| No. | Won By | Won From | Tourney | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Hallowicked | Mister ZERO | I | Allentown, PA | 11/16/02 |
| 2. | Larry Sweeney | Jigsaw | II | Emmaus, PA | 7/31/04 |
| 3. | Jigsaw | Larry Sweeney | --- | Reading, PA | 11/19/04 |
| 4. | Shane Storm | Icarus | III | Pittston, PA | 7/24/05 |
| 5. | Arik Cannon | Cheech | IV | Philadelphia, PA | 6/25/06 |
| 6. | Maxime Boyer | Arik Cannon | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 10/28/06 |
| 7. | Chuck Taylor | Ricochet | V | Hellertown, PA | 6/24/07 |
| 8. | Helios | Chuck Taylor | --- | Barnesville, PA | 10/27/07 |
| 9. | Fire Ant | Vin Gerard | VI | Hellertown, PA | 6/15/08 |
| 10. | Vin Gerard | Fire Ant | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 7/13/08 |
| 11. | Jimmy Olsen | Vin Gerard* | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 1/25/09 |
| 12. | Player Dos | Colin Delaney | VII | Philadelphia, PA | 8/19/09 |
| 13. | Tim Donst | Player Dos | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 1/31/10 |
| 14. | Frightmare | Lince Dorado | VIII | Reading, PA | 8/29/10 |
| 15. | Tadasuke | Green Ant | IX | Easton, PA | 8/27/11 |
| 16. | Mark Angelosetti | ACH | X | Indianapolis, IN | 8/18/12 |
| 17. | Heidi Lovelace | Missile Assault Ant | XI | Philadelphia, PA | 12/6/14 |
| 18. | The Estonian ThunderFrog | Wani | XII | Reading, PA | 2/6/16 |
| 19. | Space Monkey | The Whisper | XIII | Philadelphia, PA | 2/4/17 |
| 20. | Wani | Space Monkey | --- | Fern Park, FL | 4/1/17 |
| 21. | Sylverhawk | Wani | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 6/4/17 |
| 22. | Hermit Crab | Sylverhawk | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 6/18/17 |
| 23. | Razerhawk | Hermit Crab | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 7/13/17 |
| 24. | Ophidian II | Razerhawk | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 10/15/17 |
| 25. | Cam Zagani | Omari | XIV | Philadelphia, PA | 3/31/18 |
| 26. | Danjerhawk | Cam Zagani | --- | Philadelphia, PA | 7/14/18 |
| 27. | Still Life with Apricots and Pears | Boomer Hatfield | XV | Philadelphia, PA | 3/16/19 |
| 28. | Ricky South | Green Ant | XVI | Philadelphia, PA | 1/18/20 |
*The title was declared vacant due to a double disqualification in a title match between Gerard and Olsen. This was a Ladder Match for the vacant cup.
Title Defenses:
1. Hallowicked
---pinned Gran Akuma, Twelfth Show: 12/7/02
---pinned Icarus, Seventeenth Show: 4/12/03
2. Larry Sweeney
---N/A
3. Jigsaw
---beat Chris Hero by DQ, Grape American Bash: 4/17/05
4. Shane Storm
---pinned Icarus, Son of the International Invasion of the International Invaders - Stage 1: 9/16/05
---pinned Crossbones, Sand in the Vaseline: 4/21/06
5. Arik Cannon
---pinned Jon Moxley, The Crushing Weight of Mainstream Ignorance: 7/22/06
---pinned Lance Steel, Once in a Lifetime: 9/22/06
6. Maxime Boyer
---pinned Soldier Ant, Best Imitation of Myself: 3/23/07
7. Chuck Taylor
---pinned Drake Younger, Maximum Overdraft: 8/5/07
---pinned Ricochet, Here Come the International Invaders - 2nd Stage – Revenge of the Clone Menace
8. Helios
---pinned Hydra, Battle of Who Could Care Less: 11/16/07
---pinned Fire Ant, The Sordid Perils of Everyday Existence: 11/17/07
---pinned Lince Dorado, Deuces Wild: 4/19/08
9. Fire Ant
---N/A
10. Vin Gerard
---beat Drake Younger by DQ, Vanity and Violence: 8/10/08
---submitted Fire Ant, The Artistic Pursuit of Being Yourself: 9/20/08
---submitted Worker Ant, Armdrags to Riches: 11/16/08
---no contest against Equinox, Duel and Duality: 12/14/08
11. Jimmy Olsen
---pinned Amasis, Motive, Means, Opportunity: 2/21/09
---pinned Colin Delaney, Behind the 8-Ball: 4/25/09
12. Player Dos
---pinned Player Uno, Hiding in Plain Sight: 9/13/09
---pinned Frightmare, An Optimistic View of a Pessimistic World: 10/17/09
---pinned Lince Dorado, Three-Fisted Tales: 11/22/09
13. Tim Donst
---pinned Player Uno, The Mint Condition: 2/27/10
---pinned Dasher Hatfield, Wit, Verve and a Bit o' Nerve: 3/20/10
---submitted Soldier Ant, Aniversario Elf: 5/23/10
---submitted Frightmare, We Must Eat Michigan's Brain: 6/26/10
14. Frightmare
---pinned Pinkie Sanchez, Through Savage Progress Cuts the Jungle Line: 9/19/10
---pinned Johnny Gargano, The Dark Ciberknetico: 10/23/10
---pinned Lince Dorado, Scornucopia: 11/20/10
---pinned Johnny Gargano, The Germans: 11/21/10
---pinned Rich Swann, Caught in a Cauldron of Hate: 2/19/11
---pinned Obariyon, Creatures from the Tar Swamp: 3/13/11
---pinned Kodama, The Evil That Lies Within - Part 4: 6/26/11
15. Tadasuke
---N/A
16. Mark Angelosetti
---pinned Green Ant, Deep Freeze: 10/6/12
---pinned ACH, Under the Hood: 12/2/12
---pinned Saturyne, While the Dawn is Breaking: 2/10/13
---pinned Jakob Hammermeier, Just Shadows in the Fog: 3/8/13
---pinned Chiva Kid, Battle Not With Monsters: 5/3/13
---pinned Saturyne, Never Compromise: 6/2/13
17. Heidi Lovelace
---pinned Argus, Shock and Aww: 6/14/15
---pinned The Proletariat Boar of Moldova, King of Trios - Night 3: 9/6/15
18. The Estonian ThunderFrog
---pinned The Proletariat Bear of Moldova, Dead Man's Chest: 2/27/16
---pinned Arctic Rescue Ant, Disk: 4/2/16
---pinned Hermit Crab, Counting Backwards: 11/5/16
19. Space Monkey
---N/A
20. Wani
---N/A
21. Sylverhawk
---pinned Cornelius Crummels, Hide: 6/10/17
22. Hermit Crab
---pinned Cajun Crawdad, The Lodger: 7/8/17
23. Razerhawk
---pinned Everett Connors, Chikarasaurus Rex - Flesh and Stone: 8/5/17
24. Ophidian II/The Whisper
---pinned Officer Warren Barksdale, Dark Water: 11/18/17
---pinned Tony Deppen, National Pro Wrestling Day: 2/17/18
25. Cam Zagami
---pinned Green Ant, Beyond All Day: 5/27/18
26. Danjerhawk
---pinned Sage Phillips, Chikarasaurus Rex - A Deadly Secret: 8/11/18
---pinned Cornelius Crummels, Hour of Power: 8/18/18
---pinned Still Life with Apricots and Pears, La Loteria Letal: 10/27/18
27. Still Life with Apricots and Pears
---pinned Carlos Romo, Once Upon a Beginning: 4/5/19
---pinned Brayden Lee, Fright Knight: 4/27/19
---pinned Thief Ant, The Infinite Gauntlet: 5/11/19
---pinned Green Ant, Aniversario - The Apes of Wrath: 5/25/19
---pinned Breaux Keller, Live at FNB Field: 6/6/19
---pinned Boomer Hatfield, Summer Night City: 6/7/19
---pinned Cajun Crawdad, Live at Frawley Stadium: 6/8/19
---pinned Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Live at Clipper Magazine Stadium: 7/6/19
---pinned Stray Kat, Live at Coca-Cola Park: 8/8/19
---pinned Boom Harden, Live at Regency Furniture Stadium: 8/31/19
28. Ricky South
---N/A