams) | N_R_G | Toronto, ON | 7/23/16 |
| 19. | Tyler Bate & Trent Seven (Moustache Mountain) | The Devastation Corporation, Los Ice Creams and N_R_G** | Philadelphia, PA | 8/21/16 |
| 20. | Cornelius Crummels & Sonny Defarge | Rick Roland & Sloan Caprice (The Closers) and Mark Angelosetti & Dasher Hatfield (The Throwbacks)*** | Philadelphia, PA | 12/29/16 |
| 21. | Solo Darling & Travis Huckabee (The Rumblebees) | Cornelius Crummel & Sonny Defarge | Gibsonville, NC | 7/8/17 |
| 22. | Los Ice Creams | The Rumblebees | Gibsonville, NC | 7/8/17 |
| 23. | The Closers | Los Ice Creams | Philadelphia, PA | 2/17/18 |
| 24. | Princess KimberLee & The Whisper | The Closers | Philadelphia, PA | 12/8/18 |
| 25. | Tony Deppen & Travis Huckabee (FIST) | Princess KimberLee & The Whisper | Pocono Summit, PA | 4/27/19 |
| 26. | Solo Darling & Willow Nightingale (The Bird and the Bee) | FIST | Philadelphia, PA | 11/19/19 |
*This was the finals of the Tag World Grand Prix to determine the first Campeonatos de Parejas.
**The titles were vacated due to an error by the referee when he declared Los Ice Creams the winners of their title match even though they only won the first fall. This was a double elimination four-way match to determine new champions.
***The titles were vacated due to Season 17 being taped in secret. This was a Three-Way Match to determine the new champions.
Title Defenses:
1. The Kings of Wrestling
---lost to Delirious & Hallowicked by DQ, Sand in the Vaseline: 4/21/06
---pinned MIYAWAKI & Yoshiaki Yago, Aniversario Epsilon: 5/27/06
---pinned Darin Corbin & Ryan Cruz, Once in a Lifetime: 9/22/06
2. FIST
---pinned Jigsaw & Shane Storm, Best Imitation of Myself: 3/23/07
---pinned Cheech & Cloudy, Rey de Voladores: 4/22/07
---pinned Ice Cream Jr. & El Hijo del Ice Cream, Here Come the International Invaders - 1st Stage - Attack of the Phantom Sith: 8/17/07
3. Incoherence
---pinned Cheech & Cloudy, The Sordid Perils of Everyday Existence: 11/17/07
---pinned Icarus & Gran Akuma, Passion and Persistence: 4/20/08
---pinned Ophidian & Amasis, Grit and Glory: 5/18/08
---pinned Mitch Ryder & Buck Hawke, Triumph and Tragedy: 7/13/08
---pinned Tim Donst & Hydra, All That Glitters: 8/9/08
4. The Super Smash Bros.
---N/A
5. The Osirian Portal
---submitted Equinox & Lince Dorado, Armdrags to Riches: 11/16/08
---submitted Fire Ant & Soldier Ant, Revelation X: 1/25/09
---pinned Mike Quackenbush & Jigsaw, Behind the 8 Ball: 4/25/09
6. The Colony
---pinned Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood, An Optimistic View of a Pessimistic World: 10/17/09
---pinned Ophidian & Amasis, Three-Fisted Tales: 11/22/09
---pinned Icarus & Gran Akuma, A Touch of Class: 1/31/10
---pinned UltraMantis Black & Delirious, A World of Comforting Illusions: 2/28/10
7. Bruderschaft de Kreuzes
---pinned Hallowicked & Frightmare, Aniversario Elf: 5/23/10
---pinned Equinox & Helios, Faded Scars and Lines: 6/27/10
---submitted Scott Parker & Shane Matthews, Eye to Eye: 9/18/10
---pinned Ophidian & Amasis, Terror in the Neighborhood: 10/24/10
8. Mike Quackenbush & Jigsaw
---pinned Obariyon & Kodama, Caught in a Cauldron of Hate: 2/19/11
---pinned Fire Ant & Soldier Ant, Creatures from the Tar Swamp: 3/13/11
9. FIST
---pinned Atsushi Kotoge & Daisuke Harada, Small But Mighty: 10/7/11
---pinned Sugar Dunkerton & Dasher Hatfield, Maiden Flight of the Great Condor: 10/30/11
---submitted Soldier Ant & Fire Ant, JoshiMania - Night 1: 12/2/11
---pinned UltraMantis Black & Hallowicked, A Death Worse Than Fate: 2/25/12
10. 3.0
---N/A
11. FIST
---N/A
12. The Young Bucks
---pinned Dasher Hatfield & Mark Angelosetti, Give 'em the Axe: 7/29/12
---pinned UltraMantis Black & Hallowicked, Zelda the Great: 11/10/12
---pinned Marty Jannetty & The 1-2-3 Kid, Under the Hood: 12/2/12
13. 3.0
---pinned Blaster McMassive & Max Smashmaster, Just Shadows in the Fog: 3/8/13
---pinned Obariyon & Kodama, The Ghost of You Clings: 5/4/13
14. Pieces of Hate
---pinned Arik Cannon & Darin Corbin, Quantum of Solace: 6/21/14
---pinned Amasis & Ophidian, The Living Daylights: 7/19/14
15. The Throwbacks
---pinned Shane Matthews & Scott Parker, For Your Eyes Only: 11/16/14
16. The Devastation Corporation
---pinned Amasis & Ophidian, Out on a Limb: 3/7/15
---pinned Hype Rockwell & Race Jaxon, Pier Pressure: 4/5/15
---pinned Jervis Cottonbelly & Princess KimberLee, Storming the Castle: 7/25/15
17. N_R_G
---pinned Drake Carter & Shaun Cannon, Babylon Springs: 11/8/15
---pinned Frightmare & Hallowicked, Days of the Phoenix: 1/30/16
---pinned Lucas Calhoun & Missile Assault Man, The New Batch: 3/19/16
18. Los Ice Creams
---N/A
19. Moustache Mountain
---N/A
20. Cornelius Crummels & Sonny Defarge
---pinned Officer Bruno Meloni & Officer Warren Barksdale, Blink: 3/4/17
---pinned Chuck Taylor & DUSTIN, Turn Left: 3/31/17
---pinned Donald Kluger & Jasper Tippins, Aniversario - School Reunion: 5/27/17
21. The Rumblebees
---N/A
22. Los Ice Creams
---N/A
23. The Closers
---pinned Dasher Hatfield & Mark Angelosetti, Revenge of the Lawn Gnomes: 4/28/18
---pinned Nytehawk & Razerhawk, The Infinite Gauntlet: 5/5/18
---pinned Oleg the Usurper & The Proletariat Boar of Moldova, Piano Lessons Can Be Murder: 10/13/18
24. Princess KimberLee & The Whisper
---pinned Cornelius Crummels & Sonny Defarge, National Pro Wrestling Day: 2/10/19
25. FIST
---pinned Lucas Calhoun & Stray Kat, Chikarasaurus Rex: 9/7/19
26. The Bird and the Bee
---N/A